by Claudio Maccone Physicist Les Shepherd, whose funeral is today, left friends throughout the astronautical community. Claudio Maccone, who worked with Shepherd on many occasions, was quick to offer his recollections of this remarkable man whose standards of excellence and unflagging support helped many young scientists as they embarked on careers in space science. A young guy (44 years old, i.e. "young" by IAA standards) joins the IAA Interstellar Space Exploration Committee (ISEC) headed by Les Shepherd and Giovanni Vulpetti: that happened at the World Space Congress in Washington, D.C., USA, also known as the 43rd IAC, August 28 - September 5, 1992). I was then working at Alenia Spazio SpA in Torino (Turin), Italy, and I had this secret love for future interstellar space missions ("secret" since at my space company nobody was interested, of course). So, I consulted with my good old friend and "teacher" (he is senior than I) Giovanni Vulpetti, who was in a similar position at...
Les Shepherd, RIP
There are so many things to say about Les Shepherd, who died on Saturday, February 18, that I scarcely know where to begin. Born in 1918, Leslie Robert Shepherd was a key player in the creation of the International Astronautical Federation (IAF), becoming its third president in 1957 -- this was at the 8th Congress in Barcelona just a week after the launch of Sputnik -- and in 1962 he would be called upon to serve as its president for a second time. A specialist in nuclear fission who became deeply involved in nuclear reactor technology, Shepherd was one of the founding members of the International Academy of Astronautics (IAA), and served as chairman of the Interstellar Space Exploration Committee, which met for the first time at the 1984 IAF Congress in Lausanne, Switzerland. The IAF Congress in Stockholm the following year was the scene of the first ISEC symposium on interstellar flight, one whose papers were subsequently collected in one of the famous 'red cover' issues of the...
Project Icarus: Contemplating Starship Design
Andreas Tziolas, current leader of Project Icarus, gave a lengthy interview recently to The Atlantic's Ross Andersen, who writes about starship design in Project Icarus: Laying the Plans for Interstellar Travel. Icarus encounters continuing controversy over its name, despite the fact that the Icarus team has gone to some lengths to explain the choice. Tziolas notes the nod to Project Daedalus leader Alan Bond, who once referred to "the sons of Daedalus, perhaps an Icarus, that will have to come through and make this a much more feasible design." I like that sense of continuity -- after all, Icarus is the follow-on to the British Interplanetary Society's Project Daedalus of the 1970s, the first serious attempt to engineer a starship. I also appreciate the Icarus' team's imaginative re-casting of the Icarus myth, which imagines a chastened Icarus washed up on a desert island planning to forge wings out of new materials so he can make the attempt again. But what I always fall back on is...
FTL Neutrinos: Closing In on a Solution
The news that the faster-than-light neutrino results announced to such widespread interest by the OPERA collaboration have now been explained has been spreading irresistibly around the Internet. But the brief piece in ScienceInsider that broke the news was stretching a point with a lead reading "Error Undoes Faster-Then-Light Neutrino Results." For when you read the story, you see that a fiber optic cable connection is a possible culprit, though as yet an unconfirmed one. Sean Carroll (Caltech) blogged on Cosmic Variance that while he wanted to pass the news along, he was reserving judgment until a better-sourced statement came to hand. I've thought since the beginning that a systematic error would explain the 'FTL neutrino' story, but I still was waiting for something with more meat on it than the ScienceInsider news. It came later in the day with an official CERN news release, and this certainly bears quoting: The OPERA collaboration has informed its funding agencies and host...
M-Dwarfs: A New and Wider Habitable Zone
I want to work a new paper on red dwarf habitability in here because it fits in so well with yesterday's discussion of the super-Earth GJ1214b. The latter orbits an M-dwarf in Ophiuchus that yields a hefty 1.4 percent transit depth, meaning scientists have a strong lightcurve to work with as they examine this potential 'waterworld.' In transit terms, red dwarfs, much smaller and cooler than the Sun, are compelling exoplanet hosts because any habitable worlds around them would orbit close to their star, making transits frequent. When I first wrote about red dwarfs and habitability in my Centauri Dreams book, it was in connection with the possibilities around Proxima Centauri, but of course we can extend the discussion to M-dwarfs anywhere, this being the most common type of star in the galaxy (leaving brown dwarfs out of the equation until we have a better idea of their prevalence). Manoj Joshi and Robert Haberle had published a paper in 1997 that described their simulations for...
A Waterworld Around GJ1214
I love the way Zachory Berta (Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics) describes his studies of the transiting super-Earth GJ1214b. Referring to his team's analysis of the planet's atmosphere, Berta says "We're using Hubble to measure the infrared color of sunset on this world." And indeed they have done just this, discovering a spectrum that is featureless over a wide range of wavelengths, allowing them to deduce that the planet's atmosphere is thick and steamy. The conclusion most consistent with the data is a dense atmosphere of water vapor. Discovered in 2009 by the MEarth project, GJ1214b has a radius 2.7 times Earth's and a mass 6.5 times that of our planet. It's proven to be a great catch, because its host star, an M-dwarf in the constellation Ophiuchus, offers up a large 1.4 percent transit depth -- this refers to the fractional change in brightness as the planet transits its star. Transiting gas giants, for example, usually have transit depths somewhere around 1 percent,...
Black Hole Flags Galactic Collision
HLX-1 (Hyper-Luminous X-ray source 1) is thought to be a black hole, one that's a welcome discovery for astronomers trying to puzzle out the mysteries of black hole formation. Located roughly 290 million light years from Earth and situated toward the edge of a galaxy called ESO 243-49, this black hole looks to be some 20,000 times the mass of the Sun, which makes it mid-sized when compared with the supermassive black holes at the center of many galaxies. The latter can have masses up to billions of times more than the Sun -- the black hole at the center of our own galaxy is thought to comprise about four million solar masses. Just how a supermassive black hole forms remains a subject for speculation, but study of HLX-1 is giving us clues that point in the direction of a series of mergers of small and mid-sized black holes. For it turns out that HLX-1, discovered by Sean Farrell (Sydney Institute for Astronomy in Australia and University of Leicester, UK) and team at X-ray...
Jupiter’s Protective Role Questioned
How likely are we to find other planets in the universe that are as habitable as Earth? One key to the puzzle has long been thought to be the presence of Jupiter in our own Solar System. In fact, the presence of the giant planet has become a player in the so-called 'rare Earth' argument that sees Jupiter as just one factor that makes our Solar System unique. Put a gas giant in the proper position in any solar system and, so the argument goes, dangerous objects from the outer system will be deflected, protecting the inner planets and allowing life to flourish. The issue gets a hard look from Jonathan Horner (University of New South Wales) and Barrie Jones (The Open University, UK) in a paper delivered in Canberra in September of 2011. Jupiter as protector has a certain appeal. Voyager, Galileo and other probes have shown us a massive planet that is otherwise cold and forbidding, but a world with enough mass to have huge effects on other objects in the Solar System. Horner and Jones...
Alpha Centauri B: A Close Look at the Habitable Zone
The dreams of Alpha Centauri I used to have as a boy all focused on visual effects. After all, the distance between Centauri A and B ranges from 11.4 to 36.0 AU. What would it be like to have a second star in our Solar System, one that occasionally closed to a little more than Saturn’s distance from the Sun? What would a day be like with two stars, and even more, what would night be like with a star that close lighting up the landscape? I also wondered about how much effect a second star would have on the planets in our system, curious as I was about gravitational effects and even the possible repercussions for weather and seasonal change. Image: The Alpha Centauri star system and other objects near it in the sky. Image copyright Akira Fujii / David Malin Images. You can imagine, then, that Duncan Forgan’s new paper hit close to home. Forgan (University of Edinburgh) has taken discussions of habitability around Centauri B to a new level by analyzing the effect of Centauri A on...
‘Light Echo’ Reveals Eta Carinae Puzzle
Luminous Blue Variables are large, bright stars that give rise to periodic eruptions, like the so-called “Great Eruption” of Eta Carinae that was first noted in 1837 and continued to be observed for an additional 21 years. Things must have been lively around the companion star thought to orbit in the nebula around Eta Carinae, for the LBV blew off about 20 solar masses in this era, mimicking a supernova as it became the second brightest star in the sky. We’ve witnessed similar ‘supernova impostor’ events in other galaxies, but at 7500 light years, the Eta Carinae system is relatively nearby, allowing close study by Hubble and other telescopes. What brings Eta Carinae’s 1837 event back into the news is the use of so-called ‘light echoes’ to study what happened at a time when astronomy was in a much earlier state. Armin Rest (Space Telescope Science Institute) notes how useful the work is turning out to be: "When the eruption was seen on Earth 170 years ago, there were no cameras...
A Haze at Galactic Center
The Planck mission continues to peel the layers off the onion as it probes the early universe. Planck is all about the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), that radiation left over from the era of recombination around 380,000 years after the Big Bang. As electrons and protons began to form neutral atoms, light was freed to stream through the universe, an afterglow of the Big Bang that missions like the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe have studied in detail, and which Planck will now observe at still better sensitivity, angular resolution and frequency range. But the initial job for researchers is to remove sources of foreground emission to reveal the CMB itself, and that process is turning up interesting findings in its own right. The latest announcement from the European Space Agency involves a haze of microwaves that is not yet understood. Coming from the region around galactic center, the haze appears to be synchrotron emission, produced as electrons accelerated in supernovae...
KBOs: Surveying the Southern Skies
Given yesterday's post on wandering planets, otherwise known as 'rogue' planets or 'nomads,' today's topic falls easily into place. For even as we ponder the possibility of 105 rogue planets at Pluto's mass or above for every main sequence star in the galaxy, we confront the fact that we still have much to learn about objects much closer to home in our own Kuiper Belt. We have yet, for example, to have a flyby, although it's possible the New Horizons spacecraft will line up on a useful target after its encounter with Pluto/Charon (and yes, it's conceivable that Triton is a captured KBO, and thus we have had a Voyager flyby). The discovery of objects like Sedna, Makemake and Eris makes it clear how much we may yet uncover. We can think of the broader category of Trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs) in terms of potential mission targets, but we should also ponder the fact that their strong dynamical connection with the planets can help us gain insight into the mechanics of Solar System and...
‘Island-Hopping’ to the Stars
We tend to think of interstellar journeys as leaps into the void, leaving the security of one solar system to travel non-stop to another. But a number of alternatives exist, a fact that becomes clear when we ponder that our own cloud of comets -- the Oort Cloud -- is thought to extend a light year out and perhaps a good deal further. There may be ways, in other words, to take advantage of resources like comets and other icy objects for a good part of an interstellar trip. That scenario is not as dramatic as a starship journey, but it opens up possibilities. Let’s say, for example, that we only manage to get up to about 1 percent of lightspeed (3000 kilometers per second) before we run into technical challenges that are at least temporarily insurmountable. Speeds like that take well over 400 years to get a payload to Centauri A and B, but they make movement between planets and out into the Kuiper Belt and Oort Cloud a straightforward proposition. A civilization content to create...
Of Ice and the Planetesimal
Mindful of the recent work on axial tilt I've reported in these pages, I was interested to learn that Vesta's axial tilt is just a bit greater than the Earth's, about 27 degrees. We've been pondering the consequences of such obliquity on planets in the habitable zone, but in Vesta's case, the issue isn't habitability but water ice. For spurred by the Dawn mission, scientists are looking at whether permanently shadowed craters on the asteroid's surface would allow water to stay frozen all year long. Unlike the situation on the Moon, the answer on Vesta (on the surface at least) seems to be no. Earth's axial tilt is 23.5 degrees, but the Moon's is a scant 1.5 degrees, making the shadow in some lunar craters permanent, a fact that has led to speculation that ice in these locations could be of use to future manned missions there. In contrast, Vesta's obliquity means that it has seasons, so that every part of the surface becomes exposed to sunlight at some point in the year. Even so, says...
A ‘Super-Oort’ Cloud at Galactic Center?
Not long ago we looked at comet C/2011 N3 (SOHO), discovered last July just two days before it plunged into the Sun, evaporating some 100,000 kilometers above the solar surface. It was startling to learn that the SOHO observatory is tracking numerous ‘Sun-grazers,’ comets whose fatal encounters with our star are occurring roughly once every three days. Now comes news that Sagittarius A*, the supermassive black hole at the center of the Milky Way, is producing X-ray flares about once a day, thought by some to be the result of similar debris in the process of destruction. The flares last just a few hours, according to researchers working with data from the Chandra X-Ray Observatory, and can reach brightness levels up to 100 times what is normally observed in the black hole region. Kastytis Zubovas (University of Leicester) thinks we’re seeing asteroids and comets passing within 160 million kilometers of the black hole (roughly 1 AU), at which point they would likely be broken apart by...
Two Takes on Extraterrestrial Life
"With exoplanets we are entering new territory," says René Heller (Leibniz Institute for Astrophysics, Potsdam), talking about recent studies looking at axial tilt as a parameter for habitability on a planet. Heller is getting at the fact that while we've studied the axis of a planet's spin relative to the plane of its orbit rather thoroughly here in our own Solar System, we are a long way from being able to discern the axial tilt of exoplanets, much less make definitive statements about its effect on habitability. Right now we can say something about the size, mass and orbital period of many distant planets (and in a few cases, some of the components of their atmosphere) and that's about where our knowledge stops. Heller imagines the Earth with an axial tilt something akin to that of Uranus, whose equator and ring system run almost perpendicular to the plane of its orbit. Introduce such high obliquity to the Earth and the north pole would point at the Sun for a quarter of the...
Untangling a Lensed Galaxy
Gravitational lensing always gets my attention not only because of its growing use in astronomy but because of its potential for deep space missions like FOCAL, Claudio Maccone's concept for a deep space probe that would be sent beyond the Sun's 550 AU gravitational lensing distance to make observations of astronomical targets. FOCAL is an interstellar precursor mission that could give us detailed information about any system to which we might send a future probe. And, as Maccone has shown, lensing could also be used to create the kind of robust communications relay that would function with little data loss over huge distances. But we don't have to wait for FOCAL to exploit the potential of lensing for studying distant exoplanets. As Centauri Dreams readers know, gravitational microlensing has developed into a potent tool. A foreground star distorts the light from a background object when the alignment is right, and that magnification is likewise affected by planets orbiting the...
Targeting Primitive Asteroids
I see that there is a symposium on the MarcoPolo-R mission coming up in late March, which reminds me that at a time when asteroid missions are increasingly in the news, I have yet to cover this one. It was about a year ago that the European Space Agency selected MarcoPolo-R as one of four candidates for a medium-class mission that would launch between 2020 and 2024. The selection doesn't mean the mission has been finalized by any means, only that the four missions chosen will undergo a down-selection process to choose the one to implement. Thus this mission to return a sample of material from a near-Earth asteroid for analysis in ground laboratories will have to prove itself against some formidable competition, including another particularly interesting concept called the Exoplanet Characterisation Observatory (EChO), which would orbit around the L2 Lagrange point and study exoplanet atmospheres. Exoplanets are obviously hot property right now, but asteroids are also having their...
SETI in the News
Let me draw your attention to two interesting stories this morning, one harking back to the night in August of 1977 when the Big Ear radio telescope at Ohio State University recorded the famous 'Wow!' signal. For those unfamiliar with it, the 'Wow!' signal gets its name from Big Ear volunteer Jerry Ehman's annotation (several days later) on the signal's printout. 'Wow!' seemed appropriate for a signal that was 30 times stronger in volume than the background noise and took up a single 10 kilohertz-wide band on the receiver, an enigmatic 70-second narrow-band burst at almost precisely 1420 megahertz, the emission frequency of hydrogen. A message from an extraterrestrial civilization? 'Wow!' seemed to fit the bill, but it disappeared and despite more than 50 repeated searches by the Big Ear team, it never recurred. In this article for The Planetary Society, Amir Alexander calls the signal "...the single most intriguing result ever produced by the Search for Extraterrestrial...
‘Super-Earth’ in a Triple Star System
GJ 667C is an M-class dwarf, part of a triple star system some 22 light years from Earth. Hearing rumors that a 'super-Earth' -- and one in the habitable zone to boot -- has been detected around a nearby triple star system might cause the pulse to quicken, but this is not Alpha Centauri, about which we continue to await news from the three teams studying the prospect of planets there. Nonetheless, GJ 667C is fascinating in its own right, the M-dwarf being accompanied by a pair of orange K-class stars much lower in metal content than the Sun. The super-Earth that orbits the M-dwarf raises questions about theories of planet formation. Thus Steven Vogt (UC Santa Cruz), who puts the find into context, noting that heavy elements like iron, carbon and silicon are considered the building blocks of terrestrial planets: "This was expected to be a rather unlikely star to host planets. Yet there they are, around a very nearby, metal-poor example of the most common type of star in our galaxy....