I'm fascinated by how much the exoplanet hunt is telling us about celestial objects other than planets. The other day we looked at some of the stellar spinoffs from the Kepler mission, including the unusual pulsations of the star HD 187091, now known to be not one star but two. But the examples run well beyond Kepler. Back in 2006, a survey called the Sagittarius Window Eclipsing Extrasolar Planet Search (SWEEPS) used Hubble data to study 180,000 stars in the galaxy's central bulge, the object being to find 'hot Jupiters' orbiting close to their stars. But the seven-day survey also turned up 42 so-called 'blue straggler' stars in the galactic bulge, their brightness and temperature far more typical of stars younger than those around them. It's generally accepted that star formation in the central bulge has all but stopped, the giant blue stars of the region having exploded into supernovae billions of years ago. Blue stragglers are unusual because they are more luminous and bluer that...
On the Calendar: Exoplanets and Worldships
Be aware of two meetings of relevance for interstellar studies, the first of which takes place today at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. There, a symposium called The Next 40 Years of Exoplanets runs all day, with presentations from major figures in the field -- you can see the agenda here. I bring this up because MIT Libraries is planning to stream the presentations, starting with Dave Charbonneau (Harvard University) at 0900 EST. Those of you who've been asking about Alpha Centauri planet hunts will be glad to hear that Debra Fischer (Yale University), who is running one of the three ongoing Centauri searches, will be speaking between 1130 and 1300 EST. The poster for this meeting reminds me of the incessant argument about what constitutes a habitable planet. It shows two kids in a twilight setting pointing up at the sky, their silhouettes framed by fading light reflected off a lake. One of them is saying 'That star has a planet like Earth." An asterisk reveals the...
OSIRIS-REx: Sampling an Asteroid
Asteroid 1999 RQ36 may or may not pose a future problem for our planet -- the chances of an impact with the Earth in 2182 are now estimated at roughly one in 1800. But learning more about it will help us understand the population of near-Earth objects that much better, one of several reasons why the OSIRIS-REx mission is significant. The acronym stands for Origins, Spectral Interpretation, Resource Identification, Security-Regolith Explorer, a genuine mouthful, but a name we'll be hearing more of as the launch of this sample-return mission approaches in 2016. The target asteroid, 575 meters in diameter, has been the subject of extensive study not only by ground-based telescopes including the Arecibo planetary radar but also by the Spitzer Space Telescope. We know that 1999 RQ36 orbits the Sun every 1.2 years and crosses the Earth's orbit every September, with a shape and rotation rate that are well understood. OSIRIS-REx will carry pristine samples of carbonaceous materials of a...
Beyond the Kepler Planets
Kepler is a telescope that does nothing more than stare at a single patch of sky, described by its principal investigator, with a touch of whimsy, as the most boring space mission in history. William Borucki is referring to the fact that about the only thing that changes on Kepler is the occasional alignment of its solar panels. But of course Borucki's jest belies the fact that the mission in question is finding planets by the bushel, with more than 1200 candidates already reported, and who knows how many other interesting objects ripe for discovery. Not all of these are planets, to be sure, and as we'll see in a moment, many are intriguing in their own right. But the planets have center stage, and the talk at the American Astronomical Society's 218th meeting has been of multiple planet systems found by Kepler, after a presentation by David Latham (Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics). Of Kepler's 1200 candidates, fully 408 are found in multiple planet systems. Latham told...
Progress Toward the Dream of Space Drives and Stargates
by James F. Woodward I first wrote about James Woodward's work in my 2004 book Centauri Dreams: Imagining and Planning Interstellar Exploration, and have often been asked since to comment further on his research. But it's best to leave that to the man himself, and I'm pleased to turn today's post over to him. A bit of biography: Jim Woodward earned bachelor's and master's degrees in physics at Middlebury College and New York University (respectively) in the 1960s. From his undergraduate days, his chief interest was in gravitation, a field then not very popular. So, for his Ph.D., he changed to the history of science, writing a dissertation on the history of attempts to deal with the problem of "action-at-a-distance" in gravity theory from the 17th to the early 20th centuries (Ph.D., University of Denver, 1972). On completion of his graduate studies, Jim took a teaching job in the history of science at California State University Fullerton (CSUF), where he has been ever since. Shortly...
Support for Dark Energy
The far future may be a lonely place, at least in extragalactic terms. Scientists studying gravity's interactions with so-called dark energy -- thought to be the cause of the universe's accelerating expansion -- can work out a scenario in which gravity dominated in the early universe. But somewhere around eight billion years after the Big Bang, the continuing expansion and consequent dilution of matter caused gravity to fall behind dark energy in its effects. We're left with what we see today, a universe whose expansion will one day spread galaxies so far apart that any civilizations living in them won't be able to see any other galaxies. The initial dark energy findings, released in 1998, were based on Type Ia supernovae, using these as 'standard candles' which allowed us to calculate their distance from Earth. Now we have new data from both the Galaxy Evolution Explorer satellite (drawing on a three-dimensional map of galaxies in the distant universe containing hundreds of millions...
New Findings on Rogue Planets
Gravitational microlensing to the rescue. We now have evidence for the existence of the rogue planets -- interstellar wanderers moving through space unattached to any star system -- that we talked about just the other day. It's been assumed that such planets existed, because early solar systems are turbulent and unstable, with planetary migrations like those that lead to 'hot Jupiters' in the inner system. Moving gas giants into orbits closer to their star would cause serious gravitational consequences for other worlds in the system, ejecting some entirely. But while we've been thinking in terms of detecting such worlds through auroral emissions like those produced by Jupiter, researchers at two microlensing projects have made a series of detections by using gravity's effects upon spacetime. Specifically, a stellar system passing in front of a far more distant background star will warp the light of the background object. The resulting magnification and brightening flags the presence...
New Views of a Cometary Core
We looked recently at Titan Mare Explorer (TiME), a mission to land a probe on Titan's Ligeia Mare, a methane-ethane sea that would be observed for an extended period by this floating observatory. But I don't want to pass too quickly over Comet Hopper, one of the other missions being considered by NASA's Discovery Program. This one is a proposal out of the University of Maryland that would land on comet 46P/Wirtanen not once but multiple times, observing the changes on the comet and in its innermost coma as it interacts with the Sun. The innermost coma is the comet's atmosphere immediately above the nucleus, where cometary jets and outgassing originate. Jessica Sunshine, principal investigator for Comet Hopper, says the idea is to watch how surface and coma change through a solar approach: "We've had some amazing cometary flybys but they have given us only snapshots of one point in time of what a comet is like. Comets are exciting because they are dynamic, changing throughout their...
Finding an Interstellar Wanderer
Imagine a planet far more massive than Jupiter and spinning faster than Jupiter's 10 hour rotation. Throw in a large nearby moon and the associated auroral effects that would occur as the moon moved through fields of plasma trapped in the planet's magnetic field. The scenario isn't all that different from what we see happening between Jupiter and Io. But here's the kicker: Put planet and moon far away from any star, a rogue planet scenario of the kind recently discussed by Dorian Abbot and Eric Switzer, who called such rogue planets 'Steppenwolfs.' I jumped on that idea in a Centauri Dreams post last February because interstellar planets have always fascinated me. Abbot and Switzer were interested in whether a rogue planet could support life, finding in their paper that a planet just 3.5 times as massive as the Earth, and with the same basic composition and age, could sustain a liquid ocean under layers of insulating water ice and frozen atmosphere. But our rogue gas giant offers...
SETI Search Focuses on Kepler Planets
The canonical notion of the 'water hole' is that the kind of life we are looking for in our SETI searches will only thrive where there is liquid water. A quiet stretch of the radio spectrum, the water hole has two natural boundaries: The 18 cm emissions from the hydroxyl ion (OH) and the 21 cm emissions from neutral hydrogen. But the choice of frequencies for SETI is obviously not based on mere symbolism. The water hole is a window in the radio spectrum where radio emissions are not significantly absorbed by interstellar dust and other matter between the stars. It's a natural place to look, and SETI@Home users worldwide have used Arecibo data from the waterhole to participate in the hunt, in what has turned out to be a massive distributed computing project. But the latest SETI project to hit the news following the hibernation of the Allen Telescope Array last month goes where Arecibo cannot. This is a new effort at a storied place, the Green Bank facility in West Virginia. This is...
JBIS: Celebrating the ‘Red Cover’ Issues
Working on a book on interstellar flight in 2002, I came across a paper in the Journal of the British Interplanetary Society with a bold title: "A Programme for Interstellar Exploration." I already knew that its author, Robert Forward, was a major figure in the world of deep space studies, an aerospace engineer and inventor with a deep knowledge of physics as well as a popular science fiction author, in whose stories many of his futuristic ideas were played out. What I didn't know until I read the paper was that this man had proposed a step-by-step plan for reaching the stars way back in 1975 at a meeting at the U.S. House of Representatives. These were bold years for interstellar thinking, as witness Forward's appearance before the Subcommittee on Space Science and Applications that year. Forward developed a fifty-year plan for interstellar exploration that, in his words, 'envisions the launch of automated interstellar probes to nearby stellar systems around the turn of the century,...
Dawn on Vesta Approach
The Dawn mission is going to command our attention this summer, with orbital capture around Vesta in mid-July and science data collection beginning a scant two weeks later as the spacecraft produces topographical maps from an altitude of approximately 2700 kilometers. Orbiting the main belt asteroid for one year, Dawn will close to within 200 kilometers to obtain closer images and perform other scientific measurements. And then it's back into cruise mode for the trip to Ceres, another object of intense interest regarding Solar System formation. This ambitious mission is the first ever mounted to orbit two Solar System targets. The image below is Dawn's first look at Vesta, a mere five pixels across in these early approach images. This is the first image of the asteroid Dawn has taken, and images like it will be used to help scientists analyze Vesta's precise location against background stars, helping to tune up the spacecraft's trajectory on the approach. The image was taken when...
Future Splashdown in Ligeia Mare?
Given the budgetary situation, it's nice to know we can still get to the outer Solar System without the cost of a flagship-class mission like Cassini, which weighed in at 3.26 billion -- that included $1.4 billion for pre-launch development, $704 million for mission operations, $54 million for tracking and $422 million for the launch vehicle. Now Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory (JHU/APL) is moving forward on a much cheaper mission concept to reach Titan, one of the three proposals selected as candidates for an upcoming NASA Discovery Program mission. We're now down to three proposals for this mission out of an original 28 submitted last summer, with each team receiving $3 million to develop a still more detailed concept study. The Titan mission is just what the doctor ordered to perk up your ailing sense of wonder, intended to deliver a capsule called Titan Mare Explorer (TiME) that would land in and explore one of the large seas that Cassini has helped us map. The concept...
Habitability Around Nearby Stars
My friend Adam Crowl, a polymath if there ever was one, is working hard on Project Icarus and keeping an eye on the exoplanet situation. When you're working on a starship design, no matter how theoretical, a major issue is the choice of targets, and the study of Kepler planets we looked at yesterday caught Adam's eye some time ago. We're not finding as many planets in the habitable zone thus far in the Kepler hunt as we might hope to, given that the ideal would be a habitable world somewhere within reach of near-future technologies of the kind that Icarus represents. Sure, Kepler's target stars are much further away in most cases, but the mission is giving us a useful statistical sampling from which we can generalize. Working with the data from Lisa Kaltenegger and Dimitri Sasselov's paper, Adam thus takes a back-of-the-envelope stab at the galactic population of terrestrial worlds, knowing that Kepler is far from through, as we're moving into the domain of planets with longer...
Habitable Zone Planets and Kepler
A habitable zone can be defined in many ways, but for our immediate purposes, defining it with reference to liquid water on a planetary surface makes sense. Sure, we believe that life could exist beneath the surface on places like Europa, where surface water is out of the question, but the key issue is this: Are there atmospheric features that we could use to make the call on habitability? It's an important issue because with our current and near-future technology, this is how we can plan to investigate life on planets around other stars. We can study exoplanetary atmospheres already and we're getting better, but we can't drill through exoplanetary ice. A new paper from Lisa Kaltenegger and Dimitri Sasselov (Harvard Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics) gets into these questions by looking at how to evaluate habitability, studying different kinds of planetary atmospheres and developing model calculations. The intent is to apply these ideas to the habitable planet candidates, 54 in...
The Pros and Cons of METI
Tau Zero journalist Larry Klaes has been fascinated by SETI -- and its offshoot METI (Messaging to Extraterrestrial Intelligence) -- for a long time now. Here he steps back to look at METI in context, offering up an examination of the advantages of sending signals to the stars and the offsetting risks. We've looked at many viewpoints on the subject in these pages since Centauri Dreams came online in 2004. But has Larry hit upon a key fact that may trump the arguments of both sides? Is there something about human nature that makes METI more or less inevitable? By Larry Klaes SETI, or the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence, has been conducted by a variety of professional and amateur scientists since 1960 (or 1924 if you want to count a campaign that year which listened for any radio messages from the presumed natives of Mars). SETI primarily involves the passive listening or looking for transmissions from alien civilizations. More recent SETI projects have also attempted to...
Key Effects of General Relativity Confirmed
Gravity Probe B has confirmed two of the most interesting effects predicted by Einstein's General Theory of Relativity. The geodetic effect, which describes the warping of spacetime due to the mass of the Earth, has been confirmed to an accuracy of 0.28 percent. The frame-dragging effect, in which the Earth's rotation drags or stirs local spacetime, is confirmed to 19 percent accuracy. All of this from a project that drew on 34 years of research and development, 10 years of flight preparation and 5 years of analysis of the data returned from a 1.5 year mission. They were a long time coming, but these results are as much milestones in the history of physics as the 1919 measurements of Sir Arthur Eddington that supported Einstein's newly published theory. Subtle Effects, Fantastic Precision Measuring known effects to higher levels of accuracy is key to physics. It has taken so long to achieve these results because General Relativity is hard to test in the vicinity of the Earth, where...
Terrestrial Planets: Find the Debris Disk
Over 900 stars have been found that show signs of a debris disk, a circumstellar disk of dust and debris orbiting the star. It takes less than 10 million years for the gaseous content of these disks to dissipate, leaving the dusty disk behind. You can think of the Kuiper Belt in our own system, but the analogy would be imprecise in a crucial way, for most of these disks show much more dust. In fact, explaining the difference between the debris disks of other stars and what we see in our own system is instructive, and it may offer clues to terrestrial planet formation elsewhere. For we're learning that long-lasting cold dust points to a system-wide stability that is probably crucial. At issue is the question of what happens when gas giants cause gravitational instabilities in a young system. Sean Raymond (Université de Bordeaux) and collaborators tackle the question in a new paper that looks at how planets emerge from circumstellar disks. Inner disks form rocky planets in 10 to...
Goldstone Primed for Asteroid Flyby
With asteroid 2005 YU55 making a close pass later this year, it's worth remembering that we've had a look at this near-Earth object before. It was in April of 2010 that the asteroid, discovered through the efforts of the SpaceWatch Program at the University of Arizona, was deftly imaged by the Arecibo Radio Telescope. That first look was helpful in several ways, the most immediate being that it allowed scientists to rule out the possibility of an Earth impact for the next 100 years. The radar image is fuzzy, but bear in mind that this is an object no more than 400 meters in size, and as the 7.5-meters-per-pixel resolution can make out, it's spherical in shape. Image: This radar image of asteroid 2005 YU55 was generated from data taken in April of 2010 by the Arecibo Radar Telescope in Puerto Rico. Image credit: NASA/Cornell/Arecibo. The next close pass will be on November 8, when 2005 YU55 will close to within about 325,000 kilometers. And this time around, we should learn a great...
A Super-Earth in Transit (and a SETI Digression)
We've been finding planets using radial velocity methods -- analyzing the gravitational effects of planets around their stars -- since the mid-1990s, and the Kepler mission has brought the transit method to the fore, looking at the lightcurves of stars when planets pass in front of them as seen from Earth. Now we have new information about a transiting planet, 55 Cancri e, in a multiple planet system, information that has been developed by reanalyzing earlier radial velocity data. The new techniques were applied by Rebekah Dawson (Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics), working in tandem with Daniel Fabrycky (UC-Santa Cruz) to predict the orbit of 55 Cancri e. Earlier radial velocity data on the planet had suggested a tight orbit of 2.8 days, but the new analysis pegged the orbit at something less than 18 hours. The proximity to the central star meant that the chances of seeing a transit were higher than thought (the probability moved from 13 percent to 33 percent), leading to...