by Marc Millis Apropos of our recent discussion of species differentiation and what may happen when humans spread into the Solar System and beyond, Marc Millis forwarded a whimsical piece he wrote for Aerospace Frontiers, the internal news publication of NASA Glenn Research Center. The item ran in August of 2000 and makes for an enjoyable weekend diversion. From the Author: The visions presented here do not necessarily reflect the opinions of NASA Glenn, "Aerospace Frontiers," or even the author himself. What this story does represent, however, is a light-hearted glimpse of an unintended turn of events. History itself is a collection of unplanned twists and turns, so our visions of the future should prepare us for more of the same. Prepare yourself. ------- It finally happened. Access to space became cheap enough so that the average "Joe" and "Joanne" could venture beyond the bounds of Earth, and long-duration space habitats became robust enough to provide reliable places to live...
Finding Biomarkers in an Alien Atmosphere
As planet hunters catalog stellar wobbles and light-curves, some of them are working their way down through the various planetary types aiming at the ultimate discovery, an Earth-like world around another star. And if Lisa Kaltenegger has her way, they'll be able to tell us something about the existence of life on that planet. Kaltenegger faced a Washington DC audience yesterday to announce a new methodology for examining terrestrial worlds. Unable to be there myself, I attended via a much appreciated Webcast. Kaltenegger (Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics) and Wesley Traub (JPL and CfA) are looking closely at the history of Earth's atmosphere to understand what happens in the various stages of planetary evolution. The development of life is one of many factors that changed the atmosphere in the past 4.5 billion years. When the day comes that we have spectroscopic data from exoplanets as small as Earth, we'll be able to study the signatures of the gases there to learn...
A Baffling New Planetary Discovery
A Jupiter-sized planet with the density of cork? The idea seems farcical, but it's under discussion as I write at a news conference held by the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (CfA). The planet, called HAT P-1, revolves around ADS 16402, a star much like our Sun that is part of a binary system some 450 light years away in the constellation Lacerta. The first planet found by the Hungarian Automated Telescope observing network, HAT P-1 may represent a new class of planet entirely. For despite a radius of 1.38 times Jupiter's, HAT P-1 has only half its mass. "This planet is about one-quarter the density of water," said Gaspar Bakos (CfA). "In other words, it's lighter than a giant ball of cork! Just like Saturn, it would float in a bathtub if you could find a tub big enough to hold it, but it would float almost three times higher." Intriguingly, the new world isn't the first planet with oddly low density. Another planet found by the transit method, HD 209458b, is also about...
Earliest Galaxies Probed
What are being described as the 'deepest infrared and optical data ever taken' provide a new picture of the early evolution of the universe. Researchers have observed hundreds of bright galaxies from the era around 900 million years after the Big Bang and compared this catalog with a deeper look 200 million years earlier in time. The result: Only one galaxy, using the strictest criteria, turned up in the earlier period, an indication of vast changes in those 200 million years. The work comes from Rychard Bouwens and Garth Illingworth (University of California - Santa Cruz), who used the Hubble Space Telescope to look at early galaxy formation in dark patches of sky like the Hubble Ultra Deep Field and the Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey fields. The mechanism at work in this period of galactic evolution seems obvious. Says Illingworth: "The bigger, more luminous galaxies just were not in place at 700 million years after the Big Bang. Yet 200 million years later there were many...
Species Differentiation and Star Travel
Freeman Dyson among others has speculated about the physical changes that could occur as the human species spreads into the cosmos. How will evolution deal with a colony world in a distant star system, and how long will it take before serious differentiation begins to occur? For that matter, what about the crew aboard a multi-generational starship -- will humans have adapted so thoroughly to a space-borne environment when they arrive that some opt to make their planetary excursion no more than a brief research stop before pushing on to yet other solar systems? Or will they one day adapt to the vacuum itself? Such questions are called to mind by recent work from Virginie Millien (McGill University), whose new paper in the open source journal PLoS Biology examines islands as test beds for evolution on Earth. It has long been assumed that isolation would create selective pressures unique to an island environment. A so-called 'island rule' has small animals evolving into outsized...
Betting on a Long-Term Future
The idea of interstellar flight forces long-term speculation. Barring unexpected breakthroughs, we are looking at mission times that, at best, are counted in the decades if not centuries. One of the purposes of Centauri Dreams is to encourage the kind of long-term thinking that plans and executes such missions. That such thinking -- focused well beyond individual human lifetimes -- is a worthy goal in and of itself should also be obvious, and it is actively championed in projects like the 10,000 year clock of the Long Now Foundation. A partial spinoff from the Long Now called the Long Bets Foundation is increasingly active in providing a competitive arena for predictions about the future. It's a fascinating concept, both a forum for discussion about long-range issues and a tool for philanthropic giving. People make predictions which, if challenged, become bets. Each prediction requires a $50 fee to the foundation, while a minimum of $200 is required to challenge a prediction. After a...
Brown Dwarf or Planet?
Following hard on our discussion of HD 3651, a K-class dwarf whose brown dwarf companion was recently imaged, comes news that the Hubble Space Telescope has photographed something smaller still. CHRX 73 B orbits a low-mass red dwarf. Some would consider it a planet, others a brown dwarf; which camp you are in depends on what you use as a planetary marker. If it's mass, then this object, 12 times the mass of Jupiter, would probably be considered a planet. But team leader Kevin Luhman (Pennsylvania State) has other ideas. For if your marker is how the object formed, then a whole new set of criteria swim into view. Luhman argues that to be a planet, an object must have evolved from the gas and dust disk that circles a newly formed star. Whereas brown dwarfs are thought to form like any other star, from the collapse of huge clouds of hydrogen gas. They simply lack the mass to ignite hydrogen fusion in their cores. And Luhman seems to be on firm ground in making this distinction: "The...
Collaboration Bags a Transiting Gas Giant
Small telescopes doing amazing things. That's the theme of the day in exoplanet hunting, reinforced by the announcement of a new planet discovered by the Trans-Atlantic Exoplanet Survey (TrES). Small, automated equipment and off-the-shelf camera technology went into this work, which spotted the third transiting planet found with the kind of telescopes available to amateurs. "Hunting for planets with amateur equipment seemed crazy when we started the project," says David Charbonneau, an astronomer at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, "but with this discovery the approach has become mainstream." Image: A computer-generated simulation of TrES-2 crossing (transiting) the disk of its host star. TrES-2 transits farther from the disk center than any other known transiting planet. The transit of TrES-2 causes a drop in the brightness of its home star of about one and a half percent. This slight dimming of the star's light was noticed and measured by the TrES researchers, who...
Water Worlds in Known Planetary Systems
Planetary migration -- as when a 'hot Jupiter' moves inward toward its parent star during system formation -- may not be as disruptive as we once thought. In fact, according to a new study led by the University of Colorado at Boulder and Pennsylvania State, solar systems with hot Jupiters may well harbor Earth-like planets covered with deep oceans. The research team's paper, just published in Science, paints a positively benign scenario, one in which the gas giant's migration actually becomes the trigger for the formation of water worlds that could well turn out to be habitable. Let's look at this more closely, because it's quite a shift from earlier studies, which assumed that a hot Jupiter's migrations would eject protoplanetary materials from the system or else absorb them. Working with computer simulations, the Colorado/Penn State researchers now think the hot Jupiters force rocky debris outward in the system, helping the formation of rocky planets. At the same time, and this is...
Imaging a Brown Dwarf
Putting a brown dwarf into the same stellar system with one or more known planets seems like a dicey proposition, but we know it sometimes occurs. Radial-velocity studies have already detected systems like HD 38529 and HD 168443 that include a brown dwarf and known planet. In both these cases, the brown dwarf involved is known to revolve around the exoplanet host star in an orbit at least ten times wider than that of the planet found there. But there are more unusual possibilities: A brown dwarf around the star HD 202206 actually moves inside the orbit of the known exoplanet there. Look no further if you need a new science fiction setting. Until now, we've never had a direct image of a brown dwarf around an exoplanet host star, but a new paper changes all that. A German team led by Markus Mugrauer (University of Jena) provides just such a detection, as shown in the image below. The star is HD 3651, a K-class dwarf near the boundary between Pegasus and Pisces some 11 parsecs from...
A Transit Search of Gl 876
Among the 200-plus exoplanets discovered thus far, the system around the red dwarf Gl 876 stands out. For one thing, it contains the closest thing to a terrestrial-sized planet yet found, with a mass of about six times that of Earth and a tight, two-day orbit around its primary. For another, it houses two gas giants, the only planets of this type known to orbit an M-dwarf, and they exhibit a 2:1 mean-motion resonance -- one of them orbits the star twice in the same amount of time the other makes a single orbit. Such resonances provide clues in the study of how systems like these formed and changed over time. These gas giants, one in a 30-day orbit, the other in a 60, are fascinating in their own right, but the detection of the small inner planet by Doppler techniques shows just how far planetary detection methods have come in the past decade. Now a paper slated for publication in The Astrophysical Journal looks at Gl 876 in terms of planetary transits, for to arrive at the true mass...
Astounding in the Glory Years
A recent acquisition has me looking backward rather than forward to begin the week. It's the January 1940 issue of Astounding Science Fiction, a magazine then in its glory years under the editorship of John Campbell. Some of the authors here ring few bells: Sam Weston, for example, weighs in with "In the Day of the Cold," as does D.L. James with "Moon of Delirium." But this is also the issue of Robert Heinlein's "Requiem," and it contains good work by Lester del Rey and Edward E. Smith as well. Astounding's science articles mixed with its ever reliable stories gave it a special place in the history of the pulp magazines, and many a scientist has told me that it was through Astounding or its later incarnation as Analog Science Fiction & Fact that a career path in physics or astronomy emerged. Which brought to mind science fiction writer Frederick Pohl, a distinguished editor in his own right. Pohl's 1978 memoir The Way the Future Was catches the magazine's exciting heyday. He evokes...
New Horizons: Camera Ready for Pluto
The seventh and final instrument aboard New Horizons has now been tested in space and found to return good data. The Pluto-bound spacecraft used its Long Range Reconnaissance Imager (LORRI) to take a picture of the Messier 7 cluster on August 29. Stars down to 12th magnitude are visible in the image, which means the instrument checks out with pre-launch calculations and is operating nominally. "Our hope was that LORRI's first image would prove not only that the cover had opened completely, but that LORRI was capable of providing the required high-resolution imaging of Pluto and Charon," says Andy Cheng, LORRI principal investigator, from Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory, which built and operates the spacecraft. "Our hopes were not only met, but exceeded." The mirror remained in focus even after its temperature dropped by more than 50 degrees C (120 degrees F) when its cover door opened. Next for LORRI are observations of Jupiter as New Horizons begins to focus on...
A Closer Look at Centauri Space
Asteroseismologists -- the people who study the oscillations of stars to examine their internal structure -- can tell us a good deal about Alpha Centauri, and specifically about Centauri B, a K-class star which has also been carefully measured with the techniques of long-baseline interferometry. But a problem arises when you compare their mass estimates of the star with radial velocity studies, for the mass estimates of each differ by 28 Jupiter masses, plus or minus 9. Is the discrepancy a data analysis error or an indication of something more interesting? Pondering whether it might show the existence of a companion for Centauri B, a French team has searched for the presence of such an object and, in the process, has built a catalog of background objects detectable with adaptive optics, using the European Southern Observatory's Paranal site in Chile. Image: They look like one huge star in this photograph, but Centauri A and B simply overwhelm the view with their glare. Remember,...
Where Have All the Shadows Gone?
Cosmological shadows? Theory predicts that objects between us and the source of the cosmic microwave background should cast them. Specifically, the hot gases found in clusters of galaxies should show a measurable shadow effect produced by that background radiation, and there are reports of such effects from various observers. The scattering of the cosmic microwave background by high-energy electrons is known as the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect. However, a new study from the University of Alabama at Huntsville raises real problems. The first to study the phenomena with data from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP), the team reports an oddly sporadic shadow effect for a background thought to be afterglow radiation from the Big Bang. And that raises questions about the Big Bang model itself. Says physicist Richard Lieu, after an investigation involving 31 clusters of galaxies: "These shadows are a well-known thing that has been predicted for years. This is the only direct...
Quasars, Black Holes and a Reionized Universe
A black hole two billion times more massive than the Sun is not something you find every day. Even more unusual is to find it embedded in a quasar that is 12.7 billion light years from Earth. But that's just what Tomotsugu Goto (Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency) seems to have found using the Subaru optical-infrared telescope on Mauna Kea. How a black hole of this mass could have formed only a billion years after the birth of the universe is only one of the questions this find poses. For the object, found in the direction of Cancer, also shows via its spectrum that much of the hydrogen between the quasar and Earth is ionized. What would cause neutral hydrogen to be converted to ionized hydrogen in this early epoch? Ultraviolet radiation is thought to be the key, but observational evidence helping us understand how and when this occurred has always been tricky to gather for a reionization event that occurred over 12 billion years ago. Quasars are useful beacons by which to study this...
Early Notes Toward a Galactic Census
What sort of stars harbor the planetary systems we've thus far identified? The answer is easy: most of the known exoplanets were found through radial velocity surveys, and these focus on nearby Sun-like stars. Thus we're looking at a range of stars between late-F and early-K class dwarfs, and almost all are within 50 parsecs of the Sun. It is also apparent that planetary systems in our scope of observation increase with increasing metallicity of the parent star, a measure of elements higher than hydrogen and helium. Are there other trends we can identify? Perhaps not. As I. Neill Reid (Space Telescope Science Institute) writes in a new paper on the subject, "With the possible exception of a higher mean velocity perpendicular to the Plane, the planetary hosts appear to be unremarkable members of the Galactic Disk." There is not, for example, a correlation we might expect to find in metal-rich stars between the mass of the primary star and the masses of its planetary companions...
Gravity, Inertia, Exotica
Are we ever going to understand what makes matter resist acceleration? If we can get a handle on inertia, we'll have a better idea what's possible when it comes to exotic propulsion. 19th Century physicist Ernst Mach believed that inertia was the result of matter being acted upon by all other objects in the universe, even the most distant ones. At the University of California at Fullerton, James Woodward has been studying inertia in a Machian context for some time, and an implication that appears to grow out of it: an object undergoing acceleration may experience transient fluctuations in its mass. It will take a great deal of experimentation to find out whether there is anything to this, but the idea is interesting enough to keep Woodward working. His theories are put to the test in the laboratory, for they predict an effect that should be measurable. Indeed, his work with capacitors produces results that can be interpreted as mass reduction, though getting a clear data signal...
Weekend Vista: Into the Magellanics
Now and then it's good to step back from interstellar advocacy, especially on a weekend, and just look at the sky. To that end, the photograph below can be considered an object of contemplation, something to quiet the rush of the work week and return the mind to the far reaches. You're looking at a region within the Large Magellanic Cloud that contains hot blue stars, some of them brighter than a million Suns. That kind of energy pushes stellar 'winds' -- charged particles moving at tremendous speeds -- out into the surrounding interstellar gas. Image: This active region of star formation in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), as photographed by NASA's Hubble Space Telescope, unveils wispy clouds of hydrogen and oxygen that swirl and mix with dust on a canvas of astronomical size. The LMC is a satellite galaxy of the Milky Way. Credit: NASA, ESA, and the Hubble Heritage Team (STScI/AURA). And look at those dust streamers running the length of the nebula, as well as the bright orange of...
A Fourth Planet for Mu Arae
Hunting for exoplanets isn't a matter of peering into telescopes and seeing faint specks of light. It's all about combing through data -- reams and reams of data thankfully digitized -- for the telltale signatures of planets. And it's fascinating to reflect that in many cases the signatures we seek are in our possession in the form of already gathered radial velocity data. We must continue to re-examine our growing stellar libraries, which in the case of radial velocities only get richer over time as planetary influences become more pronounced. And so we come to Mu Arae, a G-type dwarf star much like our Sun and catalogued as HD 160691. A new study by Krzysztof Gozdziewski, Andrzej Maciejewski, and Cezary Migaszewski re-examines this already intriguing planetary system to discover yet another planet, the fourth to be found there. These radial velocity measurements were made by the Anglo-Australian Planet Search project and build on the earlier detections of three worlds, two being...