Below you'll see that I'm running Mike Brown's sketch of the 'new' Solar System, one I originally ran with our discussion of Joel Poncy's Haumea orbiter paper, which was presented at Aosta in July. The sketch is germane on a slightly different level today because as we look at how our views of the Solar System have changed over the years, we've learned how many factors come into play, including one Brown's sketch doesn't show. For surrounding the planets and nearer regions of the Kuiper Belt is the heliosphere, that bubble of solar wind materials whose magnetic effects help protect the inner system. Image: Our view of the Solar System has gone from relatively straightforward to one of exceeding complexity. Credit: Mike Brown/Caltech. Look at the heliosphere diagram below and you'll see that while the eight planets are comfortably within it, our Pioneers and Voyagers are pushing toward or through the termination shock on their way to the heliopause. Galactic cosmic rays are shown...
Exoplanet Transits: Maxing Out Our Resources
I'm a great believer in getting the most out of older systems. The computer I do most of my work on is now eight years old. I have access to newer equipment, but I built this box with an eye toward longevity and I'm still happy with it. With the pace of technological change, it's definitely gotten creaky despite additional memory, a new video card and various other upgrades. That means that Windows gets slower and slower on it, but then, I rarely use Windows, being an open source guy to the bone. Linux has always been my choice. Now the nice thing about Linux is that, no matter which version I run (and I've run quite a few by now), I can get snappy performance out of this old box. The astronomical analogy isn't too far to seek -- these days we're talking about building larger and larger Earth-based telescopes, and in fact have just inaugurated the Gran Telescopio Canarias on a 7,874-foot mountaintop in the Canary Islands, an instrument that has the largest segmented mirror -- 10.4...
Notes & Queries 09/28/09
Modeling a Space-Based Future The submission deadline for the MiniSpaceWorld contest has, according to Tibor Pacher, been extended to November 1. Those with a yen to build scale models with a space theme should be considering the possibilities in the project, an exhibit showcasing everything from current rocket technology to basic principles of physics and astronomy, space travel as seen in science fiction and more. MiniSpaceWorld draws on the inspiration of the Miniatur Wunderland in Hamburg, which does for model railroads what Pacher hopes to do for space-themed modelers and educators. Image: Tibor Pacher, who leads the MSW effort. With the help of the Roland Eötvös Physical Society, the MSW design particulars are now being circulated to 1500 secondary school physics teachers in Hungary, which is the reason for the deadline extension. Full particulars can be found on the site, where I notice that the design contest award ceremony will be held in Budapest on December 5. The Hamburg...
Homing In on Planet Formation
Protoplanetary disks may not raise the same level of excitement that the discovery of new planets does, but to me, the idea of watching a planetary system form is awe-inspiring. I can't help but wonder whether, going back about five billion years or so, astronomers around some distant star weren't watching the early signs of planetary formation around our own star. Disks in their various stages give us a sense of the continuity of solar system development. Continuity, that is, in the sense that stars seem to form planets as a matter of course. But we're seeing yet more evidence this week that protoplanetary disks can vary markedly from star to star. Now comes news of the dust cloud around 51 Ophiuchi, which turns out to be not one but two distinct disks, an inner one with grains 10 micrometers and larger in diameter (based on infrared observations), and an outer one made up of primarily 0.1 micrometer grains. Image: This graphic compares the inner and outer disk of the 51 Ophiuchi...
Memories of Jupiter Space
My first glimpse of Ganymede ran like this: Three dead men walked across the face of hell. Their feet groped past frozen rock, now and then they stumbled in the wan light, and always they heard the thin, bitter mumble of wind and felt the cold gnawing at their flesh. Around them there was death, naked stone reaching for a cruel sky of stars, a lean, poisonous whirl of snow which was not snow, that whipped about them and then lay still to crunch under their tread. Jupiter was low in the south, a great shield which glowed amber. That's not today's Ganymede, but a mid-1950's version as seen in Poul Anderson's The Snows of Ganymede (Ace Books, as part of an Ace Double that included Anderson's War of the Wing Men, otherwise known as "The Man Who Counts"). I bought this off a newsstand in St. Louis and remember reading it while waiting for a sandwich to arrive at a lunch counter just off Clayton Rd. I would have been something like nine years old. That memory made the recent news about...
Relativistic Effects on Solar Sails
It's a long way from the back of an envelope to a deployed spacecraft, which is one reason why scientists write papers in journals and gather at conferences. Such venues are where ideas get shaken out, problems identified and solutions proposed. We sometimes talk about realistic technologies like solar sails as if all that remained were to build them, but as Roman Kezerashvili demonstrated at the recent conference in Aosta, there is a range of problems that we are only beginning to consider. Kezerashvili (City University of New York), working with colleague Justin Vazquez-Poritz, has identified a significant area of concern for mission concepts that pass close by the Sun. Often called 'Sundiver' missions (a Gregory Benford coinage, if memory serves), these sails would be so constructed as to survive an extremely close solar pass. Perhaps protected behind an occulter until periherlion, the sail would then be unfurled to receive the full force of the Sun's photons at extremely close...
Regarding METI and SETI Motives
by James Benford I first talked to Jim Benford back in 2003, discussing his work (wih brother Gregory) on microwave beam propulsion. He had already run experiments at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory demonstrating acceleration on a lightsail using these techniques, and was then hoping to run an experiment on The Planetary Society's ill-fated Cosmos 1. The founder of Microwave Sciences, Benford's earlier work at Physics International led to the development of the largest high power microwave experimental facility in the country. Along with continuing work on sail beamed propulsion concepts, the physicist has been actively studying questions of SETI and METI, musing on the kind of beacons we might find and the motivations for building them. Herewith some thoughts inspired by recent discussions in these pages. We explored the motives for a civilization broadcasting to the galaxy at large (which I call Beacons, as they're not targeted at specific stars) in one of the two papers we did last...
Interstellar Beacons: A Silence in Heaven?
by Jon Lomberg It seems fitting that we should be in the midst of a three-part series on SETI and METI issues. As Larry Klaes reminded me in a recent comment, September 19th was the fiftieth anniversary of the paper that began the modern SETI era, Morrison and Cocconi's "Searching for Interstellar Communications" (available here). Artist, lecturer and polymath Jon Lomberg now adds his own take on the discussion. Pay particular attention to the question of signal duration -- would a METI signal be continuous or intermittent? Much rides on the answer. Lomberg is a familiar figure to Centauri Dreams readers. Creator of the Galaxy Garden (Kona, Hawaii), Jon is an astronomical artist working in many media whose work is known throughout the space community and beyond. Viewers of COSMOS will know that he was chief artist on that project, serving as Carl Sagan's principal artistic collaborator for many years. His splendid work on CONTACT, where he storyboarded many of the film's astronomical...
The Why of METI and SETI
?by Larry Klaes About a decade ago while attending a SETI conference, I was listening to a researcher give a talk about detecting messages from other galaxies such as the giant elliptical galaxy Messier 87 and the immense Virgo galactic cluster it resides in. Since M87 is about 60 million light years from the Milky Way, I later asked him why would someone send a message that they could not hope to get a reply to for 120 million years at the least. His reply was rather vague and dissatisfying to me. It was along the lines of they would do it for the sake of being able to sending such a message across such a vast distance and time. I was left with the impression he did not fully think out why any intelligence would send messages across millions of light years of intergalactic space with even less hope of a reply than our token METI (Messaging ExtraTerrestrial Intelligence) effort with Messier 13 in 1974 via Arecibo, for which we will need to wait 50,000 years for the quickest reply...
Surface Feature Found on Haumea
I'm sure there are people who can keep things straight in the shifting world of planetary definitions, but given the fact that I'm still not used to Pluto's demotion, I have to look twice before I write anything on the subject. After checking, then, I confirm that Haumea, the interesting outer system object recently considered as the target of a fast orbiter mission (see this earlier post, and its sequel), is called a 'dwarf planet.' Orbiting in the Kuiper Belt, Haumea joins Eris, Pluto and Makemake in this category, the fourth largest dwarf planet now known in the Kuiper Belt. Dwarf planet Ceres is a main-belt asteroid, and thus not, like the others, a KBO as well. Image: Composite image of computer model frames showing Haumea's red spot as the dwarf planet rotates. Credit: P. Lacerda . What's special about Haumea? Its shape, for one thing. The distant world rotates in 3.9 hours, faster than any other large object in the Solar System. That spin seems to account for Haumea's unusual...
CoRoT-7b: A Small, Rocky World Examined
?I love to run into genuine enthusiasm when someone is doing cutting-edge science, and Didier Queloz (Observatoire de Geneve) has not let me down. Here the astronomer is discussing CoRoT-7b, which new studies have determined is a rocky world: "This is science at its thrilling and amazing best. We did everything we could to learn what the object discovered by the CoRoT satellite looks like and we found a unique system." Amazing indeed. We knew from CoRoT's transit measurements that the radius of this planet was about twice that of Earth. Queloz and team went to work with the HARPS spectroscope (High Accuracy Radial velocity Planet Searcher) at ESO's La Silla site in Chile, gathering fully seventy hours of observations on the system. What emerged was the best mass measurement for an exoplanet yet. Combining that revealed mass -- five times that of the Earth -- with CoRoT's radius readings, we can deduce that CoRoT-7b is about as dense as Earth, and thus almost certainly a rocky world....
Lightcraft Experiments Continue
?The last time we developed a new way of reaching orbit was back in the 1950s. How useful, then, to come up with one that allows huge weight reduction because it leaves propellant and energy source on the ground. Keeping the fuel at home or harvesting it along the way are key ways to conceptualize missions to the outer Solar System or beyond. But in more immediate terms, laser-beamed lightcraft can give us a relatively inexpensive way to low-Earth orbit as we begin to build a true space-based infrastructure. Eric Davis (IASA) and Franklin Mead (formerly of the Propulsion Directorate, AFRL, now retired and pursuing independent research) envision a ground-based laser beam generator system made up of power supply, laser beam generator/transmitter and related tracking, hand-off and safety systems. As we saw yesterday, the system would power an air-breathing pulsed-detonation engine that feeds off ambient air turned into plasma by the laser from the ground, producing a 'superheated plasma...
Lightcraft: A Laser Push to Orbit
Not the least of the objections against using laser propulsion to boost a lightsail to the stars is the engineering required to build the system. But theorists like Robert Forward, who originated the laser lightsail idea, never thought we would simply create such a system from scratch. We might ask, then, in the area of laser propulsion, what ideas are being experimented with right now, and might be capable of development into more advanced designs? Enter the Lightcraft Laser lightcraft command the attention here. Extensive work has been done on them at the Air Force Research Laboratory (AFRL), building upon earlier work at the AFRL Propulsion Directorate at Edwards Air Force Base. These early designs aim not at the stars, of course, but at a much more accessible target: Low Earth Orbit. A ground-based laser transmits power to the spacecraft, which collects the incoming energy and uses it to power its propulsion system. The beauty of this is that ambient air becomes the working...
Connecting to the Cosmos
Learning how we connect with the universe is one of the most fruitful investigations of modern science. No matter how we approach the matter, we're confronted with interesting possibilities. We study how gas giant planets may affect life on inner, terrestrial worlds by diverting asteroids from potential impacts. We look at issues like panspermia, wondering whether life's building blocks (or even life itself) arrived from elsewhere in the cosmos. In recent times, we've examined our Solar System's movements through the galaxy to ask whether there may be clues to periodic mass extinctions on our planet. As we widen stellar habitable zones into galactic ones, our musings take us out into the universe. They also confront us with our own limitations -- our eyes, notes astronomer James Kaler, see wavelengths between 0.00004 and 0.00008 of a centimeter. Kaler calls our visual spectrum "...but one octave on an imaginary electromagnetic piano with a keyboard hundreds of kilometers long." That...
Space Art: Reviving the Imagination
The other day I made a crack about a particular piece of artwork not being up to snuff, said item being an illustration accompanying a news release about a recent astronomical find. Maybe I was just out of sorts that day. In any case, what's significant to me about much of the artwork floating around to illustrate news stories is that it's generally quite good. Sure, we're talking about 'artist's concepts' of things like exoplanets and other distant objects, but they're usually concepts informed by current data and they're well executed. Then I ran across Jeff Foust's essay on art and space in the Space Review and got to thinking about what had propelled me as a kid into this kind of work. We had a fabulous network of community libraries in St. Louis back in the 1950s and '60s, and I made good use of three of them in particular. I'd stock up on science books and more or less read the astronomy sections straight through, starting at one end and working across. The photographs of...
Obousy’s ‘Interstellar Journey’ Site Debuts
Point a Voyager-speed spacecraft at Alpha Centauri and the travel time would be on the order of 73,000 years. Those of us obsessed with the idea of interstellar journeys are forced to hope for profound breakthroughs in physics and engineering. The word 'breakthrough' is, if anything, an understatement. An Alcubierre-style 'warp drive' would, so far as we know, require energies that would tax even a Kardashev Type III civilization, as physicist Richard Obousy points out. Hence the acknowledged 'giggle factor' that plagues serious discussion of these matters. Writes Obousy: The giggle-factor is a consequence of using a name for a cutting edge propulsion concept that is taken straight from science fiction. In reality the name is a double-edged sword. When one mentions a 'warp drive' it should be immediately obvious (one would hope) that what is being dicussed is a hypothetical propulsion mechanism that utilizes an asymmetric manipulation of the fabric of spacetime to generate an exotic...
A White Dwarf with Supernova Possibilities
I try to run interesting astronomical art wherever I can find it, but the image that accompanies this ESA news release on the discovery of an interesting white dwarf just doesn't cut it. So use your imagination as I describe the results of a study using data from ESA's XMM-Newton X-ray telescope, which have given us something we've long lacked -- highly accurate mass information for an accreting white dwarf in a binary system, one that is growing close to the point of becoming a supernova. Something in the vicinity of HD 49798 has been known to be giving off X-rays since 1997, but it has taken XMM-Newton to nail the culprit. The white dwarf near the larger star is twice as massive as expected, cramming about 1.3 solar masses into an object with a diameter about half that of our planet. Rotating every thirteen seconds, this object boasts the fastest white dwarf rotation known. Why the larger mass? We're looking at a white dwarf that is pulling gaseous material out of its companion...
Habitable Planets Conference Update
The exoplanet hunt has entered a significant new phase, one focused on transiting planets and the useful things we can learn about their physical properties and atmospheres through such events. Driven by CoRoT and Kepler, we're now in position to use those transits to spot smaller worlds than ever, down to terrestrial size, and naturally the focus is on Earth analogs located in the habitable zones of their stars. So think of it this way: We've gone from a broad-brush approach based largely on radial velocity methods to a more selective hunt, one that will take us to the realm of planets that can have liquid water on their surfaces and aren't so different from our own. Not that the continuing work on characterizing planetary systems is of any less importance, but we've found plenty of gas giants, and now we're trying to learn something about how common these smaller worlds may be. Putting an exclamation point on this focus is a conference called Pathways Towards Habitable Planets, to...
An Advanced Propulsion Overview
Both Tau Zero Foundation founder Marc Millis and JPL's recently retired Robert Frisbee appear in an article in the Smithsonian's Air & Space, where voyages to distant places indeed are discussed. Nothing is further from Earth, the article notes, than Voyager 1, which travels at a speed (almost 17 kilometers per second) that would get it across the US in a little under four minutes. Point that spacecraft toward Proxima Centauri and the journey at this speed would take 73,000 years. Clearly, something has to give, and writer Michael Klesius runs through the options. From Ideas to Engineering Voyager is actually headed in the vague direction of the constallation Camelopardalis, and won't come near anything stellar in several hundred thousand years. We'd like to get mission times to a nearby star down to decades so that scientists and engineers working on the project could live to see its outcome. How to achieve that is a question that has been at the back of Bob Frisbee's mind for a...
Unusual Find 12.8 Billion Light Years Out
Here's a surprise -- a galaxy as large as the Milky Way that houses a supermassive black hole with the equivalent of a billion suns worth of matter. The surprise isn't the object itself but its distance, some 12.8 billion light years (redshift 6.43). [See Adam Crowl's comment below: This is not actually a 'distance' but the light travel time]. That makes this a young object, assuming a universe that began roughly 13.7 billion years ago, and has implications for how such galaxies form. Tomotsugu Goto (University of Hawaii), who led the team making the discovery, notes the unusual nature of his find: "It is surprising that such a giant galaxy existed when the Universe was only one-sixteenth of its present age, and that it hosted a black hole one billion times more massive than the Sun. The galaxy and black hole must have formed very rapidly in the early universe." It seems odd to say it, but what complicates studying such distant objects is that host galaxies are often lost in the...