Any unexpected kink in the debris disk surrounding a young star is often attributed to a planet forming amongst the gas and dust. But that may not be the only explanation. In fact, new work by John Debes and team at NASA GSFC points to an alternative: The motion of the infant system through insterstellar gas. Thus we have yet another reminder that space is not truly empty, and that patches of gas can play their role in planet formation. Debes and colleagues have been looking at infant systems like that around the star HD 32297, some 340 light years from Earth in the constellation Orion. About 100 million years old, the star is surrounded by a dust disk that resembles what our Solar System probably looked like not long after the major planets formed. Noticing that the dust disk around the star was warped, the team was led to link the finding to the presence of nearby interstellar gas clouds. The idea of interstellar gas drag upon a stellar system moving through such a cloud seems a...
Science Fiction and Interstellar Thinking
It's easy to cite science fiction technologies that made their way into real life, starting with, say, submarines and the Jules Verne connection, and pushing on into air travel and, eventually, a spaceship to the Moon. It's also easy to find numerous examples of science fiction being blindsided by technologies no one really predicted. I've read "A Logic Named Joe," but other than Murray Leinster's prescient 1946 tale, did anyone really predict the advent of computers small enough to fit on your desktop, or mobile devices that connect us to a worldwide network for communications and data transfer? Predictions or Dry Runs? This is where I think some science fiction enthusiasts make a mistake in trying to sell their genre as a predictive force. Sure, the examples are there, and we have visionaries like Arthur Clarke who, in addition to crafting spectacular novels of the future, managed to introduce communications satellites into the pages of a popular magazine (Wireless World) before...
Rethinking Planets and Stellar Metals
We often speak about planets migrating from the outer to the inner system of a star, something that helps us put 'hot Jupiters' in context. But what about migration within the galactic disk? It's an idea under continuing investigation. In the absence of direct observational evidence, we infer migration and assume that older stars often come from regions with significantly different metallicity than stars in their current environment. The presumed origin would be the inner disk, which Misha Haywood defines as that part of the galaxy inside the radius from galactic center to our Sun. Dave Moore sent me Haywood's latest paper a few months back and I've been slow in getting to it because I wanted to give its conclusions further thought. It's intriguing stuff. Haywood (Observatoire de Paris) takes note of the fact that we tend to find gas giants around stars that are rich in metals (here a pause to remind newcomers that by 'metals,' we mean elements higher than helium). And he wants to...
?Earth: Crash Course in Building a World
?by Larry Klaes Tau Zero journalist Larry Klaes here gives us a quick overview of the history and future of the Earth, so vital for understanding not only how life emerged here but how it may appear around other stars. It's good to keep this background in mind as Kepler and COROT go planet-hunting. Thus far we've had our share of surprises as we've explored other systems, and doubtless there will be many more as future instruments come online, both in space and on the ground. And as Larry reminds us, there is much we still have to learn about our own planet. Let's look at our celestial home’s place in time as well as space, namely the long and ancient history of its cosmic birth and development. This story includes a general history of the wide variety of living beings that dwell just about everywhere on this planet. Planet Formation and the Big Collision Earth’s geological history began about five billion years ago, roughly eight billion years after the Universe got its start in the...
Building Infrastructure: The Tether Option
Conservation of energy means we never really get something for nothing. Nonetheless, the idea of propellantless propulsion is profoundly important for our future in space. A solar sail uses momentum from solar photons to get its boost, letting the Sun serve as the energy source so we don't have to carry heavy fuel tanks and can maximize payload. So propellantless propulsion really means finding sources outside the spacecraft itself to do the work. The Interplanetary Gambit Recently I've finished Michel Van Pelt's book Space Tethers and Space Elevators (Copernicus/Praxis, 2009), a treatment of a technology we seldom consider in these pages because it's more practical in terms of near-Earth solutions. But Van Pelt surveys tethers -- and the space elevator idea, which is built around what could be considered a giant tether -- so comprehensively with regard to the implications of leaving the propellant behind that his book is a must read for those of us interested in deep space...
The Closest Dwarf
A conference like the recent on in Aosta offers plenty of opportunity to listen in on fascinating conversations, one of which had to do with what would happen if we found a brown dwarf closer to the Earth than the Centauri stars. The general consensus was that such a find would be a powerful stimulus to the public imagination and would probably result in renewed interest in getting to and exploring such a place. A boon, in short, for all our interstellar efforts, an awakening to a new set of possibilities. But if there were a brown dwarf that close, wouldn't we have other signs of it? One figure I heard mentioned at Aosta was three light years. Here I have to do some checking, because I don't recall who dropped that figure or what paper he was referring to, but the upshot was that someone has argued that even a small brown dwarf closer to the Sun than three light years would leave an unmistakable signature in the orbits of our Solar System's planets. I'll see if I can track down the...
Rethinking Stellar Populations
Back in April a paper appeared in the Astrophysical Journal that drew into question our view of star populations. We've assumed since the 1950s that we could count the stars in a particular area of sky by looking at the light from the brightest and most massive stars. In making this assumption, we were tapping the initial mass function, a way of describing the mass distribution of a group of stars in terms of their initial mass. We could, then, estimate the total number of stars based on a sample of the stars that were the easiest to see, assuming that a set number of smaller stars ought to have been created in the same region. Every star twenty or more times as massive as the Sun should be accompanied, in this thinking, by about 500 stars of solar mass or less. But Gerhardt R. Meurer (Johns Hopkins University) and team used data from the Galaxy Evolution Explorer to challenge these proportions. The numbers, it turns out, don't work out as consistently as we had thought. Says Meurer:...
A Stellar Gift to Education in Uganda
Do you have any astronomy books you could spare? Larry Klaes has passed along word from Mimi Burbank, a friend from the History of Astonomy e-mail list who lives and works in Uganda. Living in Kasese, Mimi has been involved in educational activities for people living in a rural area with few resources. She's trying to gather books on astronomy from childrens' books up to adult levels. Mimi writes as follows: The people here are very poor and there are no resources for education, and so I have been asking my friends from all around the world to send books and other things. I have received almost a hundred books for children of all ages, and the little NGO that I work with (BUFO) has achieved extremely high scores on their leaving exams at the end of the school year. They have instituted a Saturday reading hour, during which the older children who can read, read stories out of the books to the younger children who can not yet read, and they all love it. This is the beginning of a...
Gravitational Waves and their Limits
Sometimes what you don't detect tells a scientific story just as important as what you do. In the case of LIGO (Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory) and the VIRGO Collaboration, we're talking about setting limits to the amount of gravitational waves that would have been produced by the Big Bang. Those waves, predicted by Albert Einstein in 1916 and consistent with his theory of General Relativity, should be traceable and quite valuable to us, carrying as they do information about the earliest stages of the universe. Image: Modeling gravitational wave complexity. Laser interferometers should be able to detect the gravitational waves produced by the most violent astrophysical events, such as the merging of two black holes. Credit: MPI for Gravitational Physics/W.Benger-ZIB. The gravitational waves ought to be out there (General Relativity predicts that all accelerating objects should produce them) but they have yet to be observed directly. In fact, the so-called...
Notes & Queries 8/19/09
On Returning to the Moon Interesting to see that the recent debate in the pages of The Economist on whether or not we should return to the Moon has reference to the outer Solar System. The debate pits Gregg Maryniak (James S. McDonnell Planetarium, St. Louis) against Mike Gold (Bigelow Aerospace). Normally the Moon is off our agenda in these pages because of our focus on the outer system and beyond, but my friend Frank Taylor noticed that among Maryniak's arguments for a return to the Moon was its utility as a staging point. Specifically, Maryniak argues that in addition to its other uses, the Moon lets us get our 'space legs' by learning about shielding human crews and 'living off the land' in a deeply inhospitable place. All of this may well lead to lunar power stations or the collection of Helium-3 for fusion projects, a developing technology with profound implications. Writes Maryniak: Once we have the ability to capture and transmit energy at the megawatt and gigawatt levels we...
Amino Acid Detected in Comet Debris
Chalk up another win for the 'life is ubiquitous' school of thought. We now know that when the Stardust spacecraft passed through the gas and dust surrounding comet Wild 2 back in 2004, it captured samples that include glycine. Living things use glycine to make proteins, which made the preliminary detection of this amino acid a significant event, though one that had to be carefully analyzed. After all, terrestrial contamination could have accounted for the glycine gathered up by Stardust. Image: The comet Wild 2 as imaged by the Stardust spacecraft. Credit: NASA/JPL. Ensuing work, however, has ruled out the contamination scenario. The space-gathered samples show significantly more Carbon 13 than glycine from Earth, an isotopic marker that identifies the material as originating in the comet. That gets us back to a welcome thought, that life is common in the universe. Carl Pilcher (NASA Astrobiology Institute) has this to say: "The discovery of glycine in a comet supports the idea that...
Hunting Asteroids (and Money)
A recent report from the National Academy of Sciences points out that NASA has been tasked to locate 90 percent of the most deadly objects that could conceivably strike our planet. Yet only about a third of this assignment has been completed, and the money has yet to be found to complete the job. The agency calculates it needs about $800 million between now and 2020 to make the needed inventory, while $300 million would allow it to find most objects larger than 300 meters across. The problem is that even the smaller sum is not available, and this AP story quotes space policy expert John Logsdon (George Washington University) as saying the money may never come through, calling the program "a bit of a lame duck." In other words, there is not yet enough pressure on Congress to produce the needed funds. Meanwhile, asteroid detection remains a low priority for other governments as well, making this a problem we're choosing to ignore in the absence of recent reminders of its potential....
STEREO: Closing on the Lagrange Points
A note the other day from astrodynamics wizard Edward Belbruno (Princeton University) has put me in mind of the ongoing study of the L4 and L5 points being conducted by the STEREO mission. STEREO is a two-spacecraft observatory designed to study solar activity, but in September and October the craft will be making their closest approach to the two gravitational wells at L4 and L5, and it's possible we'll discover a resident population of asteroids in the process. If so, we may be looking at material from the birthplace of a long-gone planet. Call this hypothetical world, as Belbruno does, Theia. We looked at this secondary mission for STEREO last February, but as Belbruno passed along a link to the 2005 paper on the subject of Theia for which he was lead author, it's time to revisit it. The paper is a lively piece of work, noting that current thinking is that our Moon was the result of a giant impactor, a planetary-sized object that hit the Earth and produced debris that eventually...
WASP-17b: Unusual World Bloated by Tides
Why some planets are the size they are remains something of a mystery. I'm looking at the discovery paper for a planet called WASP-17b, which is said to be twice Jupiter's size but only half its mass. That raises questions about the mechanisms at work, for you can't explain the bloated nature of this world with the models of planetary evolution we're now working with without factoring in massive tidal effects. In one sense, WASP-17b is completely anomalous. In addition to its size, it orbits its star in retrograde fashion, opposite the direction of the star's spin. But in other important respects, the new planet joins the ranks of other bloated worlds like HD209458b (the first such world to be discovered), and a flock of other huge planets that includes TrES-4, WASP-12b, XO-3b and HAT-P-1b. TrES-4 shows a density about fifteen percent that of Jupiter, with a radius 1.78 times larger than Jupiter's. Image: Orbiting close to its parent star, WASP-17b may look something like this, a...
In Praise of K-class Stars
When it comes to exoplanet speculations, we're still in the era when data are few and dominated by selection effect, which is why we began by finding so many 'hot Jupiters' -- such planets seem made to order for relatively short-term radial velocity detections. It's a golden age for speculation, with the promise of new instrumentation and a boatload of information from missions like Kepler and CoRoT to be delivered within a few years. What an extraordinary time to be doing exoplanetary science. The big questions can't be answered yet, but it shouldn't be long before we have an inkling about what kind of stars are most likely to produce terrestrial planets. And maybe a qualification is in order. M-dwarfs are so common in our galaxy -- some estimates run to seventy percent of all stars and up -- that finding habitable worlds around them would hugely increase the possible venues for life. But is there any way we could call planets around M-dwarfs 'Earth-like?' Maybe in terms of...
A Massive Extrasolar Collision
It doesn't take much observation to realize that the early Solar System was a violent place. Mercury seems stripped of its outer crust, doubtless the result of a massive impact, while Uranus was knocked to one side at some point in its history, aligning its spin axis with the plane of the ecliptic. Venus was hit so violently that it rotates clockwise as seen from above, opposite to the other planets. At least, a collision is one of several theories that may explain Venus' retrograde rotation, and it's more than plausible. 100 light years from Earth is a place that reminds us of the impact that produced Earth's own moon billions of years ago. HD 172555 is a young star in the southern constellation Pavo (the Peacock), its twelve-million year old system in its infancy. Spectral analysis from the Spitzer Space Telescope shows clear evidence of a collision much like that between the Earth and that early, Mars-sized object that once struck it. Image: This artist's concept shows a celestial...
Titan: A ‘Fishing License’ to Broaden the Hunt for Life
An exotic planetary environment right here in the Solar System may be a useful test for answering the key question of how common life is in the universe. So argues Jonathan Lunine (University of Arizona) in an upcoming paper. Lunine believes there is a plausible case for life to form on Titan, and that if we were to find it there, its very dissimilarity from Earth would make it a test-case for life in other extreme environments of the sort that may be common in the cosmos. We'd like to answer this question locally because it may be some time before we can answer it around other stars. After all, the best spectral signatures we can hope to get from the atmospheres of Earth-analogues elsewhere are quite possibly going to be ambiguous. Molecular oxygen can be a sign of photosynthesis but also of the abiotic escape of water from the upper atmosphere. Methane in the same atmosphere makes biology more likely but may be, Lunine thinks, difficult to detect from Earth. Image: One way to...
Sharp Early Returns from Kepler
Unlike the Cassini Saturn orbiter, which we looked at yesterday in the context of cryovolcanism on Titan, the Kepler spacecraft has but a single scientific instrument. It's a photometer based on a Schmidt telescope design with a 95 cm aperture and a field of view larger than 100 square degrees. Measuring brightness variations for over 100,000 stars, Kepler is the first mission that should be able to detect Earth-size planets in the habitable zones of their stars. That made yesterday's news conference an eagerly anticipated event, but we have to remember that it's going to be a while before we start talking about terrestrial planet detections. It takes multiple transits and much data analysis to make that possible, and a transiting world at roughly Earth-like distance from its star will demand several years of work. Kepler's baseline mission is three and a half years, more than enough to make such detections, and the good news is that the instrument works. Image: Magnified Kepler...
Notes & Queries 8/6/09
Propulsion Book Discussion Available Give a look, and then a listen, to David Livingston's August 3rd Space Show. Livingston talked to Tau Zero founder Marc Millis and Eric Davis (Institute for Advanced Studies at Austin) about the recently published Frontiers of Propulsion Science, calling it "the ultimate research and reference book to have for advanced and out-of-the-box space propulsion science" and adding: "As you will hear me say over and over again, this is a must own and a must read book. It is also a very valuable research and reference book for anyone wanting to know propulsion and physics facts regarding space travel and related issues." Knowing how much time and effort Marc and Eric spent coordinating the many contributions from leading authorities that went into this book, it's a pleasure to see Frontiers of Propulsion Science achieving this kind of acclaim. At 739 pages and stuffed with technical and scientific papers aimed at scientists and university students, the...
Tuning Up Ion Propulsion
A story on MIT's Technology Review site looks at ion propulsion, and specifically at improvements made in the technology at Glenn Research Center. Comparing the recent work to the engines used in the Deep Space 1 and Dawn missions, the story quotes GRC's Michael Patterson as saying, "We made it physically bigger, but lighter, reduced the system's complexity to extend its lifetime, and, overall, improved its efficiency." That's good news, of course, and Patterson presented it to the AIAA's Joint Propulsion Conference & Exhibit this week in Denver. With sessions on everything from Electric Propulsion Thruster Wear and Life Assessment to Advanced Propulsion Concepts, Denver was clearly the place to be for propulsion mavens. An entire session was devoted to the new ion thrust work, which goes under the name NASA's Evolutionary Xenon Thruster (NEXT). Quoting from an abstract of one of the talks: The NASA NEXT thruster is engineered to be extremely flexible in terms of input power and...