So now we know what a planet is. As confirmed by the passage of a revised resolution at the International Astronomical Union's general assembly today in Prague, a planet meets the following criteria: It must be in orbit around a star It must possess sufficient mass to allow it to assume a round shape; i.e., it assumes hydrostatic equilibrium It is large enough that it has cleared the orbit through which it moves The third item, of course, is the interesting part, for it rules out Ceres, about which there had been some controversy. I mean, it was one thing to consider 2003 UB313 as a planet, but to delve into the middle of the Solar System and define a new planet in medias res seemed a stretch too far for some people (though not for me). Pluto is also ruled out because it moves for part of its orbit inside the orbit of Neptune; Charon likewise is left without planetary designation. What does happen to Pluto is that it becomes a 'dwarf planet,' a new kind of object that also includes...
The Latest on the Tau Zero Foundation
by Marc Millis Centauri Dreams is pleased to report again on the status of the Tau Zero Foundation. Founded by Marc Millis, former head of NASA's Breakthrough Propulsion Physics program, the Foundation's goal is to support credible research into interstellar flight, with a realistic understanding that incremental progress toward this goal can only be made through persistent, long-term effort. Here Millis describes the current state of affairs, and discusses the necessary next steps for the young Foundation. For those awaiting the debut of the Tau Zero Foundation, I thought I would take this time to let you know how it will be implemented. The first stage, setting up the basic operation and a pool of expert practitioners, is already happening. From the combined work of our practitioners we will debut a public website that explains the status of this work and the next practical steps to be taken toward interstellar flight. At that same time will be ready to accept general memberships....
New Evidence for Dark Matter
Gravitational lensing, discussed here recently as the motive for the FOCAL mission to the Sun's gravity lens, is suddenly back in the news. This time it's being used to make measurements of dark matter of a startlingly precise kind, measurements that in some quarters are being hailed as the first solid evidence that dark matter exists. Views of two merging galaxy clusters at optical and x-ray wavelengths are involved, with gravitational lensing being used to examine their mass. The clusters under investigation seem prime candidates for this kind of work. Douglas Clowe (University of Arizona), who led the study, explains its significance: "Prior to this observation, all of our cosmological models were based on an assumption that we couldn't prove: that gravity behaves the same way on the cosmic scale as on Earth. The clusters we've looked at in these images are a billion times larger than the largest scales at which we can measure gravity at present, which are on the scale of our...
Galileo Weighs in On Planetary Definitions
Centauri Dreams continues to admire the clarity of the draft IAU resolution on the definition of a planet. Although the criteria are easily understood, they also present teaching opportunities (imagine all those schoolchildren learning what a barycenter is, and why Pluto/Charon make a double planet thanks to the location of their center of gravity!). This sound definition also grows from the properties of the planets themselves and is based on the best current information on planetary formation. Galileo Galilei had some thoughts on naming things that seem apropos, and what better source to consider when defining a planet? The Tuscan astronomer/mathematician (1564-1642) could have been speaking of the current controversy when he said, "Names and attributes must be accomodated to the essence of things, and not the essence to the names, for things come first and names afterward." I submit that the draft resolution does a fine job accomodating the named thing to its essence -- that...
The FOCAL Mission: To the Sun’s Gravity Lens
One of the great missions for the 21st century could be FOCAL -- a space probe sent to the Sun's gravity lens some 550 AU out. Gravitational lensing is becoming a major tool for astronomers, and we've even seen planetary detections using microlensing, looking at targets in the direction of galactic center and the faint changes in light that indicate a planet's passage. The gravity lens concept, harking back to a 1936 Einstein paper, came to the fore in 1978, when Dennis Walsh and team spotted a twin quasar image, the result of the lensing caused by an intervening galaxy as it bends light around it. So we know that lensing works. As far as I know, the first person to apply the notion to spacecraft was Von Eshleman (Stanford University), who considered a space probe to 550 AU to exploit the potential magnifications available there. And such missions have also been considered, by Frank Drake among others, as SETI experiments, using the Sun's ability to magnify the hydrogen line at 1420...
Planet Formation in Orion
The Spitzer Space Telescope has peered into the Orion nebula with striking results: nearly 2300 planet-forming disks in the overall Orion cloud complex, a star-forming region some 1450 light years from Earth. This is where infrared truly shines, for such disks are too small to be seen with visible-light telescopes. But Spitzer is made to order for picking up the infrared signature of warm dust, giving us an unprecedented look at solar system formation in the aggregate. The image below gives a glimpse, but be sure to click to enlarge the photograph for a bit more detail. Thomas Megeath (University of Toledo, OH) likens the research to a census of potential solar systems, saying "...we want to know how many are born in the cities, how many in small towns, and how many out in the countryside." Megeath and colleagues discovered that 60 percent of the disk-bearing stars in the Orion cloud complex are found in clusters of hundreds of stars, while 15 percent exist in much smaller groupings,...
Ceres and Charon: A Matter of Gravity
Someone with more cultural insight than Centauri Dreams will have to explain why the designation of Pluto as a planet has captivated so large an audience. The issue is front page on my local newspaper this morning and I'm being asked about it by people who have never shown the slightest interest in space exploration. Perhaps it's the overturning of things memorized long ago, as if someone had changed the multiplication tables, or decided to modify what makes up the letters of the alphabet. Whatever the case, the IAU's draft definition seems to lead to a de facto loss of planetary dignity for Pluto even while maintaining its tenuous identification as one of the tribe. For 'plutons' -- that category to describe planets whose orbits take more than 200 years to complete, with large orbital inclination and eccentricity -- will no doubt soon comprise the vast majority of planets as we discover more and more material in the Kuiper Belt. Which will inevitably lead to an accurate sense that...
Cosmological Blogging from Prague
When is a galactic grouping 'compact'? Take a look at the four closely grouped galaxies in the image below; they're most of the galaxies in Stephan's Quintet (the fifth is off-image to the lower right). Redshift measurements indicate that the top three of these are at the same distance from us, about 300 million light years away in Pegasus. A group is considered compact when it shares the same gas reservoir, or so I learned while reading about a presentation on the subject made by C. Mendes de Olivera at the ongoing IAU meeting in Prague. Image: Four of the galaxies of Stephan's Quintet. The galaxy at bottom left is a foreground object, but the other three are at the same distance from us and engaged in spectacular gravitational interactions. Credit: Jane C. Charlton (Penn State) et al., HST, ESA, NASA. I owe the opportunity to learn about these matters to Ph.D student Thomas Marquart, who is working in the Galaxy Group at Uppsala Astronomical Observatory in Sweden. Marquart is...
Going Interstellar at Princeton
The annual New Trends in Astrodynamics and Applications conference meets for the third time this week in Princeton, with Ed Belbruno calling the house to order on Wednesday. From an interstellar perspective, this year's conference is packed -- last year we had but three interstellar papers, whereas the 2006 meeting will feature two complete sessions and no fewer than nine papers on topics ranging from collecting antimatter from natural sources in the Solar System (James Bickford) to spacecraft miniaturization (Mason Peck) and antimatter/nuclear hybrids (Gerald Jackson). You can find the list of speakers and their topics at the program site. This year the focus on near-term precursor concepts is robust. Greg Matloff will report on interim missions as a way to 'prep for Centaurus,' while Les Johnson and Sandy Montgomery (NASA MSFC) will present the latest solar sail developments, and Claudio Maccone will examine the FOCAL mission to the Sun's gravity lens. I had been looking forward to...
Pioneer and ‘The Long Result’
It was Tennyson whose narrator, recalling youthful wanderings and celestial vistas in the poem 'Locksley Hall,' wrote about 'the fairy tales of science, and the long result of Time.' That long result is something we seldom look at in our feverish and accelerated world, but in these closing paragraphs from a book written with Chesley Bonestell in 1972, Arthur C. Clarke thinks about the Pioneer spacecraft, the distant future and the things that may survive man. For the Pioneers will keep going. "As our space-faring powers develop, we may overtake them with the vehicles of a later age and bring them back to our museums, as relics of the early days before men ventured beyond Mars. And if we do not find them, others may. "We should therefore build them well, for one day they may be the only evidence that the human race ever existed. All the works of man on his own world are ephemeral, seen from the viewpoint of geological time. The winds and rains which have destroyed mountains will make...
A Novel Strategy for Asteroid Deflection
With the recent knowledge that half of all near-Earth asteroids are binaries, the stakes go up in the race to develop technologies to prevent potential impacts. But is the best solution what Centauri Dreams has always advocated, to intercept the approaching object as far from Earth as possible and alter its trajectory? A new paper suggests an alternative strategy: why not capture a nearby asteroid and put it into an Earth-bound orbit to use as a shield? Such an asteroid could then be moved as needed to absorb the impact of any collision that would otherwise hit the Earth. The work of Didier Massonnet and Benoît Meyssignac (Centre National d'Etudes Spatiales, France), the paper argues that an asteroid between 20 and 40 meters in diameter, which the two nickname 'David's stone,' could destroy a much larger incoming object under proper targeting conditions. The problem becomes finding the right asteroid. From the paper: We...have a detection challenge: we seek an asteroid small enough...
Simulated Planets Around Centauri B
Centauri A and B continue to stand out as likely venues for terrestrial planets. What a change since the days when it was thought orbits in binary systems like this one would be completely unstable. Today we believe that both the major Centauri stars could support small, rocky worlds within about 4 AU, and that such planets are as likely, if not more so, to form there as around our own Sun. The latter insight emerges directly from the work of Elisa Quintana and Jack Lissauer. Add to that two other factors: At UC-Santa Cruz, Greg Laughlin and Jeremy Wertheimer have shown that Proxima Centauri could perturb the debris disk surrounding the Centauri stars enough to deliver volatiles to inner worlds there. Laughlin has been arguing the Centauri case for some time now, discussing not just the Proxima factor but pointing as well to the metallicity of Alpha Centauri, which is high enough to provide the kind of materials needed to form planets analogous to Earth. Keen on detecting such a...
A Stellar ID Through Microlensing
Gravitational microlensing is a fascinating way to find exoplanets, provided you're not worried about nearby targets. For the best way to do microlensing of this sort is to work with a crowded starfield, which means looking toward galactic center, where stars are numerous and distant enough that their lensing events can be studied. You're hoping to find a star that passes in front of another as seen from Earth, in which case the gravity of the foreground star sets up the gravitational lensing effects that magnify the light of the background star. Thus OGLE-2003-BLG-235L, which displayed a planetary companion that was discovered in 2003 using ground-based observations. The oddity here is that while the planet produced an additional brightening of the background star, thus confirming its existence, astronomers weren't sure about the identity of the star it circled. It has taken two years and new observations by the Hubble Space Telescope to pin down OGLE-2003-BLG-235L -- the foreground...
Of Consciousness and the Machine
Igor Aleksander (University College, London) is a specialist in neural systems engineering who is working on emerging consciousness in machines, a process he calls 'more basic' than artificial intelligence. Velcro City Tourist Board offers up an interview with Aleksander that gets into models of the mind and the meaning of consciousness itself. A snippet: "There's one important principle involved in the computational modelling of consciousness: being conscious does not mean being a living human, or even a non-human animal. For an organism to be conscious is for it to be able to build representations of itself in a world that it perceives as being 'out there', with itself at the centre of it. It is to be able to represent the past as a history of experience, to attend to those things that are important to it, to plan and to evaluate plans - these are the five axioms." For more on conscious machines and links to Aleksander's axioms, read the whole story. We'll see the benefits of such...
More on the Hubble Constant
We've just looked at the interesting work of Kris Stanek and collaborators on the Hubble constant, which could be taken to imply that previous measurements of this important figure are off by about 15 percent. Stanek's data point to a Hubble constant of 61 kilometers per second per megaparsec (a megaparsec is equal to 3.26 million light years); current estimates had begun to settle in comfortably at around 70 (km/s)/Mpc, although some astronomers, most conspicuously Allan Sandage, held out for a much lower figure. Now comes news of a study working with x-ray data from the Chandra space observatory and radio observations of galaxy clusters. Using this information, Max Bonamente (MSFC) and team have made distance measurements to 38 galaxy clusters ranging from 1.4 billion to 9.3 billion light years from Earth. Their finding on the Hubble constant pegs it at 77 kilometers per second per megaparsec, with an uncertainty of about 15%. And it's a finding more or less in agreement with...
Night Thoughts on Human Expansion
One summer night last year I found myself at a dinner party that had stretched late into the evening. Enjoying a good Côtes du Rhône and watching distant lightning flickering through the trees outside, I hadn't been saying much until the subject came around to space. Suddenly I was challenged to justify the notion of exploring not just distant stellar systems but even the nearby planets. And before long I was talking about the need to develop technologies that could help us deflect a potential life-threatening asteroid. At which point one of the guests stopped me cold by saying, "Why should we deflect it? The human race has done little enough. What does it matter if we're all destroyed?" Try to talk someone out of that. It's early 21st Century weltschmzerz in its purest form, writing off all future generations because of a perceived sense of human failure. Not even half a bottle of Côtes du Rhône could take the edge off it. Reading a recent essay in Acta Astronautica by Giancarlo...
Hubble’s Constant Tweaked
It was in 1929 that Edwin Hubble formulated a key principle about the universe. Hubble realized that the redshift of distant galaxies was proportional to their distance, and refinements to the Hubble constant have brought some sense of order to our view of the expanding cosmos ever since. But an Ohio State astronomer and his colleagues now argue for tweaking Hubble, to the tune of 15 percent. That's the difference between previous readings of the distance to M33, the Triangulum Galaxy, and the value they have recently measured. The paper by Kris Stanek and co-authors is slated for the Astrophysical Journal, and is available in preprint form here. In it, the team describes its study of M33 in optical and infrared wavelengths using a wide variety of instruments including the 10-meter telescopes at Hawaii's Keck Observatory. The work on an eclipsing binary system in M33 produced a measurement of 3 million light years from Earth for the galaxy as opposed to the 2.6 million as determined...
An Electromagnetic Voyage for Bacteria?
Can living microbes travel between the planets, blown off one by a colossal asteroid impact, for example, and carried in debris to another? Some have suggested that life on Earth originated on Mars in just this way, but interesting work by electrical engineer Tom Dehel now offers an alternative. Dehel, who is also working on a law degree at Rutgers, was studying the Earth's electromagnetic fields and their impact on GPS satellite systems for the FAA when he realized that bacteria could be ejected from Earth by the kind of fields that create auroras. The work, presented at a meeting of the Committee on Space Research (COSPAR) in Beijing, was the subject of a recent New Scientist story by David Chandler. And it's intriguing because whereas asteroid impacts of the needed size were relatively rare even in the early Solar System, the electromagnetic fields in question are common. Dehel sees the possibility of bacteria floating in the upper atmosphere and reproducing there, evolving ways...
A Free-Floating ‘Planemo’ Binary
We know all too little about planetary-mass objects -- planemos, as Centauri Dreams is learning to call them -- that are not associated with a star. But we've learned a bit more with the discovery of an unusual binary system. Discovered in optical imagery taken by the European Southern Observatory's 3.5 meter instrument in La Silla (Chile), Oph162225-240515 (Oph1622 for short) is a 14-Jupiter mass planemo apparently orbited by a companion of about half that mass. "This is a truly remarkable pair of twins - each weighing some hundred times less than our sun," says Ray Jayawardhana, an associate professor of astronomy and astrophysics at the University of Toronto. "Their mere existence is a surprise, and their origin and fate a bit of a mystery." Following up the find with optical spectra and infrared work, Jayawardhana and ESO's Valentin Ivanov established that both members of the pair are at the same distance from the Sun and far too cool to be stars. They're also young, perhaps a...
Discovering Life by Rover
Jose Garcia writes from the wonderful Meme Therapy, where he's conducting another brain parade, this one asking science fiction writers and scientists a straightforward question: "Do you think it likely that the first discovery of extraterrestrial life will be made by a rover?" The answers to all of Jose's brain parade questions are stimulating and reflect a wide variety of perspectives, from Robert Zubrin's unqualified "No. It will be made by human explorers operating on the surface of Mars," to writer Peter Watts' call for widening the search from planets to comets and molecular dust clouds. Centauri Dreams' guess is that extraterrestrial life may well exist deep within the Martian soil, but the first conclusive proof of life beyond Earth will come by rover and in a more exotic place, such as one of the Galilean moons of Jupiter or, if we want to get truly exotic, in the bizarre deep freeze of Titan. Because this is by nature guesswork, I'm just playing a hunch that Mars is going...