A Beacon-Oriented Strategy for SETI

I've spent so much recent time on two SETI/METI papers by James, Gregory and Dominic Benford because they contain powerful arguments for re-thinking our current SETI strategy. By analyzing how we might construct cost-optimized interstellar beacons, the authors ask what those beacons might look like if other civilizations were turning them toward us. The results are striking: A distant beacon operating for maximum effect consistent with rational expense would offer up a pulsed signal that will be short and intermittent, recurring over periods of a month or year. It will, in other words, be unlike the kind of persistent signal that conventional SETI is optimized to search for. Searches designed to sweep past stars quickly, hoping to find long-lasting beacons whose signature would be apparent, would rarely notice oddball signals that seem to come out of nowhere and then vanish. Tracking such signals, looking for signs of regularity and repetition, calls for a different strategy. Image:...

read more

METI: Learning from Efficient Beacons

If we want to consider how to pick up transmissions from a distant civilization, it pays to consider the most effective strategies for building interstellar beacons here on Earth. This is the method James, Gregory and Dominic Benford have used in twin papers on SETI/METI issues, papers that should be read in conjunction since the METI questions play directly into our SETI reception strategies. It pays to have a microwave specialist like James Benford on the case. Our METI transmissions to date have used radio telescopes and microwaves to send messages to nearby stars. Longer distances will cost more and take much more power. How much would a true interstellar beacon cost, one not limited to the relatively short ranges of recent METI transmissions? Count on something on the order of $10 billion. As to power, Jim is able to quantify the amount. To reach beyond roughly a thousand light years with a microwave beacon, an Effective Isotropic Radiated Power (EIRP) greater than 1017 W must...

read more

SETI: Figuring Out the Beacon Builders

Several interesting papers on SETI have appeared in recent days, among them Gregory, James and Dominic Benford's attempt to place SETI in the context of economics. Equally useful is Duncan Forgan's new look at the Drake Equation, presenting a way to estimate the distribution of the crucial parameters. I'll bypass the Forgan paper temporarily because I've asked Marc Millis to tackle it as soon as he gets back from the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, where he's gone to attend a workshop. Forgan's study has direct bearing on a Tau Zero initiative we hope to have in place by the end of the year and thus is a natural for Marc to write up. But back to the Benfords, who have offered up twin papers (as seems reasonable for the brothers), one on SETI (with Gregory as principal author) and the other on its METI offshoot (transmitting messages rather than listening for them). James Benford is lead author on the latter. This work is so rich that I won't try to encapsulate it in a single post, but...

read more

Asteroid Belts, Possible Planets Around Epsilon Eridani

Two asteroid belts around Epsilon Eridani? So we learned yesterday, a fascinating find and one I want to discuss today, but only after celebrating Epsilon Eridani itself. Can any star have a more interesting pedigree? This is one of the Project Ozma stars, the other being Tau Ceti, that Frank Drake targeted in the first attempt to listen in on extraterrestrial civilizations. The Centauri stars seemed less likely then, in an era when multiple systems were thought to be hostile to planetary formation. But Epsilon Eridani and Tau Ceti were both single, Sun-like stars, surely possible homes to planets not much different from ours. Or so we thought. We've since learned that Tau Ceti's chances as a home to flourishing civilizations are diminished by the likelihood of intense cometary bombardment, while Epsilon Eridani itself is young enough (850 million years) that any parallel with our own Solar System, where life has had billions of years to attain technology, breaks down. But these...

read more

A Filament of Dark Matter?

Ponder the image below, which scientists at Tel Aviv University are interpreting in terms of the structure of the universe itself. The work draws on the well established notion that large galaxies are found on bubble-like structures -- the soap bubble analogy is inevitable -- with smaller dwarf galaxies scattered along the bubble surface. The Tel Aviv team thinks it has discovered visible traces of a filament of dark matter around which galaxies form. Filaments would be found at the juncture of two bubbles where the membrane is presumably thickest. Thus the image, which shows fourteen galaxies studied at the university's Wise Observatory. Here the galaxies are thought to stretch along a line extending from the lower right to the upper left corner. In its paper, the team calls the grouping "...a single kinematically well-behaved ensemble." The area studied is intriguing not only because the galaxies found here seem to be forming in a line, but also because thirteen of them show new...

read more

COROT’s First Look Inside Distant Stars

Asteroseismology is the science of looking inside a star by studying the oscillations made by sound waves as they move throughout its interior. A recent news release from the COROT team calls these 'Sun-quakes' when they occur on our own star, and points out that the effect can be compared to seismic waves on Earth, whose examination can tell us much about what is happening below the surface. The Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO) mission, launched in 1995, studies our Sun's oscillations, but COROT is now extending the science to other stars. All three of the stars the mission has studied for this purpose -- HD49933, HD181420 and HD181906 -- are main sequence stars hotter than the Sun. And while stellar oscillations can be studied by ground observatories, moving to space offers serious advantages. So says Malcolm Fridlund, ESA project scientist for COROT, who notes the limitations of such observations when made from Earth: "Adverse weather conditions, plus the fact that you...

read more

Hunting for Exoplanet Moons

We're all interested in transiting planets smaller than the Neptune-sized Gliese 436b, and sure to find many of them as our methods improve. One day soon, via missions like COROT or the upcoming Kepler, we'll be studying planets close to Earth mass and speculating on conditions there. But here's a scenario for you: Suppose the first Earth-mass detection isn't of a planet at all, but a moon orbiting a much larger planet? That challenging scenario comes from David Kipping (University College London) in a new paper on the detection of such moons. I should be calling them 'exomoons,' the satellites of planets around other stars. It's reasonable enough to assume they're out there in the billions given the nature of our own Solar System. And compared to the multitude of giant planets found thus far, an Earth-mass exomoon in the habitable zone would seem to offer a far more benign environment for life. The trick, of course, is to pull off a detection, for most exomoons are going to be...

read more

A Volcanic Jump-Start for Life?

A new look at Stanley Miller's experiments at the University of Chicago in the early 1950s offers up an intriguing speculation: Volcanic eruptions on the early Earth may have been crucial for the development of life. Miller used hydrogen, methane and ammonia to re-create what was then believed to be the the primordial atmosphere on our planet, operating with closed flasks containing water in addition to the gases. An electric spark was then used to simulate lightning, and as anyone who has ever cracked a textbook knows, the water became laden with amino acids after a few weeks. Image A: The apparatus used for Miller's original experiment. Boiled water (1) creates airflow, driving steam and gases through a spark (2). A cooling condenser (3) turns some steam back into liquid water, which drips down into the trap (4), where chemical products also settle. Credit: Ned Shaw, Indiana University. It never occurred to me that samples from the original experiments might have survived after all...

read more

Remembering Starwisp

Mention beamed propulsion and people invariably think you're talking about lasers. The idea seems obvious once you've gotten used to solar sail principles -- if photons from the Sun can impart momentum to push a sail, then why not use a laser beam to push a sail much farther, into the outer Solar System and beyond? These are regions where sunlight is no longer effective, but a laser infrastructure of the kind envisioned by Robert Forward could produce a tightly collimated beam that could drive the sail to an appreciable fraction of the speed of light. But are lasers the best way to proceed? Although he would sketch out a range of missions with targets like Alpha Centauri and, the most audacious of all, Epsilon Eridani (this for a manned crew, with return capability!), Forward himself quickly turned away from lasers and began exploring microwave propulsion. I'm fairly certain the turn to microwaves came at Freeman Dyson's suggestion, and when I asked Dyson about it in an interview...

read more

An Interstellar Talk (and More) Online

Few places on Earth please me more than the Scottish highlands, to the point that I used to daydream about moving to Inverness (this was before that city's population explosion, back when it weighed in at a sedate 50,000 inhabitants). But I'll take anywhere in Scotland, and when I realized I wouldn't be able to make the International Astronautical Congress in Glasgow this time around, I found myself sinking into a multi-day funk. Fortunately all is not lost, as the IAC, organized this year by the British Interplanetary Society, has left a digital record behind. The Web is second best to being there, to be sure, but it helps to be able to listen in on key talks. I'll leave you to page through the images and video from the event, pleased to note that Kelvin Long's highlight lecture Fusion, Antimatter & The Space Drive is available in its entirety. Interstellar advocate Long is a member of the BIS as well as an active player in the Tau Zero Foundation. If you can set aside 45 minutes or...

read more

IBEX: Viewing the Edge of the Solar System

Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX) may be the perfect name for the mission to be launched on Sunday the 19th, but the word 'interstellar' has some people thinking this is a precursor mission, headed out for deep space in the fashion of the Voyagers or New Horizons. Nothing could be further from the truth. IBEX is destined for a sedate though distant orbit reaching 240,000 kilometers above the Earth. Its instruments are the interstellar component, enabling the spacecraft to study the ever-changing boundary between the heliosphere and the true interstellar medium. Two Energetic Neutral Atom cameras are the operative tools, capable of detecting atoms emitted from this distant region. This is a fascinating mission for interstellar advocates, for we're looking at the effect of the solar wind as it collides with the cloud of interstellar materials through which the Earth moves. The shock wave that occurs where the solar wind meets the edge of the 'bubble' of materials streaming out from...

read more

Earthlike Planets: The Visibility of Youth

Directly imaging a terrestrial planet is going to be a tough challenge. Suppose you were thirty light years from the Sun, looking back at our star in the hope of seeing the Earth. You would face the problem that the Earth and its star show an angular separation of 100 milliarcseconds, a spacing so tiny that the far brighter Sun would render its third planet (and all the others) invisible. Indeed, in optical wavelengths the Earth is ten billion times less bright than the Sun. How to go about seeing it? Observing at other wavelengths offers some help. The Sun is only a million times brighter than the Earth in the mid-infrared, which is why our first glimpse of planets like ours will probably be in this range. And it may be that our first catch is not a mature, established planet potentially offering a habitat to living organisms. Instead, it may be a clump of molten rock still glowing brightly from the heat of formation. Even after surface magma solidifies -- and new work suggests this...

read more

Hellish Weather on ‘Hot Jupiters’

If the weather on Uranus, examined here yesterday, isn't exotic enough for your taste, consider the situation on Jupiter-class worlds around other stars. A 'hot Jupiter' orbiting extremely close to its star spawns weather like nothing we've ever experienced, as modeled by computer simulations coming out of the University of Arizona. And while we can't actually image these objects yet, we can certainly deduce a great deal about them from observations made during the times they transit their star. On that score, well-studied HD 189733b is an early example of pushing the envelope. Located 63 light years from Earth, this transiting planet orbits once every 2.2 days, scooting along a mere three million miles from its primary. Spitzer Space Telescope data culling variations in starlight during the frequent planetary transits have allowed us to peg daytime temperatures on worlds like these, usually in a range somewhere between 2000 and 3000 degrees Fahrenheit (1300 and 1900 degrees Kelvin)....

read more

Vivaldi’s Nightmare: Seasonal Change on Uranus

No one ever said that Uranus was anything but a strange world. Nineteen times farther from the Sun than the Earth, the planet's equator is tilted 98 degrees from its orbital plane. The tilt is so profound that if you work out the averages, the Uranian poles get more sunlight than the equator. That could lead to interesting weather patterns on a world with an 84-year orbit where seasons last twenty-one years. Such seasonal subjects have been the subject of recent study using imagery from the Keck II instrument in Hawaii, the results presented at the Division for Planetary Sciences meeting this week in Ithaca, NY. Uranus reached equinox in 2007 when the Sun attained a position directly over the planet's equator. Having equal amounts of sunlight over northern and southern hemispheres is obviously not a routine occurrence for this planet, but it's a good chance to look at what's happening on the meteorological front. Lawrence Sromovsky (University of Wisconsin) notes that seasonal...

read more

Habitability: Tides Tell the Tale

How tides affect habitability has become a sub-genre within exoplanetary studies, a theme pushed hard by the gifted trio of Brian Jackson, Rory Barnes and Richard Greenberg (University of Arizona). You may want to browse through earlier Centauri Dreams entries on their work, especially this fascinating take on habitability around M dwarfs, in which the authors consider the possibility that Gliese 581 c was once a relatively benign place, but is now in an orbit that renders life impossible. Orbital evolution is the broad issue, sustained complex life demanding planets with low eccentricities. And orbital evolution can take a lot of time to operate. Now I see that Brian Jackson has presented new work on tides and habitability at the 40th annual meeting of the Division of Planetary Sciences in Ithaca, NY. Here we push into interesting questions about planets already inside a habitable zone that are nonetheless too hellish to support life, and planets outside that zone that seem too cold...

read more

Finding Terrestrial Worlds in the Dust

Computer simulations are showing us how to detect the signature of Earth-like planets -- indeed, planets nearly as small as Mars -- around other stars. That interesting news comes out of NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center, where a supercomputer named Thunderbird has been put to work studying dusty disks around stars similar to the Sun. Varying the size of the dust particles along with the mass and orbital distance of the planet, the team led by Christopher Stark (University of Maryland) ran 120 different simulations. "It isn't widely appreciated that planetary systems -- including our own -- contain lots of dust," Stark says. "We're going to put that dust to work for us." Indeed. Useful and observable things happen as dust responds to the forces acting upon it. For one thing, starlight can exert a drag that causes dust particles to move closer to the parent star. More to the point, particles spiraling inward can become involved in orbital resonances with planets in the system. A...

read more

The Space Outlook from Kentucky

If you can put together a consortium that takes in a variety of public and private organizations, then seed it with university expertise, you can start involving yourself in space research. Take a look at what Kentucky Space is all about. I'm reminded of its ongoing efforts by the fact that its blog is currently hosting the Carnival of Space, reporting in the introduction on its upcoming sub-orbital mission, scheduled for launch today from the Mojave desert. Kentucky Space's projects have included KySat, a student-led initiative involving small satellites from design to launch and operation. This is an active and interesting program well worth your attention, and its Web presence is ably enlivened by Wayne Hall, who presents the current Carnival materials. Of these, I point you to Colony Worlds and its enjoyable musings on dogs in space. Headed out for Mars for a couple of years, or perhaps planning on settling in a distant colony, maybe an O'Neill habitat somewhere out around L-5?...

read more

Earth as Pixel: The Extrasolar Lesson

Why would you want to take pictures of Earth from a spacecraft in orbit around Venus? Aside from the wish to see a familiar place from a distant location, our planet can also become an interesting testbed for exoplanetary studies. We've run into this idea before in the EPOXI mission, which is the combined extended mission of the Deep Impact spacecraft. Here the cometary component of Deep Impact was recently augmented with observations of Earth that can suggest how to study the glint of light off distant oceans, or the signature of land masses. The extrasolar component of EPOXI is called EPOCh, for Extrasolar Planet Observation and Characterization, and it primarily involves an examination of stars with known transiting planets, looking for other planets in the system (EPOXI can detect transits of objects down to about half the diameter of the Earth) or possibly moons around the known ones. Meanwhile, the spacecraft continues its journey to comet Hartley 2 for observations there, its...

read more

Enceladus Flyby: Deep Into the Plume

The last time Cassini flew past Saturn's moon Enceladus (August 11), temperatures over one of the so-called 'tiger stripe' fractures at the south pole were lower than had been measured on an earlier flyby in March. Two October encounters, one of them scheduled for today, may provide enough additional data to help us understand what's going on. The fracture in question is known as Damascus Sulcus, which showed temperatures between 160 and 167 Kelvin in August, but 180 degrees Kelvin during the March flyby. Then again, nothing about Enceladus should surprise us any longer, including an apparent change in the intensity of the plume, within which trace amounts of organics have been detected. The October 9 approach takes us to a distance closer than any previous flyby of a Saturnian moon, a mere 25 kilometers from the surface, a key objective being to study the composition of the plume with the spacecraft's field and particle instruments. Thus Tamas Gambosi (University of Michigan, Ann...

read more

Asteroid Encounters and the Public Response

Now here's an interesting question. What would happen if a small asteroid like 2008 TC3, the three-meter object that exploded in the atmosphere late Monday, were headed for a large city? We were able to judge with a high degree of confidence that 2008 TC3 would pose no threat to the surface, and indeed, early reports suggest that its energies -- 1.1 to 2.1 kilotons of TNT -- were expended in the atmosphere. But even the most confident scientists might be hard put to sell the case for calm if the public started imagining worse case outcomes. David Morrison (NASA Ames) has written about the public response to a small impact scenario, a fact I'm drawing from the recent update of NEO News sent to me by Larry Klaes. Also available is a report from spaceweather.com of a visual sighting of the event, sent along by Jacob Kuiper, general aviation meteorologist at the National Weather Service in the Netherlands:: "Half an hour before the predicted impact of asteroid 2008 TC3, I informed an...

read more

Charter

In Centauri Dreams, Paul Gilster looks at peer-reviewed research on deep space exploration, with an eye toward interstellar possibilities. For many years this site coordinated its efforts with the Tau Zero Foundation. It now serves as an independent forum for deep space news and ideas. In the logo above, the leftmost star is Alpha Centauri, a triple system closer than any other star, and a primary target for early interstellar probes. To its right is Beta Centauri (not a part of the Alpha Centauri system), with Beta, Gamma, Delta and Epsilon Crucis, stars in the Southern Cross, visible at the far right (image courtesy of Marco Lorenzi).

Now Reading

Recent Posts

On Comments

If you'd like to submit a comment for possible publication on Centauri Dreams, I will be glad to consider it. The primary criterion is that comments contribute meaningfully to the debate. Among other criteria for selection: Comments must be on topic, directly related to the post in question, must use appropriate language, and must not be abusive to others. Civility counts. In addition, a valid email address is required for a comment to be considered. Centauri Dreams is emphatically not a soapbox for political or religious views submitted by individuals or organizations. A long form of the policy can be viewed on the Administrative page. The short form is this: If your comment is not on topic and respectful to others, I'm probably not going to run it.

Follow with RSS or E-Mail

RSS
Follow by Email

Follow by E-Mail

Get new posts by email:

Advanced Propulsion Research

Beginning and End

Archives