The recent image of a possible planet around the star GQ Lupi has met with understandable enthusiasm in the press, but we still don't know whether the small object just to the right of the star in the image below is a planet or a brown dwarf. The boundary between brown dwarf and planet is tricky terrain, but the European Southern Observatory fixes it at roughly 13 Jupiter masses, which is the critical mass needed to ignite deuterium. Brown dwarfs, then, are objects heavier than that. But the observations of Ralph Neuhäuser and colleagues do not provide a direct estimate of the smaller object's mass. Because GQ Lupi and its companion presumably formed at the same time, then the new object is young, and traditional models for such calculations may not apply. But using them, according to a press release from the ESO, implies that the object is somewhere between 3 and 42 Jupiter masses. In other words, based on what we can determine so far, GQ Lupi b is either a planet or a brown dwarf....
Emergence of the ‘Dark Energy Star’
"It's a near certainty that black holes don't exist," says George Chapline. A physicist at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Chapline has an alternative explanation: when a massive star collapses, what remains is not a black hole but a star that's filled with dark energy. Some 70 percent of the universe seems to be composed of dark energy, though no one knows precisely what it is. Chapline's work may lead to new insights into the stuff. A preprint of Chapline's paper "Dark Energy Stars" appears at the ArXiv site, where the author lays down the gauntlet early on: In the 1950s a consensus was reached, partly as a result of meetings such as a famous meeting at Chapel Hill in 1957, that although quantum effects might be important below some very small distance, on any macroscopic scale the predictions of classical general relativity (GR) should be taken seriously. In the summer of 2000 Bob Laughlin and I realized that this cannot possibly be correct. Indeed I am sure it will be...
Gamma-Ray Bursts May Have Caused Species Extinction
Centauri Dreams continues to maintain that a major justification for interstellar research is the need of our species to protect itself. The record of life on earth is studded with extinction-level events evidently caused by asteroid or cometary impacts, and as technology matures, the danger of a man-made catastrophe cannot be ruled out. We know that life is fragile, as is underscored by the following story. According to a new study from NASA and the University of Kansas, working with 'what if' scenarios and a finely-tuned model of Earth's atmosphere, a gamma-ray burst from the explosion of a relatively nearby star could destroy up to half the atmosphere's ozone layer. Remarkably, a burst that hit the Earth for only ten seconds could do the trick, damaging Earth's only shield against powerful ultraviolet radiation from the Sun. With recovery time of no less than five years, that could have catastrophic effect on all surface species and destroy the food chain. "A gamma-ray burst...
Sedna’s Missing Moon Explained
The mystery of Sedna's spin seems to be solved. The enigmatic Kuiper Belt object whose orbit reaches as far as 500 AU from the Sun (and as close as 80) appeared to have an unusually slow rotation rate when first observed. Some astronomers speculated that an unseen moon could be the cause, even though the best Hubble images showed no such object. It has taken a set of new measurements by Scott Gaudi, Krzysztof Stanek and colleagues at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (CfA) to solve the mystery. Sedna's rotation period isn't the previously thought 20 days, but ten hours, which is consistent with other planetoids in the Solar System. The need for the missing moon has vanished. Not that Sedna doesn't remain unusual. In addition to its highly elliptical orbit, the planetoid is one of the largest Kuiper Belt objects known, three-quarters the size of Pluto, or about 1,000 miles across. Another oddity: Sedna's ruddy color, which remains unexplained. Image: CfA astronomer Scott...
New Earths Awaiting Discovery
The planetary systems so far discovered around other stars have generally been dominated by huge, gas giant worlds, many with so-called 'hot Jupiters' that orbit extremely close to their parent star. And that makes sense, given that a major method used for detecting exoplanets relies upon the star's 'wobble' as it is influenced by such high-mass objects. We're not yet at the point where Earth-sized planets can be found, although we've reduced the detection size down to Neptune-class objects, with better things to come. But don't assume that even the systems discovered so far are without terrestrial planets. As many as half of them may harbor habitable worlds, according to work by Barrie Jones, Nick Sleep, and David Underwood at the Open University in Milton Keynes (UK), which was presented today at the Royal Astronomical Society National Astronomy Meeting in Birmingham. The team used computer models to analyze the gravitational effects of known exoplanets on other, undiscovered...
Laser Propulsion to Orbit?
When Freeman Dyson recently addressed Flight School (a part of the PC Forum technology conference held in Scottsdale AZ in March), he cited one key driver for getting people into space in a big way: propulsion. "What you need," Dyson said, "is a launch system that stays on the ground." A case in point that Dyson favors is laser propulsion, as exemplified in the 'lightcraft' concept of Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute's Leik Myrabo. Back in October of 2000, a small test model of Myrabo's design rose to a height of 233 feet, powered by a 10-KW pulsed carbon dioxide laser. Beamed energy means that future, full-scale versions of such technology will need only a small amount of on-board propellant, sharply reducing the mass of the vehicle. The lightcraft models created so far reflect the laser beam from a parabolic mirror on the underside of the vehicle to superheat air to a temperature roughly ten times that of the surface of the Sun. The air explodes and propels the craft into motion,...
Doubts About GQ Lupi
Sky & Telescope is reporting that the purported planet around GQ Lupi may not be a planet but a brown dwarf. The magazine evidently draws this conclusion from a study of the paper by Ralph Neuhaeuser and colleagues that is to run in an upcoming issue of Astronomy & Astrophysics. "The newly released paper by Neuhauser and his colleagues suggests that the the object in question could be as much as 42 Jupiter masses. Brown dwarfs are, by definition, between 13 and 74 Jupiter masses," the magazine reports. Meanwhile, data on the possible GQ Lupi planet can be found at the Extrasolar Planets Encyclopedia. The preprint of the Neuhaeuser paper, "Evidence for a co-moving sub-stellar companion of GQ Lup," is available here. A key excerpt from the paper: The most critical point in the mass determination of the companion (candidates) of GQ Lup and 2M1207 are the models, which may be off by an unknown factor for low ages (few Myrs); they need to be calibrated, before the mass of such companions...
Image of an Extrasolar World?
Space.com is reporting that a European team led by Ralph Neuhaeuser of the Astrophysical Institute & University Observatory has obtained a photograph of an extrasolar planet around GQ Lupi, a young star about 400 light years from Earth. The image shows a faint object the team believes to orbit some 100 AU from its parent star, an apparently young and hot planet. From the article: The planet is about 3,140 degrees Fahrenheit (2000 Kelvin) -- not the sort of place that would be expected to support life. Neuhaeuser's team has also detected water in the planet's atmosphere. The world is expected to be gaseous, like Jupiter. It is about twice the diameter of Jupiter. The mass estimate -- one to two times that of Jupiter -- is "somewhat uncertain," Neuhaeuser said. The planet is three times farther from GQ Lupi than Neptune is from our Sun. "We should expect that the planet orbits around the star, but at its large separation one orbital period [a year] is roughly 1,200 years, so that...
Shielding an Interstellar Probe
Project Daedalus, a probe to Barnard's Star that was the first complete design study of a starship, included among its other innovations a dust shield made of beryllium. Driven by a nuclear-pulse engine using internal confinement fusion, Daedalus was so large that its 50 ton shield (nine millimeters thick over a radius of 32 meters) represented only a fraction of its enormous payload. But it was a critical part of the design. For the Daedalus team realized that at 12 percent of the speed of light, an encounter with even a tiny object could destroy their vehicle. Working in the 1970's and made up of members of the British Interplanetary Society, the starship designers knew that most of the interstellar medium is gaseous, primarily hydrogen and about 25 percent helium. Dust is rare, no more than one dust particle for every trillion atoms, but the faster a spacecraft moves, the more stray protons and electrons it will encounter. At a significant percentage of the speed of light, such...
Using the Transit Method for SETI Detections
Every study using transit methods to detect objects around other stars is looking for planets. But a paper by Luc Arnold (Observatoire de Haute-Provence, France), soon to be published in The Astrophysical Journal, suggests that the same methods could be employed to find artificial planet-sized objects in orbit around stars. Arnold sees this as a possible SETI ploy, for transits of multiple objects could be used to emit signals that might be detected by other civilizations. What would such objects be? Giant solar sails, perhaps, or huge low-density structures of other configuration built purposely as a means of interstellar communication. Arnold's work inevitably recalls Freeman Dyson's 1960 Science article "Search for Artificial Stellar Sources of Infrared Radiation," which developed the idea that would later be known as a Dyson Sphere, an artificial cluster of rotating objects the size of a planetary orbit that would collect almost all the solar energy available and create a vast...
A New Take on Artificial Intelligence
An intelligent computer that can operate autonomously is the heart of any interstellar robotic probe. In an important sense, it would be the probe, running its systems, adjusting its course, repairing damage, conducting experiments and choosing the future direction of its own research. We're a long way from such autonomy, but a new company called Numenta may be laying some of the groundwork. The firm plans to use the theories of Jeff Hawkins, inventor of the PalmPilot and co-founder of Palm Computing and Handspring, to create hardware that can think and learn like a human brain. Hawkins' theories appeared in his recent book On Intelligence, and surfaced again at the PC Forum conference in Scottsdale AZ, where he explained his plans in some detail, as discussed in a recent story by Erick Schonfeld in Business 2.0. Hawkins believes the brain's basic function is to store patterns, creating a model of the world that is constantly being used as a reference that can predict what will...
Looking for Life Around Red Giants
Should we narrow the search for life-bearing planets to Sun-like stars? The answer may be 'no' if we take age into account, according to a new study from an international team of astronomers. Stars well into their red-giant phase may have actually revived outer, icy planets to offer them a chance at developing living ecosystems of their own. This happens because stars become brighter as they get older, pushing their habitable zones deeper into any planetary system they possess. The study considered the aging process of stars having the same mass as the Sun, and also considered stars with 1.5 and 2 times its mass. "Our result indicates that searches for life-giving worlds outside our solar system should include planets around old stars," said Dr. Bruno Lopez of the Observatoire de la Cote d'Azur, Nice, France. Lopez is lead author of a paper on this research that is to appear in The Astrophysical Journal. That puts more than 150 red giants within 100 light years on a list of possible...
‘Deep Impact’ Mission in Cruise Phase
NASA's Hubble, Spitzer and Chandra space telescopes will all be watching in July when the Deep Impact spacecraft releases its impactor module (about the size of a coffee table) into the path of onrushing comet Tempel 1. Deep Impact's flyby module will be watching, too, as the impactor creates a crater that may be anywhere from two to fourteen stories deep, releasing cometary dust and ice and exposing underlying materials that have remained unchanged since the formation of the Solar System. Now in the cruise phase of its flight, Deep Impact has been through a test of its autonomous navigation system, and its high gain antenna is operating nominally. A mission status report provides some details about the early stages of the flight, when critical subsystems were put through their paces: Another event during commissioning phase was the bake-out heating of the spacecraft's High Resolution Instrument (HRI) to remove normal residual moisture from its barrel. The moisture was a result of...
Out onto the Wine-Dark Sea
"From time to time, alarm has been expressed at the danger of a 'sensory deprivation' in space. Astronauts on long journeys, it has been suggested, will suffer the symptoms that afflict men who are cut off from their environment by being shut up in darkened, soundproofed rooms. "I would reverse this argument: our culture will suffer from sensory deprivation if it does not go into space. There is striking evidence of this in what has already happened to the astronomers and physicists. As soon as they were able to rise above the atmosphere, a new and often surprising universe was opened up to them, far richer and more complex than had ever been suspected from ground observations. Even the most enthusiastic proponents of space research never imagined just how valuable satellites would actually turn out to be, and there is a profound symbolism in this. "But the facts and statistics of science, priceless as they are, tell only a part of the story. Across the seas of space lie the new raw...
Survey Finds Mysterious ‘Dark Accelerators’
The central part of the Milky Way has never been surveyed in gamma ray wavelengths with the sensitivity offered by HESS, the High Energy Stereoscopic System. And as announced in the March 25th issue of Science, the HESS team has not only found eight new very high energy (VHE) gamma ray sources in the galactic disk, thus doubling the number of known sources, but has also discovered two 'dark accelerators,' objects that emit energetic particles but have no known optical or x-ray counterpart. It takes a particle accelerator of cosmic proportions to produce gamma rays, such as the explosion of a supernova. But such sources should be visible in other wavelengths. Says Dr. Paula Chadwick of the University of Durham (UK): "Many of the new objects seem to be known categories of sources, such as supernova remnants and pulsar wind nebulae. Data on these objects will help us to understand particle acceleration in our galaxy in more detail; but finding these 'dark accelerators' was a surprise....
Defining Habitable Zones in the Galaxy
When is a planet habitable? The assumption, in studies of the 'circumstellar habitable zone' (CHZ) ranging back as far as 150 years, is that a planet is habitable if liquid water can be maintained on its surface. That this is a 'life as we know it' scenario is obvious: it works best if you assume a planetary system not so different from our own, one with roughly the same configuration of planets (gas giants in outer orbits, rocky worlds in close). Venus and Mars have served as test cases of the boundaries of habitable zones. But our view of habitable zones is evolving. I relied on Stephen Dole's groundbreaking study Habitable Planets for Man (New York: Blaisdell Publishing Company 1964) in Centauri Dreams. Dole's work was prepared for the RAND Corporation, and was released in popularized form as Planets for Man, in collaboration with Isaac Asimov (New York: Random House, 1964). Dole defined a stellar ecosphere as ". . . a region in space, in the vicinity of a star, in which suitable...
The Light of Distant Worlds
As discussed in yesterday's entry, being able to work with actual light from distant planets is a major breakthrough. It opens the possibility of studying characteristics like temperature and atmospheric composition, further fusing astronomy with the nascent science of astrobiology. And with the Spitzer Space Telescope's proven ability to make such observations, we can expect a whirlwind of exoplanetary data ahead. A few further details from yesterday's announcements: A study of the work on HD 209458b, a 'hot Jupiter' that orbits its parent star in 3.5 days, ran in today's online edition of Nature. The paper is Deming, D., Seager, S. et al., "Infrared radiation from an extrasolar planet." Dr. Sara Seager of the Carnegie Institution, a co-author of the study, provided more about HD 209458b: "This planet was discovered indirectly in 1999 and was later found to transit its star--the star dims as the planet moves in front of it during the course of the planet's orbit. With Spitzer, we...
Confirmed Detection of Extrasolar Planets’ Light
Light from two planets orbiting other stars has now been directly detected by the Spitzer Space Telescope, in findings announced today at a NASA news conference. Spitzer scrutinized both planets using the 'transit' method, in which a planet eclipses its star and blocks a small fraction of its light. The space-based telescope has been able to detect not only the primary transit but the secondary eclipse, occurring when a planet comes out from behind its star on the far side of its orbit. It thus became possible for astronomers to subtract the planetary 'signal' from the otherwise overwhelming light of the parent star, the first confirmed detection of the light from extrasolar worlds. Both planets fall into the category of 'hot Jupiters' -- massive worlds that orbit at extremely close distances from their primaries. The first (studied with Spitzer's Infrared Array Camera) is TrES-1, orbiting its star at a distance of four million miles and boasting a temperature of 1340 degrees...
Extrasolar Planet Announcement Moved to Today
"Astronomers will announce major findings about planets outside our solar system, known as extrasolar planets, at a NASA Science Update at 3 p.m. EST today." So says a media advisory just out from the agency. NASA TV plans to carry the event, which will discuss discoveries made by the Spitzer Space Telescope. The panelists: Dr. Drake Deming, chief, planetary systems laboratory, NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, Md. Dr. David Charbonneau, assistant professor of astronomy, Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, Cambridge, Mass. Dr. Alan Boss, staff research astronomer, Department of Terrestrial Magnetism, Carnegie Institution of Washington Dr. Kim Weaver, moderator; Spitzer program scientist, NASA's Science Mission Directorate, Washington.
Tweaking Einstein on the Nature of Light
It makes sense to this former Midwesterner that Alan Kostelecky can compare light to waves propagating across a field of grain. After all, Kostelecky works at Indiana University, in a state where fields of grain are not so far from view. The theoretical physicist argues in research published online today in Physical Review D that we could consider light as the result of small violations of relativity, which compare not only to waving wheat but to "...a shimmering of ever-present vectors in empty space." Having seen my share of winds rippling across wheat fields, I know one thing: a propagating wave in a nearby crop comes with a sense of directionality. You know which way the wind is coming from, and how it's affecting the local environment. Thinking of light in such terms is a far cry from a view with a much longer pedigree, that light depends upon an an underlying symmetry that is built into nature itself. Think of symmetry this way: Spacetime in the Einstein model has no preferred...