With its May 18 launch date fast approaching, Japan's IKAROS hybrid sail mission is at last getting a bit of press attention, long overdue in my opinion. The Daily Mail, at least, has just run a story on IKAROS, which will combine two mission concepts within a single spacecraft. Its solar sail works conventionally, using the momentum of photons from the Sun to accelerate the craft. But the JAXA designers have added thin film solar cells on the sail membrane. These produce the electricity that could be used in future (and larger) iterations to drive an ion engine. But IKAROS (Interplanetary Kite-craft Accelerated by Radiation of the Sun) is a demonstrator, not only taking the sail concept into space but pushing it into interplanetary regions. Launched in tandem with the Venus Climate Orbiter AKATSUKI, the spacecraft will deploy its sail a month after launch on the way to Venus, and having swung by the planet, will test out its propulsion and navigation systems. Kelvin Long, head of...
Astrobiology in Houston: From Fossils to SETI
NASA's teleconference from the Astrobiology Science Conference 2010 in Houston offered some interesting news about the discovery of microscopic fossils in gypsum from a period about six million years ago, when the Mediterranean Sea had all but dried up. Gypsum (calcium sulfate) precipitates out of sea water, and the find has implications for finding life on Mars, as I'll explain in a moment. What gave me a chuckle, though, was that after a discussion between four crack astrobiologists about life's appearance on Earth and the best ways to search for it elsewhere, the first question from reporters was about Stephen Hawking's views on aliens, and whether NASA had a policy on broadcasts to the stars. The answer is clearly no, and NASA's Mary Voytek noted the differences of opinion between the agency's scientists on the issue, prompting Steven Squyres (of Mars rover fame) to note that our signals are already in play in the form of TV broadcasts and planetary radar signals. I'm thinking...
Notes & Queries 4/28/10
Solar Sail Symposium in July The 2nd International Symposium on Solar Sailing (ISSS 2010) draws closer, the event occurring July 20-22 at New York City College of Technology of the City University of New York. The focus will be on recent advances in solar sailing technologies and near-term solar sailing missions, with coverage of hardware, enabling technologies, concepts, designs, dynamics, navigation, control, modeling and mission applications and programs. The deadline for abstracts is May 15, 2010, with full information available at the symposium's Web site. Image: The IKAROS hybrid sail concept. A solar sail gathers sunlight as propulsion by means of a large membrane while a solar "power" sail gets electricity from thin film solar cells on the membrane in addition to acceleration by solar radiation. What's more, if the ion-propulsion engines with high specific impulse are driven by such solar cells, it can become a "hybrid" engine that is combined with photon acceleration to...
GJ 436b: Mystery and Its Uses
Yesterday's musings on extraterrestrial contact were inspired both by Stephen Hawking and the surrealist painter Giorgio de Chirico (1888-1978). Whereas Hawking opined that an encounter with an alien culture could be dangerous, my own hunch was that it would be deeply mysterious and perhaps not even understood as contact, given the huge differences in technology between us. That called De Chirico's strange cityscapes to mind, what Walter Wells calls 'their deep and often irrational shadows, their empty walkways and portentous silences.' It helped, of course, that years ago I had reviewed V.S. Naipaul's The Enigma of Arrival, which draws heavily on the De Chirico painting of the same name (shown above). Naipaul's book is a strange, autobiographical meditation whose subject is consciousness confronted with mystery. He imagines one of the two figures in the painting as a traveler and conceives a story based on the scene, one set in what he calls a 'dangerous classical city,' but he soon...
The Enigma of Contact
What Stephen Hawking thinks about aliens made news this weekend, and Centauri Dreams readers will know from our past discussions more or less what Hawking has to say. Assuming we come into contact with an extraterrestrial civilization, it is widely assumed that one of two things will happen. Either an alien visit will be devastating, as has all too often happened when cultures with widely different technologies met, or a benign transfer of information will occur, in which case we benefit by our exposure to new science and revolutionary ideas. A Threat to Humanity? Hawking, who has been working on an upcoming program for the Discovery Channel, opts for the former, as this story in TimesOnline notes. Most life elsewhere in the universe, the physicist believes, will be relatively simple, microbial or primitive animals. But there will be exceptions: ...a few life forms could be intelligent and pose a threat. Hawking believes that contact with such a species could be devastating for...
SETI and Open Data
Are there better ways of studying the raw data from SETI? We may know soon, because Jill Tarter has announced that in a few months, the SETI Institute will begin to make this material available via the SETIQuest site. Those conversant with digital signal processing are highly welcome, but so are participants from the general public as the site gears up to offer options for all ages. Tarter speaks of a 'global army' of open-source code developers going to work on data collected by the Allen Telescope Array, along with students and citizen scientists anxious to play a role in the quest for extraterrestrial life. SETI@home has been a wonderful success, but as Tarter notes in this CNN commentary, the software has been limited. You took what was given you and couldn't affect the search techniques brought to bear on the data. I'm thinking that scattering the data to the winds could lead to some interesting research possibilities. We need the telescope hardware gathered at the Array to...
Kepler: Hold the Data?
Not long ago I sent out a 'tweet' on the Centauri Dreams Twitter feed talking about the number of planet detection candidates the Kepler mission was working with. Almost immediately I discovered that the story had become unavailable at the Nature News site, making me wonder whether the figures were right, but the story is back up (available here) and I can cite it once again. Thus: Since its launch on 6 March 2009, Kepler, with its 0.95-metre telescope, has been staring at the same field of stars near the northern star of Vega, looking for tiny reductions in starlight caused by a planet passing in front of a star's face. In January, the Kepler team announced the discovery of five new exoplanets. [Kepler principal investigator William] Borucki says that the team, as of last week, has found 328 more candidates — but that as many as 50% of these may be false positives, where objects such binary stars confuse the picture. 328 candidates, and much work ahead in weeding out the...
Life Throughout the Solar System?
Just as SETI is redefining its parameters, astrobiology has been going through a shift that widens our notion of habitable zones. Not so long ago, the concept seemed simple. Take a Sun-like star and figure out at what distance a planet could maintain liquid water on its surface. Assume, in other words, that the life you're looking for is more or less like what's found on Earth, and therefore needs the same conditions to persist. Now we're finding remote venues like Enceladus that remind us liquid water can turn up in unusual places, and we've parachuted a probe onto a world, Titan, where it's not inconceivable that exotic forms of life can develop. Throw in the possibility that objects as distant as the Kuiper Belt may contain subsurface liquids and what used to be a constrained habitable zone seems to be vast indeed. And perhaps we've already found another living planet, as astrobiologist Dirk Schulze-Makuch tells Lee Billings in a recent interview. Along with David Darling,...
An Archaeological Approach to SETI
Changing approaches to SETI are getting public attention these days, as witness a new article in The Economist that makes reference to the probable cause of the interest, the publication of Paul Davies' The Eerie Silence (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2010). Sub-titled 'Renewing Our Search for Alien Intelligence,' Davies' book is making accessible to the general public the kind of discussion we've often had in these pages, looking at the question of whether our SETI strategies at radio and optical wavelengths aren't too limited for any chance of success. The Economist is just one sign of the new interest. After all, technologies like spread spectrum encoding are already masking straightforward radio communications, while conventional broadcasting is giving way to such heavy use of fiber-optics that a planet like ours may go dark at radio wavelengths within a relatively short time as civilizations go, and no more than an infinitesimal flicker in cosmological terms. Thus the interest in...
Confirming General Relativity at Large Scales
The discovery that the universe's expansion is accelerating has led some to wonder whether General Relativity breaks down at large scales. But new work by Fabian Schmidt and colleagues at Caltech seems to play down a rival theory known, economically enough, as f(R). If, under General Relativity, we see dark energy in terms of a cosmological constant, and thus view it as the energy of empty space, f(R) takes another tack, seeing the cosmic acceleration as the result of a necessary modification of gravitational theory. This effect would play a role in the way matter grows over time to become galaxy clusters, and that leads to a useful way to test the theory. What Schmidt and team did was to take mass estimates of 49 galaxy clusters based on observations from the Chandra X-ray Observatory, comparing them with the predictions of theory and raw data from supernova studies, the cosmic microwave background and the large-scale distribution of galaxies. Compellingly, they found no difference...
A Dusty Finish in Glasgow
I'm always sorry when a good conference like the Royal Astronomical Society's 2010 gathering ends, even if I'm attending it 'virtually' from the other side of an ocean. But virtuality has its advantages, as I'm reminded by several conference attendees who have struggled with Icelandic volcano ash when trying to book flights out of the UK. If I were with them in Glasgow, I'd praise my good fortune for extra time in Scotland and immediately take the train for Inverness, then on to Skye and the Inner Hebrides, where I've spent many good days and intend to spend many more. Volcanic ash or no, it was a lively conference with tantalizing results on planetary system residues in white dwarfs and retrograde exoplanet orbits, and a number of other issues that can be found in the conference program. I'll close our RAS coverage here with two items that deal with interstellar dust rather than the Earth-based dust and ash that closes airports. Red giants, the kind of star our Sun will eventually...
Musings on SETI and Nearby Brown Dwarfs
There is enough going on at the Royal Astronomical Society's 2010 meeting to keep us occupied for some time, but I don't want to go any farther without circling back to UGPS 0722-05, an unusually cool brown dwarf now thought to be the seventh closest star to the Sun. The parallax measurements of its distance are still being refined, but the dwarf is currently thought to be some 9.6 light years from Earth, roughly twice the distance of Proxima Centauri. With a temperature between 130 and 230 degrees Celsius, this is the coolest brown dwarf ever observed, its mass ranging somewhere between five and thirty times that of Jupiter. A number of readers sent links to this discovery, for which many thanks, and I note how interest seems to be growing in the idea that a brown dwarf may exist closer to us than the Alpha Centauri stars. Brown dwarfs are now thought to be relatively common in the galaxy, perhaps as common as normal stars, which suggests that missions like WISE may well discover...
Do ‘Hot Jupiters’ Rule Out Terrestrial Planets?
Meetings like the Royal Astronomical Society's gathering in Glasgow can be overwhelming, with all kinds of news to track via emails, news releases and Twitter. Yesterday we looked at the possible signature of rocky planets in the atmospheres of white dwarfs. But the unusual orbits of planets newly discovered by the WASP project (and follow-up studies of older hot Jupiters) get pride of place as perhaps the most notable announcement so far. WASP (Wide Angle Search for Planets) turned up nine new planets, bumping the exoplanet total to 454), but follow-up studies of these worlds, along with other 'hot Jupiters' from earlier surveys, showed that six out of the 27 examined orbited opposite to the rotation of their host star. Moreover, more than half of the planets studied are misaligned with their star's rotation axis. Image: Exoplanets, discovered by WASP together with ESO telescopes, that unexpectedly have been found to have retrograde orbits are shown here. In all cases the star is...
White Dwarfs Show Signs of Planetary Debris
Kepler, CoRoT and future space missions should give us an estimate of how common small, rocky planets are in the galaxy. But there is much we can do from Earth, as Jay Farihi told the Royal Astronomical Society's 2010 meeting today. Farihi's team used data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey to conclude that rocky worlds emerge around at least a small percentage of A- and F-class stars. The method: Analyze the position, motion and spectra of white dwarfs found in the SDSS survey. Farihi was interested in the presence of elements heavier than hydrogen and helium in the stellar atmospheres. Finding calcium, magnesium or iron in the atmosphere of a white dwarf is, Farihi believes, evidence of rocky debris, and the new work shows that at least 3 percent and as much as 20 percent of all white dwarfs may be contaminated in this way. Such elements should have sunk below the photosphere in the high gravity of a white dwarf, leading to the belief that any visible contamination must be the...
Pondering Life on Titan
I love what William Bains (University of Cambridge) has to say about extraterrestrial life and how it might appear to us. "Wouldn't it be sad if the most alien things we found in the galaxy were just like us, but blue and with tails?" He's thinking, of course, of some science fiction evocations of aliens and their general similarities to our own species, perhaps the result of Hollywood budgetary constraints as much as lack of imagination. But Bains is interested in alien life for more than cinematic reasons. He's looking hard at Titan, and envisioning what life there might look like. Image: A flat, calm, liquid methane-ethane lake on Titan is depicted in this artist's concept. Copyright 2008 Karl Kofoed. Life on Titan would be, by our standards, a bit unusual. Says Bains: "Life needs a liquid; even the driest desert plant on Earth needs water for its metabolism to work. So, if life were to exist on Titan, it must have blood based on liquid methane, not water. That means its whole...
SETI Beacons and Altruistic Aliens
by James and Gregory Benford Interstellar beacons continue to draw discussion, and the Benford brothers now return with further thoughts on the matter in response to reader comments here. How to distinguish a beacon from a natural source, and why consider it in terms of cost? The answer is below, as is an interesting twist on the Fermi paradox. We proposed making cost a useful, perhaps universal, standard because it is a quantitative constraint. Our aim is to help observers look for plausible beacons that may exist. Using transient events seen by observers is an economic way to ask these next, exploratory questions. Speculations always yield to data, and at its 50th anniversary SETI needs a vital data point: first detection. In our latest work, we point out that researchers should be aware of the likely properties of beacons. In particular, beacons may mimic pulsars in repetition rate. But they would distinguish themselves in some way, such as amplitude modulation, varying pulse...
Atmospheric Changes Mark Triton Summer
A new instrument that lets us look deeper into things almost always changes the game. Such an instrument is CRIRES, the Cryogenic High-Resolution Infrared Echelle Spectrograph. Now operational at the Very Large Telescope, CRIRES has already done yeoman work on Pluto, and has now been used to study the atmosphere of Neptune's large moon Triton in more detail than ever before. The result: A new understanding of Triton's carbon monoxide, whose existence in its upper surface layer is now confirmed and shown to be an icy 'film' that, over time, adds to the atmosphere. Image: Artist's impression of how Triton, Neptune's largest moon, might look from high above its surface. The distant Sun appears at the upper-left and the blue crescent of Neptune right of centre. Using the CRIRES instrument on ESO's Very Large Telescope, a team of astronomers has been able to see that the summer is in full swing in Triton's southern hemisphere. Credit: ESO/L. Calçada. It should come as no surprise that...
Notes & Queries 4/8/10
Project Ozma's Anniversary It was just fifty years ago today, April 8, 1960, when Frank Drake launched Project Ozma by turning the Green Bank, WV dish toward Tau Ceti. In a reminiscence of the project written for Cosmic Search magazine, Drake recalls the initial sense of anticipation, followed by examination of the chart recorder, which returned nothing but noise. When Tau Ceti set in the west, Drake and team pointed the telescope at Epsilon Eridani. Let Drake tell it: A few minutes went by. And then it happened. Wham! Suddenly the chart recorder started banging off scale. We heard bursts of noise coming out of the loudspeaker eight times a second, and the chart recorder was banging against its pin eight times a second. We had never seen anything like this before in all the previous observing at Green Bank. We all looked at each other wide-eyed. Could it be this easy? Some people had even predicted that the most rational extraterrestrial signal would be a slow series of pulses, as...
Brown Dwarf Companion: Planet or Star?
Our knowledge of brown dwarfs is expanding rapidly, and with the help of the WISE mission, we will be able to build a much more complete catalog of such stars in our neighborhood. But look what the Hubble Space Telescope, in conjunction with the Gemini Observatory, has produced: A companion to a brown dwarf that gets us right back into the debate about how to define a planet. When Pluto was in question, we were faced with a true imbroglio. Now the question involves not a small but a large object, and forces us to consider whether its origins can make an object of acknowledged planetary mass something else instead. But first, the imagery (this is, after all, a direct detection). The primary brown dwarf is 2M J044144, images of which were obtained as part of a survey of 32 young brown dwarfs in the Taurus star-forming region 450 light years away. Both objects are visible below: Image: Hubble Space Telescope (top) and Gemini North (bottom) images of the 2M J044144 system showing the...
Analyzing Transients: Pulsars or Beacons?
Recently we looked at James and Gregory Benford's thoughts on interstellar beacons, noting that using cost as a likely constraint allowed the authors to discuss how cost would affect design, and therefore the parameters of any beacon we would be likely to observe. But what is it about interstellar beacons that sets them apart from transient phenomena? After all, it was no longer ago than 1963 that Nikolai Kardashev proposed that the radio source CTA 102 could be evidence of a Type II or III extraterrestrial civilization (i.e., one that is able to use the entire energy output of its star, or in the most extreme case, of its entire galaxy). When Gennady Sholomitskii announced his observation that CTA 102's radio emission was varying, something of a sensation ensued. Those of us of a certain age can recall Roger McGuinn's song 'CTA 102,' written and performed by McGuinn's group The Byrds. It was on their Younger Than Yesterday LP, released in 1967. A sample: CTA 102 Year over year...