Finding three planets around a single star is newsworthy in itself, but when the planets are Neptune-class things get more interesting. And when one of these worlds is found to be in the star's habitable zone, Centauri Dreams definitely drops everything for a closer look. Not only that, but the system around HD 69830, a Sun-like star some 41 light years away, is also the home of an asteroid belt, making the comparison with our Solar System that much closer. Here's what we know, as reported in a paper in the May 18 Nature: The orbital periods of the three planets are 8.67, 31.6 and 197 days, with that outer world located near the inner edge of the zone where liquid water could exist. In terms of mass, this planet is not Earth-like; in fact, the measurements show the new planets to be between 10 and 18 times the mass of Earth. So what we're probably detecting in the habitable zone is a planet with a rocky/icy core surrounded by a dense atmosphere. We know nothing, of course, about...
A Clear View of Distant Worlds
Yesterday's post on UMBRAS and occulter technology focuses attention on the characteristics of light, some of them counter-intuitive but well demonstrated. And since we've also been talking recently about the nearby star Epsilon Eridani, I've chosen an image of that star to illustrate some of the problems with planetary detections. What you see below is via Massimo Marengo (Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics), who has done such outstanding recent work on untangling the riddle of Epsilon Eridani's debris disk. This is a false color image with red, yellow, green and blue representing different infrared wavelengths. I ran the same image last summer, when Marengo posted it on his own weblog (he had used it to illustrate his team's work in a presentation at the American Astronomical Society meeting in San Diego). Image: A false-color infrared image of Epsilon Eridani. Credit: Massimo Marengo (CfA). What I want to single out here are the artifacts in the image. The red/orange...
Occulters and Their Uses: A Helpful Resource
'Umbras' is Latin for 'shadows,' and it becomes a fitting acronym for projects to block the light of stars so that astronomers can see the planets around them. The unwound acronym is Umbral Missions Blocking Radiating Astronomical Sources, which refers to both an imaging technique and a class of space missions. The basic idea is this: deploy a space telescope flying in formation with a second, distant companion spacecraft that carries an occulting screen. We're looking for direct pictures of planets by reducing a star's glare, and there are a number of projects aimed at making them, including one we've discussed here many times, the New Worlds Imager mission championed by Webster Cash. I pulled both images in this post from the UMBRAS Web site, where these ideas are explored as a way of pooling talent in the disparate occulter community. Remember, almost everything we know about exoplanets has come from radial velocity studies, microlensing and planetary transits. At best, we are...
Probing the Epsilon Eridani System
In Centauri Dreams' imagination, the name Epsilon Eridani is magic. Like many of us, my earliest speculations about life on other worlds always came back to the nearby, Sun-like stars like Tau Ceti, Epsilon Eridani and Centauri A and B. Frank Drake used the first two as his targets for Project Ozma in 1960, an effort that continues to inspire SETI work today. And Epsilon Eridani is joined by Vega, Fomalhaut and Beta Pictoris as the first stars found by the Infrared Astronomical Satellite (IRAS) to have a cool debris disk somewhat analogous to our own Kuiper Belt. The fact that this K2 star is likely to be orbited by the closest exoplanet to our Sun is also exciting. Its planet seems to be slightly larger than Jupiter, with estimates ranging from 0.8 to 1.6 Jupiter masses, and an eccentric orbit varying from 5.3 to 1.3 AU (here again we see how important it is to establish the effect of gas giants on terrestrial worlds in the habitable zone). At 10.5 light years from us, Epsilon...
A Universe Before the Big Bang
We seem to be awash in exotic physics, an administrative category I created on this site only a couple of days ago to house the trillion-year crunch story and the 'light in reverse' work at the University of Rochester. It seems an appropriate time, then, to look at an investigation reported in the Physical Review Letters that takes us, like Alice through the looking glass, into the universe before the Big Bang. Penn State researchers are behind this study, combining quantum physics tools that Einstein didn't have with general relativity to punch through to a universe on the other side. So let's talk again about what might have been there before the Big Bang. This analysis says the previous universe had a spacetime geometry much like our own expanding universe, except that it was a contracting universe. Gravititational forces were pulling the previous universe together until the quantum properties of spacetime caused gravity itself to become repulsive. What follows is aptly described...
Faster than Light in Reverse?
If you thought the trillion-year crunch was mind-boggling, how about light that moves backwards, and does so at speeds faster than c? From the University of Rochester comes word that Robert Boyd, a professor of optics there, has slowed light to negative speeds. To do this, the experimenter sent a pulse of laser light through an optical fiber laced with the element erbium. Leaving the laser, the light pulse was split, with one pulse going into the fiber and the other left undisturbed for reference. The remarkable result: The peak of the pulse emerged from the other end of the fiber before it entered the front of the fiber, and ahead of the reference pulse. "Through experiments we were able to see that the pulse inside the fiber was actually moving backward, linking the input and output pulses," says Boyd, who acknowledges "I've had some of the world's experts scratching their heads over this one." Centauri Dreams hardly qualifies as an expert, but head-scratching does seem in order...
Trillion Year Crunch
How to explain dark energy, which is pushing distant galaxies away at an accelerating rate? The cosmological constant that would account for the phenomenon -- originally conceived but then rejected by Einstein -- is far smaller than one would expect from conventional Big Bang scenarios. In fact, the observed vacuum energy (a possible explanation for the repulsive force) is smaller by a factor of 10120 than it would need to be to do the job. But if the universe were older than today's estimate of 13.7 billion years, and I mean a lot older, then this tiny value might make sense. So say Paul Steinhardt (Princeton) and Neil Turok (Cambridge, UK), who put forward a startling concept: there was indeed a time before the Big Bang. There is remarkable solace in this for all of us who grew up asking what happened before the Big Bang, only to be told that the question made no sense because it was unanswerable. So said a kindly astronomy professor in a long-ago college course, raising his shaggy...
Organic Particles from the Early Solar System
Can we say anything definitive about organic materials in the early Solar System? Perhaps so, judging from recent news from the Carnegie Institution. Researchers there have found organic particles from the days of Solar System formation inside meteorites. The material is similar to what is found in interplanetary dust particles believed to have come from comets, and gives us a view of the complexity of the organic mix that may have been available as the planets formed. Studying six carbonaceous chondrite meteorites, the researchers looked at different isotopes of hydrogen and nitrogen associated with insoluble organic materials, which are extremely difficult to break down chemically. The relative proportion of these isotopes can reveal much about how the carbon was formed, and the meteorite samples show in some cases even higher amounts of the relevant isotopes than those found in interstellar dust. "We have known for some time, for instance, that interplanetary dust particles (IDP),...
Habitable Worlds and the Gas Giant Problem
I remember wondering, while still getting acclimated to the odd existence of 'hot Jupiters' in those amazing first years of exoplanet discovery, what the view from a terrestrial world in one of those systems might be like. After all, a Jupiter-sized mass in close solar orbit must make for some unusual visual effects. Do terrestrial worlds exist around these stars? For that matter, what are the constraints on terrestrial planet formation in systems where gas giants orbit farther out, well past the habitable zone? These questions are occasioned by the work of Sean Raymond (University of Colorado), whose paper on the subject will soon run in the Astrophysical Journal Letters. Raymond looks at how the presence of gas giants would affect the late stages of terrestrial world formation and presents the results of his simulations on same. Bear this in mind: gas giants, it is now thought, must form within the first few million years of the early protoplanetary disk. Whereas terrestrial worlds...
Of Lightsails and Solar Arrays
Rudolph Meyer's work on solar arrays and ion propulsion elicited quite a few e-mails asking for further information. I don't yet have the Acta Astronautica paper that spells out the details -- nor do I know just how detailed Meyer gets -- but I'll try to provide some answers soon. In the interim, I was startled to realize that Geoffrey Landis, who commented on the Meyer design for New Scientist, had actually gone into this concept at some length as long ago as 1989. In fact, Landis' key paper "Optics and Materials Considerations for a Laser-propelled Lightsail" (available here) was presented at the 40th International Astronautical Federation Congress in that year. Landis speculated on a lightweight sail that focuses power on a small solar array, noting that a basic problem with laser-propelled lightsails is their low energy efficiency: The energy efficiency may be greatly improved, at the cost of a reduction in specific impulse, by combining the laser sail with a photovoltaic powered...
A Planet in the Asteroid Belt?
Was there ever a fifth rocky, terrestrial planet in our Solar System? If so, it was located beyond the orbit of Mars in what is now the asteroid belt. John Chambers (Carnegie Institute of Washington) likes to call the hypothetical world 'Artemis,' and at the 2006 Astrobiology Science Conference in Washington DC this March, he described how the planet might have formed. The trick, of course, is to account for the orbits of the giant planets, which some believe underwent a shift from almost circular to more highly eccentric (elliptical) orbits. If you set up a simulation with Jupiter in a circular orbit, terrestrial worlds form out to about 2.2 AU. From an abstract of Chambers' presentation: Artemis could have formed in a region that was stable before the giant planets' shift, but unstable thereafter, probably between 1.8-2.2 AU. We simulate the giant planets' orbital shift to explore Artemis' demise, varying Artemis' mass and starting location. In each simulation, the giant planets'...
Spectacular Movies of Titan Landing Released
Centauri Dreams has great pleasure in recommending new movie views of the landing of the Huygens probe on Titan, released yesterday by NASA, the European Space Agency and the University of Arizona. The first sequence, titled "View from Huygens on Jan. 14, 2005" offers a spectacular four-minute ride that compresses what would have been seen by the probe during its 2.5 hour descent, using data gathered by the Descent Imager/Spectral Radiometer instrument aboard Huygens. Image: DISR view south at 5 miles above the landing site on Titan, Jan. 14, 2005. (Credits: ESA/NASA/JPL/University of Arizona). "At first, the Huygens camera just saw fog over the distant surface," said Erich Karkoschka, team member at the University of Arizona, Tucson, and creator of the movies. "The fog started to clear only at about 60 kilometers [37 miles] altitude, making it possible to resolve surface features as large as 100 meters [328 feet]," he said. "But only after landing could the probe's camera resolve...
Two Ways to Build a Gas Giant
How planets form is not an issue that will be settled any time soon, but two models have emerged that continue to energize research. We saw yesterday in a review of Alan Boss' new paper that gravitational instability is one way to create a gas giant. But I spent most of yesterday's post talking about UV radiation and its effects on the atmospheres of planets around M stars, a key part of Boss' explanation of so-called 'super-Earths' in these environments. So let's back up and talk about gravitational instability itself. As early as 1997, the astrophysicist had proposed that planet-sized clumps could form relatively quickly due to instabilities in the disk of dust and gas surrounding a young star. Boss believed these clumps could be massive enough to form a gas envelope, but the model was hard to use in any predictive sense and demanded more intensive computer simulations than were then available. Later work by Thomas Quinn, however, bears Boss out. Quinn (University of Washington)...
Planetary Formation Around Red Dwarfs
What we know about the planets circling M-class dwarf stars is changing rapidly. Recent microlensing surveys have revealed the existence of two 'super-Earths' -- rocky worlds 5.5 and 13 times as massive as the Earth -- around distant red dwarfs. Microlensing has also produced two gas giants around such stars. And radial velocity surveys have found systems like Gl 876, an M-class star orbited by an outer pair of gas giants and an inner super-Earth. Other radial velocity catches are Gl 436 and Gl 581, each accompanied by a super-Earth in a short-period orbit. A curious fact emerging from these studies is that the frequency of gas giants around M dwarfs seems to be lower than around F, G and K-type stars. In a new paper, Alan Boss (Carnegie Institute of Washington) discusses the formation of these planetary types, arguing that disk instability rather than core accretion may be the cause of their formation. An additional, and in his view critical, factor: the loss of planetary gas...
A Supermassive Black Hole Pairing
How do you get two supermassive black holes in each other's neighborhood? That's the question raised by the discovery of a pair of such objects, each 150 million times more massive than the Sun, and separated by a cosmically minute 24 light years. They're in the center of a galaxy called 0402+379, some 750 million light years from Earth, and they orbit each other every 150,000 years. "Astronomers have thought for a long time that close pairs of black holes should result from galaxy collisions," says Cristina Rodriguez (University of New Mexico and Simon Bolivar University in Venezuela). And that's apparently what happened here. Astronomers working with the Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA) radio telescope think that these black holes were each at the core of separate galaxies. A collision between the galaxies would then have left the two objects orbiting each other. It would be intriguing indeed if the black holes themselves would collide, as the event should cause strong gravitational...
Publishing’s Mutating Tools
It's fascinating to watch as new publishing models unfold using digital tools. Coverage is uneven at present, but the day will come when the average conference makes its proceedings available in audio and video format on the Web, with the once essential printed volume now playing a supporting but still vital role in libraries and on the shelves of researchers. On the journalism side, the growth of weblogs and self-publishing tools makes possible the coverage of stories from a wider variety of perspectives than ever before. We're a long way from the demise of printed books, but electronic publishing is beginning to offer new options for authors as well. One harbinger is the arrival of an new e-book called Kosmos: You Are Here, billed as "a look at science, life, evolution, cosmology and other fundamental concepts," and written by a community of online volunteers with proceeds going to support the YearlyKos political conference this June. Cosmology, geology, evolution and climate...
A New Probe of Dark Energy
What we know about dark energy can be pretty much summed up in these words: "We know that it dominates the universe. In fact, it comprises an estimated 73 percent of the universe, while so-called dark matter accounts for 23 percent, and matter of the familiar kind — the stars, galaxies, all known life — comprises only four percent." The speaker is David Lambert, a University of Texas at Austin astronomer and the director of UT's McDonald Observatory. And it has always seemed to Centauri Dreams that these numbers -- what we know and see of the universe is no more than four percent of the total -- should inspire a certain humility. Yes, we know more than those before us, but just how far we are from comprehending the nature of 'reality' seems obvious. There are real reasons to wonder whether the human mind is capable of ever understanding ultimate reality. Perhaps a quote from Martin Rees about the beginning of the universe is appropriate: "There are lots of ideas of what...
Cometary Breakup Continues
73P/Schwassmann-Wachmann is proving to be a far more interesting object than first anticipated. The comet is closing toward the Sun and will swing around it on June 7, passing the Earth along the way at a distance of 11.7 million kilometers. The fascination comes from watching its ongoing disintegration, which has broken the comet into more than 30 separate fragments. Nor is the show over. The larger fragments appear to be continuing their breakup. In the image below, taken by the Hubble Space Telescope, you can see one of the major fragments breaking into smaller chunks, dozens of which trail behind the main piece. The chunks are evidently pushed back along the tail by outgassing from their Sun-facing surfaces, and the smallest of them seem to be dissipating completely over a multi-day period. Image: The second image from a three-day observation with Hubble showing the breakup of Comet 73P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 3's Fragment B. Credit: NASA, ESA, H. Weaver (APL/JHU), M. Mutchler and...
Via Solar Array to the Outer Planets
New Scientist is covering the work of Rudolph Meyer (UCLA), who envisions a vehicle that sounds for all the world like a cross between a solar sail and an ion engine. And in a way, it is: Imagine a flexible solar panel a solid 3125 square meters in size, and imagine this 'solar-electric membrane' weighing no more than 16 grams per square meter, far lighter than today's technology allows. I'll be anxious to see the paper when it's published in Acta Astronautica, but the gist of the design seems to be this: the solar membrane would power an ion engine array which, conventionally enough, draws xenon ions through a powerful electric grid to create thrust. The membrane, stabilized by additional ion engines at the corners, could reach remarkable speeds. Meyer talks about 666,000 kilometers per hour -- that's one year to Pluto, and an obvious invitation out into the Kuiper Belt. No show stoppers here, but clearly a design heavily dependent on advances in thin film arrays. I always listen to...
A Powerful Resource on ‘Hot Jupiters’
That oh so interesting planetary system around 51 Peg continues to fascinate exoplanet hunters. After all, this was the first planetary discovery around a main sequence star, and the formidable dimensions of the radial velocity dataset accrued before and since the discovery may lead to other planets in the same system. For the latest on 51 Peg, check the online proceedings of last August's colloquium, in which eighty astronomers provide their thoughts on 'hot Jupiters' and discuss recent observational facts about this intriguing system. Centauri Dreams is always delighted to see conference proceedings made available online. The only catch here is that the format is PDF -- yes, it's a standard of sorts, but there has to be a better way...