Lowering Life’s Chances on Super-Earths

Super-Earths are exciting finds. The more of them we discover, the more likely it seems that life is abundant in the cosmos. But new work examining the viscosity and melting temperature of mantle rock is casting a different aura over super-Earths. Rather than being planets much like the Earth but simply more massive -- worlds characterized by thick atmospheres, plate tectonics, volcanic activity and magnetic fields -- they may differ in fundamental ways. With internal pressures tens of times higher than those found in Earth's interior, large viscosities and melting temperatures could have adverse consequences on the planet's habitability. The potential effects extend as far as the core of the planet, which may not even exist. In a presentation at the European Planetary Science Congress on September 26, Vlada Stamenkovic (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) noted that the average super-Earth may in fact be undifferentiated; i.e., it may not have separated into a metallic core and a...

read more

Pluto, Charon and Kepler

Our view of Pluto/Charon gets better and better as we prepare for the New Horizons flyby in 2015. It wasn't so long ago that we had no idea Pluto had a single moon, much less the five we have so far identified. When James Christy (USNO) discovered Charon in 1978, he was looking at photographic plates of Pluto that showed little more than a slight bulge that appeared periodically. The bulge came into and out of view as the [dwarf] planet rotated, indicating a genuine object and not a flaw in the observation, but although Charon had been found, we couldn't resolve separate disks until the Hubble Space Telescope's images of the 1990s. Image: Plates taken with the Kaj Strand Astrometric Reflector at the USNO Flagstaff Station in Arizona revealed the existence of Charon, visible as an elongation in the image. Later eclipses and occultations of Pluto and Charon confirmed the discovery. Charon has a mass of about 22 percent that of Pluto. Credit: Wikimedia Commons. The Hubble images,...

read more

Life-Bearing Rocks in Slow Motion

I've been fascinated with Edward Belbruno's work on 'chaotic orbits' ever since meeting him at an astrodynamics conference in Princeton some years back. The idea is to develop low-energy routes for spacecraft by analyzing so-called 'weak stability boundaries,' regions where motion is highly sensitive and small changes can create gradual orbital change. A low-energy route was what Belbruno used in 1991 to help the Japanese spacecraft Hiten reach the Moon using almost no fuel, a proof of concept about which the physicist said "It saved the spacecraft, and it saved my career." That comment came from a lecture to the Mathematical Association of America in 2009 that you can listen to here. It's fascinating in its own right, but doubly so since Belbruno is back in the news with new findings on the idea of panspermia, and specifically that version of panspermia called lithopanspermia. In this hypothesis, elemental life forms are distributed between stars in planetary fragments created by...

read more

The Billion Year Plan

At the 100 Year Starship Symposium in Houson, I sent out a large number of tweets as @centauri_dreams. That Twitter account is still live, but be aware that my son Miles, who is now working actively with us, has set up a new account solely for the Tau Zero Foundation. You can access @TZFoundation to pick up interesting links and news of the interstellar community. I suspect, for example, that when Miles runs across articles like the one I'm going to be discussing today, they'll appear on Twitter, but he's bound to find a lot of good material that I miss. Yesterday we were looking at distance issues as Larry Klaes discussed the extension of Ithaca, NY's Sagan Planet Walk all the way to Hawaii, where a new 'station' represents Alpha Centauri. Matters of scale are important to convey to the public because getting across the distances involved in interstellar flight is tricky, and various ways of modeling them can provide the needed perspective. Peter Garretson thinks about scale as...

read more

To Alpha Centauri via Hawai’i

I’m always looking for ways to relate interstellar distances to common objects on Earth, knowing that misunderstandings about the vast scale of the universe are common. Sir John Herschel (1792-1871) talked about dropping a pea off the side of a ship after every mile on an ocean voyage the distance of the nearest star, telling his readers that it would require ‘a fleet of 10,000 ships of 600 tons burthen, each starting with a full cargo of peas.’ Herschel was the first to try to measure the distance to Alpha Centauri, and while his numbers weren’t as accurate as ours, he captured for his era the disconnect between Earthly distances and the heavens. Larry Klaes weighs in this morning with yet another way to study the issue, using an exhibition on the interplanetary scale that has now been extended Herschel-style to the ultimate voyage. By Larry Klaes Since its dedication in 1997, the Sagan Planet Walk has become a landmark feature of downtown Ithaca, New York. The various monuments, or...

read more

Keeping the Worldship Alive

One of the challenges of explaining why a starship project is worth doing even though its final goal may not be realized for a long time is in showing how this work can have an impact on improving things on Earth. Technological spinoffs have acquired a bad name because of the stigma of Teflon and Tang -- NASA hasn't made the strongest case for how advanced work changes lives (and in any case, Teflon and Tang are not actually NASA spinoffs, though they are in the eyes of the public). But work in space can effect profound changes on Earth, and there is every reason to believe that energy breakthroughs in propulsion and power generation could be highly useful in solving our planet's future energy demands. [See the comments for a recent change to this text]. The list can obviously be expanded, as in the case of closed ecologies, which we've been talking about recently in these pages. A long-duration human mission demands attention to environments and their maintenance that will surely...

read more

A Space Telescope Enmeshed in History

It's been heartening to see renewed interest in the space program's past. Neil Armstrong's death surely had something to do with it, for the scattering of his ashes at sea, which occurred while the 100 Year Starship Symposium was in session, was a reminder of the dramatic days when public fascination with space was intense and the whole world rejoiced at Apollo 11's success. The memorial ceremony held at the National Cathedral in Washington the day before had focused everyone's gaze on that great mission, which remained in the air throughout, a continuing counterpoint to formal discussions and casual conversations in the hallways. Larry Klaes has passed along another historical marker, the fact that today could be called the 60th anniversary of the interplanetary probe. As in so many eventful astronautical moments, the British Interplanetary Society was involved. Eric Burgess and C. A. Cross had come to a BIS meeting in 1952 to read a paper called "The Martian Probe," which took the...

read more

Wrapping Up the Houston Starship

Because I utterly lack their skills, I have huge admiration for practical-minded people who can organize things well. Eric Davis’ work as track chair for the ‘Time and Distance Solutions’ track in Houston is a case in point. The challenge is in coping with a key fact of interstellar studies: We are so early in the game that we have not remotely figured out which propulsion method makes the most sense for journeys of this magnitude. Discussing time and distance means culling papers to find a balance of ideas, from what could be near-term (fusion, although it always seems near-term) to highly speculative (antimatter and nanotech). Image: Physicist Eric Davis, a highly visible figure at the Houston conference. Eric nailed the composition of the track, and it was because of that that I stayed in it through the conference. The temptation of getting involved with alternate tracks on ‘Becoming an Interstellar Civilization’ and especially ‘Destinations and Habitats’ was huge, but it was the...

read more

A Lab Experiment to Test Spacetime Distortion

Sonny White's work on exotic propulsion has galvanized the press, as witness this story in the Daily Mail, one of many articles in newspapers and online venues. I was fortunate enough to be in the sessions at the 100 Year Starship Symposium where White, an engaging and affable speaker, described what his team at Eagleworks Laboratories (Johnson Space Center) is doing. The issue at hand is whether a so-called 'warp drive' that distorts spacetime itself is possible given the vast amounts of energy it demands. White's team believes the energy problem may not be as severe as originally thought. Here I'll quote Richard Obousy, head of Icarus Interstellar, who told Clara Moskowitz in Space.com: "Everything within space is restricted by the speed of light. But the really cool thing is space-time, the fabric of space, is not limited by the speed of light." On that idea hangs the warp drive. Physicists Michael Pfenning and Larry Ford went to work on Miguel Alcubierre's 1994 paper, the first...

read more

Saturday at the 100 Year Starship Symposium

While I didn't see too many technical glitches at the 100 Year Starship Symposium in Houston, I ran into plenty of them in my own attempts to cover the event. The banquet hall where the opening ceremonies were held -- and where the plenary sessions occurred each day -- was impervious to the hotel's WiFi, so that I was unable to use Twitter. Friday's technical sessions in the conference rooms went fine, and I managed to send out a steady stream of tweets from the 'Time and Distance Solutions' track. But halfway through the Saturday sessions, Twitter itself went down. I tried all afternoon to get on, but though my Net connection was strong, Twitter wouldn't come up. Image: Early arrivals setting up at the opening plenary session for the 100 Year Starship Symposium. Everything in order but the WiFi. My experience with US Airways was about the same. The two flights out to Houston were uneventful, but coming back I was on an aircraft that reached new levels of passenger compression. With...

read more

Time and Distance in Houston

? At left is Mae Jemison, snapped from my seat as she spoke to open yesterday morning's sessions. I couldn't tweet about her comments because the hotel Wi-Fi wasn't working in the room. Several people asked me today why I was still using a ‘netbook’ to take notes and send out tweets from the Houston symposium. It’s an easy answer -- I need a standard keyboard rather than a virtual one, and despite the beauty of tablets like the iPad, I don’t want to carry a separate keyboard around. Besides, my little 10-inch screen Asus serves me well, gives me all the connectivity I need, and runs Linux much faster than the original Windows that it came with (I blew Windows off the hard disk as soon as I bought it and slipped Ubuntu on effortlessly, continually updating it ever since). At $350, which is what it set me back a few years ago, the netbook is a no-brainer for places where I need to make a lot of notes, and if I leave it in a taxi or drop it, the financial loss is minuscule. Image: Mae...

read more

Houston: Meetings and Reconnections

?Bring an umbrella to Houston? I figured it would be unnecessary and left it out of my luggage. Lo and behold yesterday morning it began to rain and it seems to have continued off and on most of the day. That hardly matters when you’re in a huge high-rise hotel, but it’s a good thing it didn’t happen Wednesday night, when I walked all over downtown looking for restaurants. I favor inexpensive ethnic places with interesting menus but also love any place with a decent wine list and crusty bread baked in-house. I walk 3-5 miles each day and get seriously stressed out when I don’t get in the exercise, so I’m hoping the rain will be gone or at least sporadic enough today to let me get out a bit. Houston’s humidity, I must say, did slow down my pace in each journey I’ve taken so far. No time for walking yesterday, though, as I spent all day in meetings re the 100 Year Starship organization and future planning. It was great fun to be with a small group including 100 Year Starship leader Mae...

read more

A Stellar Thursday in Texas

?A few words before a long day begins. I’m in meetings all Thursday here in Houston as the 100 Year Starship Symposium gets going, having slept well last night on the gigantic bed provided by the Hyatt. The travel day was uneventful. I had decided to make this a non-digital flight as much as possible so as to get through security with less difficulty. That meant the laptop went in a checked bag, the Kindle stayed home, and for the plane I took an actual book, one with pages that you turn by hand, a cover, and an index in place of a search engine. So much for my plans - everything was going great until a couple of coins in my pocket set off the alarms and I got patted down. Image: Yesterday afternoon's view from my room. The Hyatt Regency has a rotating restaurant on its 31st floor. Despite Calvin Trillin's famous exhortation never to eat in a restaurant that rotates, I found the food quite good, including a spectacular glass of Cloudy Bay Sauvignon Blanc from New Zealand. Nice view,...

read more

On to Houston

I'm on my way to Houston for the 100 Year Starship symposium, and I should be airborne before this clicks into visibility through the wonders of automation. I'm involved in meetings all day Thursday and then into regular symposium activities for the rest of the weekend, about which I'll be reporting next week and to a certain extent from the site itself. Last year in Orlando I wound up sending out more tweets than blog posts from the actual venue and this year I've decided to more or less play it by ear, seeing what opportunities arise and how best to convey them. If you're following me on Twitter as @centauri_dreams, be advised that I don't know how much I'll be tweeting, but feel free to 'unfollow' me as needed if you start getting more than you bargained for. You can always sign back up again after the symposium. What I've learned over the years is that I'm not good at multitasking, and my priority has to be getting accurate notes from the various workshops and technical sessions...

read more

The Psychology of Space Exploration: A Review

By Larry Klaes A new book looking at the inner lives of astronauts is Larry Klaes' subject today. Planning for long-term missions like a manned trip to Mars requires a great deal of work on closed systems, as we've recently discussed. But we also have to consider the psychological issues raised by confinement in a cramped environment for long durations, issues that are one thing in the confines of low-Earth orbit but perhaps another when far from the home world. Early on the morning of February 5, 2007, several officers from the Orlando Police Department in Florida were summoned to the Orlando International Airport, where they arrested a female suspect. This woman was alleged to have attacked another woman she had been stalking while the latter sat in her car in the airport parking lot. Judging by the various items later found in the vehicle the suspect had used as transportation to the Sunshine State all the way from her home in Houston, Texas, her ultimate intent was to kidnap and...

read more

Crowdsourcing Breakthrough Propulsion Ideas

Making Progress on Star Trek Physics is Marc Millis' foray into crowdsourcing, a just announced project on Kickstarter. For those new to the concept, Kickstarter allows the general public to make donations to projects that are described on the site. A deadline is established and so is a minimum funding goal -- if the goal is not reached by the deadline, no funds are collected. $275 million have been raised for various Kickstarter projects thus far and Millis is hoping to catch this wave in support of a new book on breakthrough propulsion concepts that is aimed at a broad, general audience. Centauri Dreams readers will recall that Millis and Eric Davis co-edited 2009's Frontiers of Propulsion Science, published by the AIAA. The first compilation on topics Millis analyzed as head of NASA's Breakthrough Propulsion Physics project, Frontiers was lengthy (22 individual essays in 739 pages) and written specifically with a graduate-level and professional audience in mind. The new project...

read more

100 Year Starship Symposium Next Week

The 100 Year Starship 2012 Public Symposium begins next week, with the recently announced news that former president Bill Clinton will serve as honorary chair for the event. I'm not sure whether a US president has ever spoken about starships before, but what Clinton said was this: "This important effort helps advance the knowledge and technologies required to explore space, all while generating the necessary tools that enhance our quality of life on earth." The symposium takes a decidedly multi-disciplinary theme, with speakers on topics ranging from engineering to ethics, philosophy, the social sciences and biology. Our recent discussions about experimenting with self-enclosed ecosystems flow naturally into the upcoming event in light of the range of topics to be covered. In addition to the speakers and scientific papers, four workshops have been announced. Let me pull some excerpts on the workshops directly off the 100 Year Starship page: Workshop 1: Research Priorities for the...

read more

Space Imperative: Building Closed Ecologies

Long journeys by spaceship are a staple of science fiction, but we know all too little about how to sustain a human habitat in a hostile environment. Experiments in closed ecosystems simply reveal how much work will have to go toward this subject before we can talk about moving out into the Solar System, much less sending missions outside of it. One experiment in this direction was Bios-3, conducted at the Institute of Biophysics in the Russian city of Krasnoyarsk. John Allen, himself deeply involved with the later Biosphere 2 project, called Bios-3 "something of a clandestine legend to the handful of people actually working on closed life systems." The thought behind Bios-3, which was completed in 1972, was to develop closed ecosystems that could support a crew of up to three in a 315 cubic meter space that would be divided into four areas, one designated for the crew, the others for growing food sources, with xenon lamps acting as the light source and power supplied by a nearby...

read more

Robotics: Pushing the Envelope

"My increasingly sophisticated laptops are starting to develop personalities of their own," says Charles Lineweaver (Australian National University), as interviewed by Peter Spinks in The Age. It's a whimsical remark in the context of a discussion on robotics in space missions, but I think many of us can relate to it. We all tend to anthropomorphize at the drop of a hat, reading motives and reactions into the routine habits of our pets that may say more about us than about them. Maybe making things seem human is an essential part of what being human is. It's worth thinking about all this given the successes as well as the limitations of robotic technologies. I'm all in favor of both robotics and a robust manned program, but right now deep space is a machine's game, and budget realities tell me it will remain so for the foreseeable future. That being the case, and again, with our tendency to anthropomorphize our machinery, there was a certain frisson associated with Curiosity's...

read more

Small Town Among the Stars

As we've had increasing reason to speculate, travel to the stars may not involve biological life forms but robotics and artificial intelligence. David Brin's new novel Existence (Tor, 2012) cartwheels through many an interstellar travel scenario -- including a biological option involving building the colonists upon arrival out of preserved genetic materials -- but the real fascination is in a post-biological solution. I don't want to give anything away in this superb novel because you're going to want to read it yourself, but suffice it to say that uploading a consciousness to an extremely small spacecraft is one very viable possibility. So imagine a crystalline ovoid just a few feet long in which an intelligence can survive, uploaded from the original and, as far as it perceives, a continuation of that original consciousness. One of the ingenious things about this kind of spacecraft in Brin's novel is that its occupants can make themselves large enough to observe and interact with...

read more

Charter

In Centauri Dreams, Paul Gilster looks at peer-reviewed research on deep space exploration, with an eye toward interstellar possibilities. For many years this site coordinated its efforts with the Tau Zero Foundation. It now serves as an independent forum for deep space news and ideas. In the logo above, the leftmost star is Alpha Centauri, a triple system closer than any other star, and a primary target for early interstellar probes. To its right is Beta Centauri (not a part of the Alpha Centauri system), with Beta, Gamma, Delta and Epsilon Crucis, stars in the Southern Cross, visible at the far right (image courtesy of Marco Lorenzi).

Now Reading

Recent Posts

On Comments

If you'd like to submit a comment for possible publication on Centauri Dreams, I will be glad to consider it. The primary criterion is that comments contribute meaningfully to the debate. Among other criteria for selection: Comments must be on topic, directly related to the post in question, must use appropriate language, and must not be abusive to others. Civility counts. In addition, a valid email address is required for a comment to be considered. Centauri Dreams is emphatically not a soapbox for political or religious views submitted by individuals or organizations. A long form of the policy can be viewed on the Administrative page. The short form is this: If your comment is not on topic and respectful to others, I'm probably not going to run it.

Follow with RSS or E-Mail

RSS
Follow by Email

Follow by E-Mail

Get new posts by email:

Advanced Propulsion Research

Beginning and End

Archives