Budding astrobiologists should be thinking about the significance of red dwarf stars as they approach their careers. Let's say, as pure speculation, that one out of every thousand stars in class M has a planet in the habitable zone. That works out to 75 million potentially habitable planets around these stars in our galaxy alone. Note the assumptions I'm making. First, I peg M dwarfs at 75 percent of the galactic population. That figure is widely in use and I've just run across it again in a new paper by Paul Shankland (US Naval Observatory), David Blank (James Cook University, Australia) and colleagues, about which more in a moment. Another assumption: That the Milky Way holds about one hundred billion stars. That's low-balling the number, I think, because estimates seem to start at that figure and go up to four or five times as high. So my 75 million potentially habitable planets, while just a guess, may not be totally off the wall. Image: An artist's impression of a gas giant...
Notes & Queries 3/29/08
Did short supplies of oxygen and molybdenum slow down the evolution of animal life? Ancient oceans low on molybdenum would create problems for bacteria that use the element to convert atmospheric nitrogen into a form useful for living things. Brian Wang muses over these matters in his entry in the latest Carnival of Space, referring to a recent Nature paper and moving on to look at potential oceans in the Solar System, from Titan to Callisto, Ganymede, Enceladus, and of course, Europa. Can life could develop in such places, and if so, how long would it take? Brian frames the question in relation to the Fermi paradox. Perhaps the universe takes a lot longer to evolve complex life than we have been assuming, with implications for what we might find on planets around other stars. We're shooting in the dark on these questions, unable to say whether life exists off-planet in our own Solar System, but the day may not be so far off when results around nearby planets give us another...
Intriguing Temperatures on Enceladus
Cassini's recent pass through the plumes of Enceladus resulted in a number of intriguing finds, perhaps the most interesting of which is the temperature along the 'tiger stripes.' These are the fissures from which Enceladus' famous geysers erupt. Cassini's Composite Infrared Spectrometer found them to be warm along almost their entire length, reaching no less than minus 93 degrees Celsius (-135 F). The warmest regions correspond to two visible geyser locations. The contrast in temperatures is striking: The differential between these regions and other areas on Enceladus is a whopping 93 degrees Celsius (200 F). This heat map gives a sense of what we're dealing with. The brightest fracture, known as Damascus Sulcus and visible at lower left in the image, shows the highest temperatures. In this image, the false color infrared data are superimposed on a grayscale mosaic of the south pole that dates back to the summer of 2005. The map was made at a distance of between 14,000 and 32,000...
Life’s Precursors: The Interstellar Connection
Was the early Earth seeded with amino acids from deep space? The variety of molecules found between the stars makes the supposition provocative, but finding interstellar amino acids has been a challenge. Various amino acids have indeed been found in meteorites, but it has been argued that these could have been produced right here in the Solar System within asteroids. Yet laboratory experiments have shown that amino acids can form among the molecules found in interstellar clouds, including such important ones as glycine, alanine and serine. What's next is to identify amino acids in the interstellar medium, and we're coming close. Ponder this: Since 1965, more than 140 molecules have been identified in space, both in interstellar clouds and circumstellar disks, many of them organic or carbon-based. Now researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy in Bonn have detected amino acetonitrile (NH2CH2CN), a potential precursor of the simplest amino acid, glycine. The odds are...
TESS: All Sky Survey for Transiting Planets
I've never met George Ricker, but in at least one respect I believe he thinks the way I do. Ricker is senior research scientist at MIT's Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Research, and he's someone who can connect the exoplanetary systems we study with places we might eventually go. As witness this comment in a discussion of a planned satellite-based observatory being designed at the Institute: "Decades, or even centuries after the TESS survey is completed, the new planetary systems it discovers will continue to be studied because they are both nearby and bright. In fact, when starships transporting colonists first depart the solar system, they may well be headed toward a TESS-discovered planet as their new home." It's wonderful to see a 'when' rather than an 'if' when referring to starships, even though everyone concerned can appreciate the blue-sky nature of the comment. For my part, I'll take whatever the physics will bear, from close-up imagery of terrestrial exoplanets...
Death and Life in a Distant Galaxy
By Larry Klaes One response to Fermi's famous 'Where are they?' question is to speculate on factors that might destroy incipient life forms. The recent gamma ray burst seen halfway across the universe reminds us of the powers that can be unleashed within a galaxy. Now Tau Zero journalist Larry Klaes goes to work on two galaxies 1.4 billion light years from Earth whose destinies are in some ways intertwined. Are we witnessing the possible annihilation of civilizations? Being tiny creatures who have spent our existence on and around a rather insignificant ball of rock, it is often quite difficult for humans to imagine the infinitely vaster Universe we live in. As the late author Douglas Adams once said in his famous series, The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy: "Space…is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly hugely mindboggingly big it is. I mean you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist [pharmacy], but that's just peanuts to space." Not only are...
Musings on Titan’s Sub-Surface Ocean
The recent news that there may be an underground ocean on Titan tantalizes us in astrobiological terms. It also brings us up against the question of how to define a habitable zone. The standard definition involves the presence of liquid water at the surface, a reasonable requirement when you're looking for carbon-based life. But it's also true that exobiology may one day be studying forms of life that are nothing like us, living in environments we would at first dismiss from our list of living places. Just how far does a habitable zone extend? First, a short defense of the status quo. As we expand our exoplanet hunt and become capable of detecting the signature of life on distant planets, we need a target list to optimize our search time. It's entirely reasonable to fine-tune that list toward conditions similar to what we find on Earth because the life on our planet is the only kind we've been able to study. Detecting its biomarkers in an alien atmosphere is a sensible goal. We know...
GRB Visible Halfway Across the Universe
The recent news of a record-setting gamma ray burst (GRB) in a distant galaxy doesn't just raise eyebrows. It practically singes them. Occurring in the midst of a 24-hour period that saw five gamma ray bursts (a story in itself), the burst called GRB 080319B was picked up by the Swift satellite on March 19 and traced to the constellation Boötes. The afterglow brightened to magnitudes between 5 and 6, meaning that in dark locations, people with normal vision could have seen the burst remnant with the naked eye. How extreme was this burst? Ponder the implications of what Derek Fox (Pennsylvania State University) has to say: "These optical flashes from gamma-ray bursts are the most extreme such phenomena that we know of. If this burst had happened in our galaxy it would have been shining brighter than the Sun for almost a minute -- sunglasses would definitely be advised." Brighter than the Sun. All of this makes the optical afterglow of GRB 080319B 2.5 million times more luminous than...
Organic Molecule in Exoplanet Atmosphere
Well-studied HD 189733b is a Jupiter-sized planet again in the news. Studying this transiting world, scientists using Hubble Space Telescope data have made the first identification of an organic molecule -- methane -- in the atmosphere of an exoplanet. What's particularly significant here is the growing sophistication of our use of spectroscopy, splitting light into its components to tease out the constituents of the atmosphere under study. This new finding shows that we're on target in planning to use space-based observatories to make far more challenging detections. Image: A wide field image of the region of sky in which HD 189733b is located. In this image we can see the asterism of the "Summer Triangle" a giant triangle in the sky composed of the three bright stars Vega (top left), Altair (lower middle) and Deneb (far left). HD 189733b is orbiting a star very close to the centre of the triangle. Credit: A. Fujii. Methane in the atmosphere of a gas giant wouldn't rank as a...
Starships, Pubs and Sir Arthur
I'm a great believer in getting back to work when bad news hits, and I suspect Arthur C. Clarke was as well. His almost 100 books surely attest to the fact. With intriguing exoplanet news about to be released, that is exactly what I've been doing this morning, with an article I'll post tomorrow. As I've been developing that story, I've kept pondering what to say about Clarke, working up a kind of reminiscence in the back of my mind, then deciding everything was happening too fast for that. Not that his death was a surprise, Sir Arthur having been ill for quite some time, but the thought of a world without Clarke in it takes a bit of getting used to. I'll need some time to take its measure. Oddly, my favorite of his books was the relatively obscure 1957 collection Tales from the White Hart. The yarns in this slim volume involve one Harry Purvis, like Clarke a polymath who deals knowledgeably on most any subject, and a man whose improbable accounts flummox the ready audience in the...
Arthur C. Clarke, R.I.P.
No time this evening to do anything more than pass along the sad news that we have lost one of our greatest visionaries. The BBC has the story, and the New York Times offers a lengthy obituary.
If the Phone Doesn’t Ring, It’s Me
The line in the title above is from a Jimmy Buffett song. A friend who knows all Buffett songs line by line uses it on his answering machine, invariably provoking a chuckle when I ponder the implications. If the phone doesn't ring, just what kind of message is being sent? Or is any message being sent at all? Thus does the singer capture the bewildered funk of romantic attachments, which can make hash out of all our logic. Like the dog that doesn't bark (think Sherlock Holmes), the phone that doesn't ring carries its own meaning, one we must now try to parse. For the SETI phone isn't ringing. If extraterrestrial civilizations are out there, is their silence a way of sending us a message? Alan Tough created a Web site with the express purpose of offering a communications venue to any nearby alien probes, spacecraft designed to study us and report home. The Invitation to ETI contains a number of essays explaining the project and more or less asking for participation by ET (Paul Davies'...
Organics, Water in Protoplanetary Disk
We have interesting news coming up this week with regard to the first detection of methane in the atmosphere of an exoplanet, of significance because it demonstrates that we can detect organic molecules using spectroscopy in ways that will one day help us study the atmospheres of terrestrial worlds around other stars. More on this later in the week, after a NASA teleconference scheduled for the 19th. Today, though, let's talk about another kind of detection in the circumstellar disk of a young star. At work in the latter is the Spitzer Space Telescope's infrared spectrograph, which is being put to use to look at the composition of protoplanetary disks. Specifically, John Carr (Naval Research Laboratory) and Joan Najita (National Optical Astronomy Observatory, Tucson) have been examining gases in the planet forming region around the star AA Tauri, using refined methods that have allowed them to find the spectral signatures of three organic molecules: Hydrogen cyanide, acetylene and...
Human Outcomes Among the Stars
Does transhumanism have a serious objective? The question resonates oddly yet provocatively given the stakes being considered. Augmenting the human frame potentially expands our powers, while the goal of uploading consciousness seems to offer a kind of immortality. These are surely desirable steps, but some versions of a posthuman future seem to point toward triviality, an existence within a simulated reality within a computational matrix, an awareness that sees no need to explore when simulation and observation can suffice. Can we avoid such a result? I have a visceral, non-digital sense that a 'singularity,' if it occurs, will not include pushing minds evolved over eons to cope with a physical biosphere into digital frameworks. I doubt seriously that a human consciousness could make the adaptation -- madness is the likely result. Hardly an expert on any of the relevant disciplines, I could well be wrong, but I noted Athena Andreadis' thoughts on this issue in a recent entry on her...
Time, Tides and Habitability
Keep your eye on Gliese 581. Not that the news is necessarily good for our hopes for habitability around that star -- in fact, a recent paper suggests quite the opposite. The red dwarf exploded into the public consciousness with the announcement that one of its planets -- Gl 581 c -- could conceivably support clement temperatures and water at the surface, at least in places. But in exploring that possibility, we're getting a case study of world-class science at work, analyzing data, offering hypotheses, broadening options. It's an exciting process to watch. Gl 581 d is now being analyzed for habitability, while Gl 581 c begins to appear less and less likely as a home to life. It may take decades and new space-based observatories for the issue to be resolved, but we now have a new take on Gl 581 c, embedded in a broader study of tidal evolution as planetary systems evolve. The study has implications not just for rocky worlds but for planetary formation in many scenarios. The work of...
Cassini: Close Pass Skirts Enceladus Plumes
One question jumps out at me from the blog entries that Cassini team members have been posting on the probe's dazzling close pass by Enceladus. It's from deputy project scientist Linda Spilker, who says: "I am thinking about the two Voyager flybys of the Saturn system that took place over 25 years ago. How in the world did we miss the Enceladus plumes back then???" Indeed, but that's the nature of exploration, to learn something new each time you revisit a place, especially one that's fully 10 AU out. The process is addictive, and breathtaking. Do be aware of the flyby blog, offering an inside view of one of the most interesting of Cassini's encounters thus far (also be aware that the entries are oddly out of order, a problem apparently being fixed). With the data downlink now started (as of about 0201 UTC today) via the Deep Space Network's Goldstone station, we can ponder the chutzpah of taking a spacecraft so close to the huge geysers erupting out of the south pole of Enceladus....
Moving (and Saving) the Planet
The ever reliable Dennis Overbye gives us a look at the Earth's fate in his most recent story for the New York Times. Citing the work of Klaus-Peter Schroeder (University of Guanajuato, Mexico) and Robert Connon Smith (University of Sussex), Overbye describes our planet's eventual engulfment by a red giant Sun. Earlier studies had questioned whether the Earth might survive this phase, but Smith and Schroeder say no. Their calculations show a red giant Sun 256 times as wide as today's star, and fully 2730 times more luminous. And it will swallow the Earth. I was interested to see Overbye's reference to a 2001 paper that, in the spirit of speculative jeu d'esprit familiar in good science fiction, looks at a way to save the planet. But first, let's run through where our star is heading. Burning through its hydrogen on the main sequence, the Sun should keep getting hotter and larger. Figure 1.1 billion years until you reach the point where it is 11 percent brighter than today, creating a...
In Praise of Ancient Light
How things change over time has never been as strikingly demonstrated as in recent findings. If you go back to the distant era when the universe was only 380,000 years old, you find that neutrinos made up fully ten percent of the universe. Given that these sub-atomic particles moving at nearly the speed of light are so abundant today that millions of them pass through us every second, you'd think they compose a substantial portion of today's universe, but they actually account for less than one percent. And the change in neutrino ratio is only the beginning. For according to five years of recently released data from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP), the early universe was composed of 12 percent atoms, 15 percent photons, almost no dark energy, and 63 percent dark matter. The contrast is stark, given WMAP estimates of the current cosmos: 4.6 percent atoms, 23 percent dark matter, 72 percent dark energy. And, of course, those greatly diminished neutrinos. Image: WMAP...
TEDI: Looking for Planets Around Small Stars
A new observing program designed to study planets around small, cool stars is in the works. TEDI, the TripleSpec - Exoplanet Discovery Instrument, saw first light on the 200-inch Hale Telescope just before Christmas, and is now in its commissioning phase, with an observing program scheduled to begin this spring. And for those who occasionally wonder why we seldom discuss stars like Barnard's Star or Proxima Centauri in terms of the planet hunt, read on. For TEDI is the kind of program that should be able to survey not just M dwarfs but L and T class stars as well, opening exciting possibilities for discovery. Planets around Proxima Centauri? Perhaps, and extending all the way down to T-class brown dwarfs makes things interesting as well. But finding such planets is a challenge with conventional radial velocity methods. Here's why: Radial velocity searches are generally conducted in the optical band, and work well with stars, like the Sun, that are bright at these wavelengths. The...
Power Shortage in the Outer Solar System?
As if we didn't have enough trouble getting to the outer Solar System, now comes word that the US inventory of plutonium-238 is diminishing. That's what NASA administrator Mike Griffin told a House appropriations subcommittee this past week, pointing out that after the Mars Science Laboratory launches in 2009, the agency will find itself running out of the plutonium needed to fuel radioisotope power systems. Even New Horizons, on the way to Pluto/Charon, is using Russian plutonium, the periodic purchase of which has been forced by NASA's dwindling supplies. New Horizons' principal investigator Alan Stern told the committee that beyond the Mars Science Laboratory, NASA probably has enough plutonium on hand or on order to fuel the outer planets flagship mission targeted at 2017 and an interim Discovery class mission scheduled to fly a few years earlier, the latter intended, ironically enough, to test more efficient radioisotope power systems now under development. Meanwhile, the outer...