Everybody loves a mystery, and the one surrounding Pioneer has everything going for it, an unusual effect observed via two of the most distant spacecraft ever launched. Both Pioneer 10 and 11 are slowing a bit more than expected as they move through the outer reaches of the Solar System. Explanations range from a variety of on-board causes to suggestions that our understanding of gravity itself needs an upgrade. NASA's Slava Turyshev, as noted in this New Scientist story, is compiling data from the spacecraft that had previously been inaccessible due to data formats and media incompatible with modern equipment. Turyshev's work may take a year to complete, but it holds the promise of nailing what many think to be the probable cause of the anomaly: heat from the RTGs (radioisotope thermoelectric generators) that provide power for the probes. Asymmetrical radiation of that heat just might do the trick. Meanwhile, New Scientist also gets into far more exotic possibilities, noting that...
Exoplanet Announcements at Santorini
Steinn Sigurðsson (Pennsylvania State) has been reporting from the Greek island of Santorini, where he is attending the Extreme Solar Systems conference. I want to send you at once to Steinn's Dynamics of Cats weblog, where updates are being filed and will presumably continue through today, the conference's last day. It sounds like a terrific gathering filled with the energizing news of discoveries, its theme being, in addition to finding Earth-like planets, the study of exoplanets in tricky places like dense star clusters, near giant stars and orbiting pulsars. That last is fitting enough, given that the first extrasolar planets of Earth-like mass were discovered 15 years ago around the pulsar PSR 1257+12; in fact, the conference meets on the occasion of that anniversary and celebrates as well the sixtieth birthday of Alex Wolszczan, the discoverer of those worlds. All of that and beauteous Santorini too, though as Steinn reports, the heat has been the worst since 1916, as per...
The Latest Carnivals of Science
The 11th edition of the monthly science carnival Philosophia Naturalis is now up at Chris Rowan's Highly Allochthonous site, where discussions move from the Higgs boson to Cassini's extended mission, with time in between to investigate puddles on Mars. Take note as well of the weekly Carnival of Space, now in its 9th edition, this week edited on the Planetary Society's weblog by the able Emily Lakdawalla. Here again the range is spacious, with musings on the atmospheres of extrasolar planets to the nano-minded Brian Wang's thoughts on laser systems that could get us to Mars. If you only have time for one, don't miss Pamela Gay's take on gravitational lenses, a fine job on a tool of ever growing importance.
Asteroid Watch: Saving Arecibo’s Radar
"Let's hope that we find all the dangerous asteroids in the next few months," says Cornell astronomer Joseph Burns. He's talking about the Arecibo Observatory in Puerto Rico, which Cornell manages for the National Science Foundation. Word is that Arecibo's radar system may lose its NSF funding as early as 2008, leaving us without our premier tool for tracking asteroids of the Earth-crossing variety. Strictly speaking, Cornell's Arecibo effort runs through the university's National Astronomy and Ionosphere Center (NAIC), which will need to find outside partners to pick up as much as half of the observatory's operating costs or face the threat of total shutdown of the Arecibo telescope by 2011. Image: Aerial view of the Arecibo Telescope, equipped with a 12.6cm, 1.0MW radar transmitter. Credit: NAIC/Cornell University. It's hard to understand why, in its deliberations on the matter, the NSF all but ignored the contribution of Arecibo's radar. In fact, as this Cornell news release makes...
DNA as Cosmic Code
If you possessed technologies so advanced that you could seed life throughout the cosmos, wouldn't you leave some marker that would identify your work? We can't know what a hypothetical extraterrestrial intelligence might do, but we do know enough about human nature to acknowledge the desire for recognition. It shows up every time a new squabble breaks out over who really discovered an exoplanet -- humans crave the praise of their fellows. Yes, if humans had life-seeding technologies, you can bet we would leave signs of our craftsmanship. Consider what the Keio University team working under Masaru Tomito has done in Japan. As explained in a New York Times essay by Dennis Overbye, they've inserted copies of the immortal equation E=mc2, along with the date of its derivation (1905) into the genome of a bacterium. Thus we see DNA as a kind of archival medium. Overbye is reminded of Jaron Lanier and David Sulzer's idea of encoding a year's worth of the New York Times magazine into the...
Woodward, Mach and Breakthrough Propulsion
Four trips to the Moon a day? That's one capability of a theoretical vehicle discussed in last January's newsletter from the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics. I hadn't realized the AIAA was putting these newsletters online until I saw Adam Crowl's post on Crowlspace discussing the above possibility. Adam notes that a vehicle powered by a so-called Mach-Lorentz Thruster (MLT) of the sort being studied by James Woodward (California State University, Fullerton) could not only make the four lunar trips a day but deliver almost 3000 tons of cargo a year. The AIAA story, adapted by Paul March from his later presentation at the 2007 STAIF meeting (Space Technology and Applications International Forum) in Albuquerque, presents several startling scenarios, all of which come down to our understanding of inertia. Go back to the days of Isaac Newton and inertia is seen as an inherent property that causes a body to resist acceleration. Inertia means a body at rest will oppose...
Of Telescopes on the Moon
Putting an enormous radio telescope on the far side of the Moon has so many advantages that it's hard to imagine not doing it, once our technology makes such ventures possible. Whatever the time frame, imagine an attentuation of radio noise from Earth many orders of magnitude over what is possible anywhere on the near side, much less on Earth itself. In a recent telephone conversation, I discussed these matters with Italian space scientist Claudio Maccone, whose work on a mission to the Sun's gravity focus we've examined in these pages before. Having just completed a week at Rutgers attending its Symposium on Lunar Settlements, Maccone anticipates the publication of his new paper on the lunar far side and its scientific potential -- I'll have to put off the specifics of those interesting ideas until the paper actually appears. But do ponder the implications of a radio observatory conceivably able to probe extrasolar planets. As a news item in New Scientist explains: The interaction...
Ceres, Vesta and the Dawn Mission
With launch of the Dawn mission to Ceres and Vesta coming up on July 7, NASA has announced a news conference for next Tuesday, the 26th, to discuss details of the four year journey to the asteroids. Held at NASA headquarters, the event is due to be streamed on the agency's homepage. The Hubble Space Telescope, meanwhile, has provided these images, shown below as a montage, of the two target asteroids. The debris of the asteroid belt, which may house 100,000 or more asteroids as large as ten kilometers across, provides an idea of the kind of materials available for planet-building some 4.6 billion years ago. For those who follow robotic missions with fascination for the rapid strides in technology they represent, consider that Dawn is the first mission sent to orbit two different targets. Vesta will be the first, in 2011, with Ceres following in 2015. The Vesta image (on the right) shows the asteroid's southern hemisphere, which is dominated by an impact crater so large that the...
The Colors of Exobiology
Speaking of bio-signatures, as we did at the end of yesterday's post on planetary atmospheres, take note of the Virtual Planet Laboratory, a working group at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory that is trying to figure out what life's markers might look like across a wide range of biological types. The most obvious signature for life itself is the presence of unusual combinations of things. A world without life shouldn't, for example, give us strong signatures in both methane and oxygen simultaneously. We looked at this subject in an April post, but a recent news release prompts me to put it back into play. The work is highly theoretical, proceeding as it does with no current examples of extrasolar planetary spectra from terrestrial-class worlds to look at. But we can begin with photosynthesis and its variants, as discussed here by Robert Blankenship (Washington University, St. Louis), a member of the group of researchers: "When you consider another world you've got to find that life there...
Modeling Exoplanet Atmospheres
Where does the Solar System keep its water? Beyond Mars, the trend seems to favor more and more water content the farther out we go. Thus Jupiter, which is considered depleted in water, is eclipsed in these terms by Saturn, though that planet has less water than other volatiles. Move on to Uranus and Neptune and you get into serious water enrichment. "The farther out you go in the solar system, the more water you find," says Bruce Fegley (Washington University, St. Louis). Fegley's work, discussed at the Chicago meeting of the American Chemical Society last March, points to a compelling theory about the outer planets: From Jupiter to Neptune, these are worlds whose atmospheres are 'primary,' drawn directly from the solar nebula as the planets of our Solar System were forming. Just as the Sun is rich in hydrogen and helium, Jupiter likewise shows large amounts of hydrogen and helium, though less carbon, nitrogen and oxygen than the other gas giants. Observations of methane, hydrogen...
Interstellar Conundrum: Is Stross Right?
Although people have been recommending that I read Charles Stross' novel Accelerando for some time now, I haven't found the time and now wish that I had. I recently read a fascinating speech that Stross gave at a Munich tech conference discussing, among many other things, how advances in computer storage will change our lives. And now his essay The High Frontier, Redux is exciting controversy, asking whether many of our ideas about spaceflight need to be reassessed in light of the enormity of the challenges we face. Much of what Stross has to say is true, and I hope that those who haven't read the essay will give it a look. The reason why we don't want to minimize the magnitude of the problems we face in interstellar flight is that a clear-eyed view is needed to begin to conceive the radical technologies that may one day solve the problem. And I know too many people who learn how far away the stars really are, even the closest of them, and then throw the whole concept out as wishful...
Stross: The Interstellar Improbability
Science fiction writer Charles Stross, always an insightful voice when it comes to the future of technology, offers up an incisive look at the problems of interstellar flight in his The High Frontier, Redux. The article is in the queue for discussion here, but since I can't get to it until tomorrow afternoon -- and since comments are already flying about what Stross has to say -- I'll set up this topic as a gathering point for those comments until the larger post goes online. Read Stross when you can, as anyone seriously interested in interstellar possibilities needs to understand the magnitude of the challenge. We'll run through some of the issues tomorrow, and look at one Stross comment I find completely puzzling.
Geological Activity on Tethys and Dione?
Centauri Dreams doubts that most space scientists expected to find as much activity around Saturn as the Cassini probe has revealed. Enceladus was spectacular enough, with its geysers spewing material hundreds of kilometers above the surface. And now we find indications that two other moons -- Tethys and Dione -- are active worlds as well. More Cassini close passes will be needed to firm this up. For that matter, data already collected from previous flybys may contain still more clues, which is how things work in planetary science these days -- we collect information at a rate far surpassing our ability to keep up with the inflow. In any event, Cassini's arrival in Saturn space in 2004 made it clear that centrifugal forces caused by the planet's fast rotation (10 hours and 46 minutes) compressed plasma into a disc from which cold, dense plasma from the planet's inner magnetosphere was being flung into space. Hotter plasma from the outer magnetosphere quickly moves in to fill up the...
A Possible Planet around Fomalhaut
Watching the motion of the stars they orbit has been how most of the planets beyond our Sun have thus far been discovered. Such radial-velocity methods are getting more precise all the time, but a likely planet around the nearby star Fomalhaut comes out of an entirely different line of research. Alice Quillen (University of Rochester) is an expert on stellar disks and the planets that help to shape them. And she has learned to predict a planet's size and position from her studies. In the case of Fomalhaut, Quillen worked with Hubble Space Telescope imagery showing the star's surroundings in greater detail than ever before. The Hubble images took advantage of a coronagraph to mask the light of the star to bring out detail in the dimmer ring, confirming what astronomers had previously noted -- Fomalhaut is off-center within its ring. Image: Hubble's view of Fomalhaut's dust ring. Credit: University of Rochester/STScI. Quillen's models examine ring/planet interactions for young stars,...
Cramer’s Time Experiment Funded
When you've read Analog as long as I have -- and I date back to the days when it was named Astounding -- you develop a real fondness for some of the primary players. That's one reason I'm glad to hear the good news about John Cramer's time travel experiment, which has received enough private donations to be pursued. Cramer's 'Alternate View' columns have been running in the magazine since 1984, covering everything from cosmology to space drives and quantum mechanics. I've always admired his clear, straightforward style. A physicist at the University of Washington, Cramer caught the attention of the press in recent months by discussing his hopes of testing the idea of quantum retrocausality. Here we're in the domain of what Cramer calls the Transactional Interpretation, in which the processes of quantum mechanics involve waves traveling both forward and backward in time. His experiment, which may begin as early as next month, will test whether photons can communicate in reverse time....
Musings on Planet X
My younger son Alec can be forgiven a certain amount of confusion over the term 'Planet X.' Back in the 1980s, I told him all about the marvelous Edgar G. Ulmer film The Man from Planet X, a favorite since my own childhood. Ulmer was a gifted director who is rarely talked about today (see his 1945 film Detour for a glimpse of just how gifted). And 1951's The Man from Planet X was compelling in a way that few B movies of the era achieved, with an alien whose spooky presence has stuck with me ever since I first saw him on an old black-and-white set. But then Alec encountered a different 'Planet X' in an astronomy class, learning that some astronomers had searched for a planet beyond Pluto, although at that point with notable lack of success. Planet X was supposed to account for various orbital oddities exhibited by Pluto and become emblematic of a fabulous, unknown place at the very edge of the system that was the ultimate catch for the next Clyde Tombaugh. I didn't think it existed...
Explosions Near Light Speed
Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), those titanic explosions in distant galaxies that some consider to be the most powerful events since the Big Bang, can be more luminous than anything else in the universe, at least for a while. But their moment in the spotlight is brief, less than a second to as much as a few minutes, and questions about their origins abound. Astronomers expecting speeds close to the 300,000 km/s of light itself for the material exploding from these bursts have now been vindicated by measurements made at the European Southern Observatory's La Silla facility. Image: Light curve of the gamma-ray burst of 7 June 2006, GRB 060607A. The red dots are the data obtained with the REM telescope observing the afterglow (in the near-infrared H-band) of the burst from 73 seconds after the explosion. The blue line is a fit to the data, allowing the astronomers to determine the peak of the light curve and so, derive the velocity of the material. (c) ESO. Space-to-ground coordination is...
Pondering an Ocean Beneath Titan
An underground ocean on Titan? The apparent detection of low frequency radio waves makes liquid water beneath the surface of the huge Saturnian moon a possibility, according to research led by Fernando Simoes (Centre d'Etudes Terrestres et Planetaires, Saint Maur, France). Simoes and team have been studying what New Scientist is describing as an 'enigmatic radio signal' that the European Space Agency's Huygens probe detected as it descended to Titan's surface in 2005. The signal seems not dissimilar to what lightning produces on Earth, where low frequency signals bounce between the ground and the upper atmosphere, in the process attenuating some frequencies while enhancing others. But Titan's surface seems to be a poor reflector, meaning there may be a better one below. Thus the talk of an ocean, although it's just one candidate. "We do not need a subsurface ocean but require a subsurface reflector," Simoes told New Scientist. "If a subsurface ocean exists, the solid-liquid interface...
Transitsearch Ups the Ante
Buy a commercial telescope today, equip it with a CCD detector, and you're arming yourself to enter the exoplanet hunt. A CCD, or charge-coupled device, is a sensor that proves far more efficient than photographic film at capturing incoming light. It wasn't so long ago that such tools were available only at large observatories, but no more. Today's amateur can observe a planetary transit, sensing the slight dimming that the planet causes to the starlight as seen from Earth. The trick is knowing when and where to look, and on that score, the Transitsearch network, often working with the American Association of Variable Star Observers, offers ephemeris and transit search results for stars thought to be candidates for such detections. For those new to the term, an ephermeris (pl. ephemerides) is a table plotting the position of celestial bodies. Look to Transitsearch for an example. Greg Laughlin (UC Santa Cruz) noted this morning on the systemic site that he was overhauling the look...
Michaud’s Contact with Alien Civilizations
I'm glad to see Universe Today's review of Michael Michaud's new book Contact with Alien Civilizations: Our Hopes and Fears about Encountering Extraterrestrials (Springer, 2006), since I haven't gotten to it yet despite a promise early in the year. Those hoping for a thorough analysis of the Drake Equation are in luck, since Michaud evidently tweaks every parameter to see what happens as a result. Many of the issues raised here are things we've kicked around on Centauri Dreams, as is apparent in this excerpt from the review: Are we alone; does the universe revolve around our species; and, is everything in existence for the use of humans? As well, should humans be trying to contact aliens; with what urgency should we start populating outer space; and, how should we react to alien contact? As an example, what would we do if it came to our attention tomorrow that aliens were colonizing Mars? These questions about our actions, our purpose and ourselves serve hopefully, to make the reader...