by Larry Klaes Larry Klaes wraps up his two-part essay on our attitudes towards extraterrestrials by looking at how the subject has been treated in the past, and speculating on the scenarios that might bring disaster. Do Earth-shattering depictions of space invasion reflect what people really believe, or are they merely a form of escapism? Either way, they tell us something about ourselves as we confront the possibility of contact. For those who may still wonder and question just how much weight the words of the famous cosmologist Stephen Hawking hold for the concept of alien intelligences and their potential reactions to encountering humanity, consider this: A new science fiction film coming out this November titled Skyline has recently premiered its theatrical trailer, which you can view here. The trailer begins with the line: "On August 28th, 2009, NASA sent a message into space farther than we ever thought possible... in an effort to reach extraterrestrial life." Now it is true...
Why Do We Fear Aliens?
By Larry Klaes Just how we would react to the reception of a signal from an extraterrestrial civilization is an increasingly controversial question, and one filled with import as we take the SETI search in proposed new directions. The ongoing Royal Society meeting in Chicheley (UK) probes the issue, with panel discussions on whether or not we should be sending our own broadcasts to the stars, and presentations exploring the import of extraterrestrial life on the future of humanity. It seems a good time, then, for Larry Klaes to have a look at the question in this, the first of a two-part essay that analyzes our attitudes not so much about signals from the stars as their senders. Several months ago, the famous British physicist and cosmologist Stephen Hawking shared his views on extraterrestrial intelligences (ETI) with the intelligent beings of the planet Earth. This was done in no small part as a way to gain publicity for his new television science series, Stephen Hawking's...
A Tour de Force of Planetary Discovery
Steven Vogt (UC-Santa Cruz) is suddenly the buzz of the blogosphere, though not in ways he might have intended. The designer of the HIRES spectrometer that made the detection of Gliese 581g possible, Vogt can claim pride of place as the discoverer of the first near-Earth mass planet found in the habitable zone of its star. But he's also taking his lumps for saying that he could all but guarantee life on that planet. An unwise call, as many commenters here have noted. Perhaps even more unwise is his hope to name the new planet after his wife, Zarmina. Centauri Dreams has nothing against the notion of naming celestial objects for loved ones, but caution should always be the byword. Suppose, for example, that Mrs. Vogt, fed up with publicity and tired of the company of astronomers, should surprise her husband by leaving him. Vogt's ex would be forever enshrined in the celestial sphere, a taunting presence whenever the poor man thought of the Gl 581 system. Such a scenario happens in...
Unraveling an Outer System ‘Knot’
IBEX, the Interstellar Boundary Explorer, was never designed to visit the regions it studies. Indeed, the spacecraft, launched in October of 2008, is in Earth orbit and a highly elliptical one at that, with an apogee of 322,000 kilometers and a perigee of 16,000 kilometers. But from that vantage IBEX is able to study and map the boundary between the heliosphere and true interstellar space. It does this by detecting energetic neutral atoms of hydrogen (ENAs) produced at the heliosheath, helping us understand the effects of the solar wind as it collides with interstellar materials. The encounter between solar wind and the interstellar medium causes ENAs to be scattered in all directions from the heliosheath -- those that pass near the Earth are what IBEX detects, and the spacecraft scans overlapping strips of sky to build up a 360-degree map. It was last October, a year after launch, that we learned from the first IBEX map that the interstellar boundary was a more lively place than...
A Quick Take on IAC’s Final Day
by Kelvin Long No one gets more done on a Blackberry than Kelvin Long, one of the powerhouses behind Project Icarus. Kelvin has been in Prague for the International Astronautical Congress, and just sent along a wrap-up of his final day at the conference, one he completed while on the way to the airport. Here's a quick and mobile take on the last day of IAC 2010 as seen by this physicist and author. I'm sitting listening to one of my last talks before I catch my flight. It's on the JEO or Jupiter Europa Orbiter mission [part of the proposed Europa Jupiter System Mission (EJSM)]. The spacecraft will have around twelve instruments on board with the focus on the emergence of habitable worlds. It will be accompanied by the JGO spacecraft or Jupiter Ganymede Orbiter. It's going to be a great mission and pity Arthur C. Clarke isn't around to see it. Launch date 2020 and ends around 2029. Apparently the radiation design dose will be 2.9 Mega rads. An Io gravity assist will be used for...
Gl 581g: Rocky and Potentially Habitable
What exactly does the word 'habitable' mean? The question comes to mind because of two things, the first being the media buzz over Gliese 581g, now widely described as the first potentially habitable planet we've found. The second is Paul Davies' presentation yesterday at the International Astronautical Congress in Prague, where Davies was careful to differentiate between 'habitable' and 'inhabited.' More on the latter in a moment. Let's look first at this outstanding find, two new planets in the Gliese 581 system discovered through the unflagging efforts of the Lick-Carnegie team. A World in the Zone? The beauty of Gl 581, of course, is not only that it has yielded a storehouse of planets (six known at present), but that these worlds are on nearly circular orbits, and several have caught our eye re habitability before. The current buzz seems a bit tamer than the one that greeted the announcement of Gl 581c, at the time thought to be capable of sustaining liquid water on its surface,...
SETI: The Red Giant Factor
The ‘slow boat’ to Centauri concept we’ve discussed before in these pages envisions generation ships, vessels that take thousands of years to cross to their destination. And based on current thinking, that’s about the best we could manage with the propulsion systems currently in our inventory. Specifically, a solar sail making a close solar pass (a ‘sundiver’ maneuver) could get us up to 500 or 600 kilometers per second (0.002c), making a 2000-year journey to the nearest star possible. It’s hard to imagine under what circumstances such a mission might be launched. But let’s think long-term, as Greg Matloff (New York City College of Technology) did in a session that just concluded at the International Astronautical Congress in Prague. Matloff, a solar sail expert and well known figure in the interstellar community, notes that when the Sun leaves the main sequence and becomes a red giant, its luminosity may have increased by a factor of a thousand. Imagine using that kind of star as...
Project Icarus: Finding the Fuel
Project Icarus, introduced to the IAA at last year's Aosta conference, made quite a splash yesterday at the International Astronautical Congress in Prague, with four presentations by Icarus team members and related work on the FOCAL mission by Claudio Maccone. Icarus is the attempt to re-examine the Project Daedalus starship study of the 1970s in light of technological developments in the intervening years. A joint project between the British Interplanetary Society and the Tau Zero Foundation, it's now in fully operational mode. Fueling Up a Starship There is much in these papers worth comment, but today I'll home in on the issue of helium-3 and where to find it, presented yesterday and drawing on the work of Andreas Hein, Andreas Tziolas and Adam Crowl. Daedalus was envisioned as a fusion mission using deuterium and helium-3 as fuel, a reaction that has advantages over deuterium/tritium but one that has yet to be demonstrated in a working reactor. Assuming we do figure out how to...
Early Interstellar Missions and Energy
The International Astronautical Congress is in full swing in Prague today, with regular updates flowing over #IAC2010 on Twitter and the first session of interstellar import now in progress as I write this. It's a session on interstellar precursor missions that includes, in addition to Ralph McNutt (JHU/APL) on the impact of the Voyager and IBEX missions, a series of papers from the Project Icarus team ranging from helium-3 mining to communications via the gravitational lens of both the Sun and the target star (no specific target has yet been chosen for Icarus). Claudio Maccone will be summarizing where we stand with the FOCAL mission, envisioned as the first attempt to exploit gravitational lensing for astronomical observations. But I'll turn today to Marc Millis, who will wrap up the precursor session with a discussion of the first interstellar missions and their dependence on things we can measure, such as energy. The notion here is to look at the energy required for an...
Interstellar Archaeology on the Galactic Scale
The European Planetary Science Congress ends today in Rome even as scientists and engineers on the astronautical side of things head for Prague, where the International Astronautical Congress convenes on Monday. I'll be keeping an eye on events in Prague and wishing I could join the gathering of Tau Zero practitioners that will be taking place there -- Marc Millis will be presenting four papers, and many of the Project Icarus team members are also making the journey, so we should be getting regular updates on matters interstellar. Nor do I want to neglect the Royal Society meeting on extraterrestrial life, coming up early in October in Buckinghamshire in the UK. Emails from James Benford (Microwave Sciences) and Richard Carrigan (Fermilab) tell me both will be speaking at the session, which reminds me that it was way back in April that I promised more on Carrigan's notions of interstellar 'archaeology,' a form of SETI that makes no assumptions about the originating civilization. It's...
Rosetta: A Southern Hemisphere Landing
It's hard to believe it's been over six years since the launch of the European Space Agency's Rosetta mission, now well enroute to comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko, a ten year journey that will be completed in 2014. Upon reaching the comet, Rosetta will begin an extended encounter that includes an orbiter that will circle Churyumov-Gerasimenko for thirteen months as it moves toward the Sun, and a small lander that will investigate surface conditions. We learned more about the mission in today's sessions of the European Planetary Science Congress, now being held in Rome. Jeremie Lasue (Los Alamos National Laboratory) presented the latest Rosetta findings at the conference, drawing on computer models that predict the behavior of the comet's nucleus over the course of the spacecraft's operations. Landing on a comet is tricky business, because dust, ice and frozen carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide will be active as the comet's tail begins to form. What Lasue and colleagues have done is...
Probing Seasonal Change on Titan
Imagine being Jean-Pierre Lebreton. The man behind the Huygens probe, Lebreton and the ESA team behind him hold the record for the most distant landfall in history, the 2005 descent onto the surface of Titan. I have no idea what dreams this man might have had in his childhood, but one of mine was descending through Titan’s thick atmosphere to see its never before glimpsed surface. Huygens pulled off the feat with astonishing ease, descending slowly and steadily while snapping panoramic views of the enigmatic moon. Doubtless Lebreton has much to share about all this at this year’s European Planetary Science Congress, now being held in Rome. EPSC is the major meeting in Europe for planetary scientists, and it’s no surprise that Titan appears prominently in the news from the conference. Cassini’s Visual and Infrared Mapping Spectrometer instrument (VIMS) has been keeping an eye on Titan’s cloud cover since the orbiter first took up its vigil around Saturn, and 2000 VIMS images have now...
Data Clippers: Bringing the Science Home
I was fortunate enough to meet Joel Poncy (Thales Alenia Space, France) at last year's deep space conference in Aosta, where he gave the audience the lowdown on an extraordinary mission concept, an orbiter of the Kuiper Belt object Haumea. Haumea is a tricky target, lacking an atmosphere that would allow aerobraking and pushing all our limits on propulsion and power generation. But Poncy's team worked out a design using either electric or magneto-plasma technologies, assuming a gravity assist to shorten the journey for arrival around 2035. In a later lunch conversation, Poncy talked to me about the benefit of probing the Kuiper Belt, and the collateral advances that such a mission would bring in terms of developing the orbiters, landers and deep-drilling capabilities we'll need to explore planetary moons like Europa or Ganymede. Sometimes you choose targets, in other words, not only for their immediate payoff, but because they become part of the process of developing next generation...
SETI on the Ecliptic
Is anyone out there in the galaxy aware of our presence? If so, it's most likely through detection of our planetary radars, like those at Arecibo and Evpatoria that are used to detect and study nearby objects like asteroids, and provide a valuable part of our planetary defense. Sure, we've been pumping television and radio signals into the deep for a long time now, but Arecibo is the most powerful radar in the world, its 430 MHz transmitter offering a maximum total peak pulse output power of 2.5 MW. The planetary radars at Arecibo, Goldstone and Evpatoria are sending far more powerful signals than the faint traces of our early TV broadcasts. It's one of the hopes of SETI that we might detect a similar transmission from another civilization, but in saying that we run into all kinds of assumptions. How long a time-frame does a civilization have before it develops technologies far superior to planetary radars for studying nearby objects? For that matter, how long would any sort of...
Light Off Distant Oceans
While we're this early in the game of detecting life signs from distant planets, it makes sense to focus on surface habitability, which is why oceans are so interesting. Sure, we can imagine potential biospheres under the ice of a Europa or even an Enceladus, but given the state of our instrumentation and the distance of our target, going after the most likely catch makes sense, and that means looking for oceans. Significant work from the EPOXI mission has given us some of the parameters for studying a planet like ours using multi-wavelength photometry. EPOXI, you'll recall, is the extended mission of the Deep Impact spacecraft that drove an impactor into Comet Tempel 1 in 2005 and is now enroute to Comet Hartley 2. Its views of Earth are being used to help scientists prepare for studies of terrestrial worlds around other stars. Planets with large bodies of water should reflect light from their star differently than dry planets, and as the observed planet goes through its phases as...
A Bioengineered Future in Deep Space
NASA's Human Research Program is all about risk reduction, finding ways to counter fatigue and mitigate radiation damage, among other potential issues in space travel. But what if a different kind of program had evolved? After all, back in the 1960s the agency was looking into the much broader question of how a human being might be adapted for space. The notion grew out of a 1960 article by Manfred Clynes and Nathan Kline called "Cyborgs and Space," suggesting that re-creating the environment of Earth aboard a space vehicle was not as useful an option as adapting a human being at least partly to the conditions he or she would face. The idea was a bold one in its day. From the paper (the italics are in the original): The task of adapting man's body to any environment he may choose will be made easier by increased knowledge of homeostatic functioning, the cybernetic aspects of which are just beginning to be understood and investigated. In the past evolution brought about the altering...
Micro ‘Bots’ to the Stars?
Debra Fischer (Yale University) takes a brief look at the next thirty years as part of a Discover Magazine 30th anniversary section, an appearance notable more for what Fischer doesn't say than what she does. Any hint of how her radial velocity studies of the Alpha Centauri system are proceeding? I wouldn't have expected any, I'll admit, and Fischer says nothing about it, but the betting here is that we'll have an announcement within the next year either by Fischer or Michel Mayor's team either giving us a planetary discovery or sharply constraining the alternatives. What Fischer does speculate on beyond the notion that we'll detect life in exoplanetary atmospheres is that interstellar probes will eventually fly. You may recall Robert Freitas' notion of interstellar probes loaded with artificial intelligence and as tiny as sewing needles, scattered into the galaxy in their hordes to investigate potentially habitable worlds. Fischer, too, likes miniaturization, which does so much to...
Detecting (and Understanding) Life Signals
A symposium celebrating the first fifty years of NASA' exobiology program takes place on October 14 in Arlington, Virginia. 'Seeking Signs of Life' looks all the way back to 1959, when NASA funded its first exobiology investigation, an experiment for a future spacecraft to detect life on Mars. The actual exobiology program was established in 1960, and led to the three Viking experiments that eventually flew. Exobiology has these days morphed into 'astrobiology,' as we look at topics as diverse as chemical evolution in interstellar space and planetary formation. For those in range of Arlington, more information is available here. Be aware as well of a workshop on SETI that is now taking place at the National Radio Astronomy Observatory in Green Bank, WV, marking the 50th anniversary of Frank Drake's first search for extraterrestrial signals. Webcasts begin at 0830 EDT (1230 UTC), and will include Drake's views on 'SETI in 2061 and Beyond' at that time on September 15. Further...
Next Gen NEAR: Targeting an Asteroid
A manned mission to an asteroid sounds, on first hearing, like a true deep-space venture, and in the days when we thought of the asteroids as largely confined to a belt between Mars and Jupiter, so it would have been depicted. But today we know that a large population of near-Earth objects (NEOs) is out there, close enough to make one of them the most obvious target for a mission beyond the Earth-Moon system. Moreover, they're a necessary target given our need to understand their composition in case we ever have to change an asteroid trajectory. Even so, you don't send a human team to a completely unknown destination, which is why robotic asteroid exploration continues to loom large. Two missions -- Japan's Hayabusa and NASA's Near Earth Asteroid Rendezvous (NEAR) -- have actually orbited and landed on an asteroid. Now the Applied Physics Laboratory at Johns Hopkins University is proposing a follow-on to the NEAR mission that would give us the needed insights for later human visits....
Of ‘Hot Jupiters’ and Short Lifetimes
Globular clusters held an early fascination for me, and I guess anyone who encounters these rich cities of stars for the first time wonders what it would be like to be on a planet deep inside one of them. The clusters appear to be distributed in a spherical halo around the galactic center, ancient collections of stars much lower in heavy elements than stars in the galactic disk (although globular clusters in some other Local Group galaxies seem younger). The thought of the night sky on a planet embedded in such a place makes the mind reel, star upon star upon star filling the view. Image: The globular cluster 47 Tucanae, the second brightest globular cluster orbiting the Milky Way (behind Omega Centauri). Imagine the night sky deep within such a cluster. Credit: South African Astronomical Observatory. But a new paper suggests that at least one category of planets may be rare in such clusters. It follows up on an earlier survey of the cluster 47 Tucanae which examined some 34,000...