The Search for ‘Chaotic Earths’

As we get the next generation of space-based telescopes into operation, one of our more significant problems is going to be knowing where to look. After all, once we've identified potentially interesting planets for follow-up with spectroscopic analysis of their atmospheres, we're still faced with the need to focus on the most likely targets. Telescope time is precious, and the ability to rule out planets so as to whittle down our list is a necessary skill to refine. On that score, Rory Barnes (University of Washington) and colleagues have weighed in with a particular type of planetary configuration we may want to avoid. Barnes is interested in solar systems where gravity plays a significant role in disrupting what might otherwise be a circular orbit in the habitable zone. Some of these effects may be relatively small, but if. over time, we elongate the orbit of an otherwise habitable planet by these small interactions, we can all but eliminate its chances for life. The particular...

read more

Evidence Mounts for Ganymede’s Ocean

Yesterday's discussion of hydrothermal activity inside Saturn's moon Enceladus reminds us how much we can learn about what is inside an object by studying what is outside it. In Enceladus' case, Cassini's detection of tiny rock particles rich in silicon as the spacecraft arrived in the Saturnian system led to an investigation of how these grains were being produced inside Enceladus through interactions between water and minerals. If correctly interpreted, these data point to the first active hydrothermal system ever found beyond Earth. Now Ganymede swings into the spotlight, with work that is just as interesting. Joachim Saur and colleagues at the University of Cologne drew their data not from a spacecraft on the scene but from the Hubble Space Telescope, using Ganymede's own auroral activity as the investigative tool. Their work gives much greater credence to something that has been suspected since the 1970s: An ocean deep within the frozen crust of the moon. Image: NASA's Hubble...

read more

Hydrothermal Activity in the ‘Broken Heart’ of Enceladus

Enceladus has been a magnet for investigation since 2005, when the Cassini spacecraft began to reveal the unusual activity at the moon's south pole, where we subsequently learned that geysers of water ice and vapor laden with salts and organic materials were spraying into space from deeply fractured terrain. Subsequent studies have homed in on what is now believed to be a 10-kilometer deep ocean beneath an ice shell 30 to 40 kilometers thick. Now we learn that evidence for hydrothermal activity -- water reacting with a rocky crust in a process that warms and saturates it with minerals -- has been found on Enceladus, drawing on a four-year analysis of Cassini data. The new paper, published in Nature, is one of two just out that paint a gripping picture of active processes on the moon. It uses computer simulations and laboratory experiments to make sense out of Cassini's early detection of silicon-rich rock particles flung into space by Enceladus' geysers. Researchers working on data...

read more

Mission Updates: New Horizons, Hayabusa 2

While we wait for the Dawn spacecraft to come back around the lit side of Ceres as it continues a long period of orbital adjustment, let's check in on two other spacecraft with the potential for a big science return. New Horizons performed a 93-second thruster burn on March 10 that was the farthest burn from Earth of any spacecraft in history. We're now in the approach phase to Pluto/Charon and this was the first maneuver of that phase, designed to slow the spacecraft by a mere 1.14 meters per second. The New Horizons team describes this as 'a tap on the brakes' considering that the probe is moving at 14.5 kilometers per second. As this New Horizons news update informs us, yesterday's burn delayed arrival time at Pluto/Charon by 14 minutes, 30 seconds as the spacecraft's course was adjusted. New Horizons is now 149 million kilometers from Pluto -- in other words, 1 astronomical unit, or AU, meaning the spacecraft is the same distance from its target as the Earth is from the Sun. It...

read more

The Fermi Question: No Paradox At All

We've talked often enough about the so-called 'Fermi paradox' in these pages, but Gregory Benford recently passed along a new paper from Robert H. Gray making the case that there is in fact no paradox, and that Fermi's intentions have been misunderstood. It's an interesting point, because as it turns out, Fermi himself never published anything on the subject of interstellar travel or the consequences if it proved possible. The famous lunch conversation at Los Alamos in 1950 when he asked 'Where is everybody' (or perhaps 'Where are they') has often been seen as a venue for Fermi to express his doubts about the existence of any extraterrestrial civilization, and the 'Fermi Paradox' has become a common trope of interstellar studies. Robert Gray (Gray Consulting, Chicago) believes this is a misunderstanding, and sorts through the aftermath of that particular event. It would be another 27 years before the term 'Fermi paradox' even appeared in print, inserted into a JBIS paper by D. G....

read more

Searching for Exoplanet Rings

Not long ago we looked at the discovery of what appears to be a disk orbiting the huge gas giant J1407b (see Enormous Ring System Hints of Exomoons). The example of Saturn is one thing that makes us wonder whether rings might exist around exoplanets, but of course in our own Solar System we also have Jupiter, Uranus and Neptune as hosts of ring systems of different sizes. In the case of J1407b, we’re not strictly sure that the object is a planet. If it’s actually a brown dwarf, we might be observing a protoplanetary disk in a young system. I’m not surprised when it comes to looking for ring systems around exoplanets that David Kipping (Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics) should be in the mix. Working with Jorge Zuluaga (University of Antioquia) and two of their students, Kipping is co-author of a paper discussing how we might identify what are now being called ‘exorings.’ As illustrated in the figure below, an exoplanet’s transit signature is a key, taking advantage of the...

read more

Dawn Orbits Ceres

I spent the morning working on an interesting paper about detecting 'exorings' -- ring systems like Saturn's around exoplanets -- while switching back and forth to Twitter and various Web sources to follow events as the Dawn spacecraft became gravitationally captured by Ceres. I have problems with so-called 'multi-tasking,' which at least in my case means I do two things at once, performing each task less effectively than if I were tackling them separately. Fortunately, I have all weekend to tune up the exorings story, and I put it temporarily aside to work on Dawn's historic arrival. Congratulations to the entire Dawn team on the continuance of this splendid mission. We have much to look forward to as observations proceed and the orbit stabilizes. Similarly, we have the almost immediate prospect of following New Horizons in to Pluto/Charon, another case of a previously blurry object taking on breathtaking resolution as the days pass. The bounty of 2015 then opens into an uncertain...

read more

Planet in a Quadruple Star System

Planets in multiple star systems intrigue us particularly when we try to imagine the view from the surface. Call it the 'Tatooine Effect,' made to order for visual effects specialists and cinematographers. But planets like these also raise interesting issues. Lewis Roberts (JPL) and colleagues have just published a new study of the 30 Ari system, demonstrating that it is a quadruple star system with a gas giant of about four times the mass of Jupiter in a 335 day orbit around its primary star. We already knew about the planet in the 30 Ari system. What's new is the discovery of the additional star. At 23 AU from the planet, the newly discovered fourth star would seem to be a factor in the orbital dynamics of the gas giant, but just what effects it has remain to be studied. The paper, which also reports the detection of a stellar companion to the exoplanet host system HD 2638, notes that 30 Ari is the second quadruple system known to host an exoplanet. And interestingly, both HD 2638...

read more

Strategies for Life on Titan

Back in September of 1961, Isaac Asimov penned an essay in Fantasy & Science Fiction under the title "Not As We Know It," from which this startling passage: ...when we go out into space there may be more to meet us than we expect. I would look forward not only to our extra-terrestrial brothers who share life-as-we-know-it. I would hope also for an occasional cousin among the life-not-as-we-know-it possibilities. In fact, I think we ought to prefer our cousins. Competition may be keen, even overkeen, with our brothers, for we may well grasp at one another's planets; but there need only be friendship with our hot-world and cold-world cousins, for we dovetail neatly. Each stellar system might pleasantly support all the varieties, each on its own planet, and each planet useless to and undesired by any other variety. Asimov's idea, prompted by a monster movie excursion with his children, was to look at realistic ways that life much different from our own could emerge. Here he anticipated...

read more

Were There Planets Inside Mercury’s Orbit?

With the Mercury Messenger mission now coming to its end, it seems an appropriate time to speculate on why our inner Solar System looks the way it does. After all, as we continue finding new solar systems, we’re discovering many multi-planet systems with planets -- often more than one -- closer to their star than Mercury is to ours. We have Kepler to thank for these discoveries, its data analyzed in a number of recent papers including one arguing that about 5 percent of all Kepler stars have systems with tightly packed inner planets. The awkward acronym for such systems is STIP. Well, maybe it’s not all that awkward, and Kathryn Volk and Brett Gladman (University of British Columbia) have good cause to deploy it in their new paper, which focuses on this topic. They’re wondering why our Solar System lacks planets inside Mercury’s orbit, and they point to the paper I mentioned above (Lissauer et al, 2014) as well as another by Francois Fressin and colleagues that concludes that half of...

read more

Seeing Ceres: Then and Now

I'm interested in how we depict astronomical objects, a fascination dating back to a set of Mount Palomar photographs I bought at Adler Planetarium in Chicago when I was a boy. The prints were large and handsome, several of them finding a place on the walls of my room. I recall an image of Saturn that seemed glorious in those days before we actually had an orbiter around the place. The contrast between what we could see then and what we would soon see up close was exciting. I was convinced we were about to go to these worlds and learn their secrets. Then came Pioneer, and Voyager, and Cassini. And, of course, Dawn. As we discover more and more about Ceres, the process repeats itself, as it will again when New Horizons reaches Pluto/Charon. Below is a page from a book called Picture Atlas of Our Universe, published in 1980 by the National Geographic. Larry Klaes forwarded several early images last week as a reminder of previous depictions of the main belt's largest asteroid, or dwarf...

read more

Astrobiology: A Cautionary Tale

We're discovering planets around other stars at such a clip that moving to the next step -- studying their atmospheres for markers of life -- has become a priority. But what techniques will we use and, more to the point, how certain can we be of their results? Centauri Dreams columnist Andrew LePage has been mulling these matters over in the context of how we've approached life on a much closer world. Before the Viking landers ever touched down on Mars, a case was being made for life there that seemed compelling. LePage's account of that period offers a cautionary tale about astrobiology, and a ringing endorsement of the scientific method. A senior project scientist at Visidyne, Inc., Drew is also the voice behind Drew ex Machina. by Andrew LePage Every time I read an article in the popular astronomy press about how some new proposed instrument will allow signs of life to be detected on a distant extrasolar planet, I cannot help but be just a little skeptical. For those of us with...

read more

A Laser ‘Comb’ for Exoplanet Work

It's been years since I've written about laser frequency comb (LFC) technology, and recent work out of the Max Planck Institute of Quantum Optics, the Kiepenheuer Institute for Solar Physics and the University Observatory Munich tells me it's time to revisit the topic. At stake here are ways to fine-tune the spectral analysis of starlight to an unprecedented degree, obviously a significant issue when you're dealing with radial velocity readings of stars that are as tiny as those we use to find exoplanets. Remember what's happening in radial velocity work. A star moves slightly when it is orbited by a planet, a tiny change in speed that can be traced by studying the Doppler shift of the incoming starlight. That light appears blue-shifted as the star moves, however slightly, towards us, while shifting to the red as it moves away. The calibration techniques announced in the team's paper show us that it's possible to measure a change of speed of roughly 3 cm/s with their methods, whereas...

read more

Soft Robotics for a Europa Rover

Approaching problems from new directions can be unusually productive, something I always think of in terms of Mason Peck's ideas on using Jupiter as a vast accelerator to drive a stream of micro-spacecraft (Sprites) on an interstellar mission. Now Peck, working with Robert Shepherd (both are at Cornell University) is proposing a new kind of rover, one ideally suited for Europa. The idea, up for consideration at the NASA Innovative Advanced Concepts (NIAC) program, is once again to exploit a natural phenomenon in place of a more conventional technology. What Peck and Shepherd have in mind is the use of 'soft robotics' -- autonomous machines made of low-stiffness polymers or other such material -- to exploit local energy beneath Europa's ice. We're at the edge of a new field here, with soft robotics advocates using principles imported from more conventional rigid robot designs to work with pliable materials in a wide range of applications, some of which tie in with the growth in 3D...

read more

Beta Pictoris: New Analysis of Circumstellar Disk

Our discovery of the interesting disk around Beta Pictoris dates back all the way to 1984, marking the first time a star was known to host a circumstellar ring of dust and debris. But it’s interesting how far back thinking on such disks extends. Immanuel Kant’s Universal Natural History and Theory of the Heavens (1755) proposed a model of rotating gas clouds that condensed and flattened because of gravity, one that would explain how planets form around stars. Pierre-Simon Laplace developed a similar model independently, proposing it in 1796, after which the idea of gaseous clouds in the plane of the disk continued to be debated as alternative theories on planet formation emerged. Today we can view debris disks directly and learn from their interactions. Out of the Beta Pictoris discovery have grown numerous observations including the new visible-light Hubble images shown below. The beauty of this disk is that we see it edge-on and, because of the large amount of light-scattering dust...

read more

Scholz’s Star: A Close Flyby

The star HIP 85605 until recently seemed more interesting than it may now turn out to be. In a recent paper, Coryn Bailer-Jones (Max Planck Institute for Astronomy, Heidelberg) noted that the star in the constellation Hercules had a high probability of coming close enough to our Solar System in the far future (240,000 to 470,000 years from now) that it would pass through the Oort Cloud, potentially disrupting comets there. The possibility of a pass as close as .13 light years (8200 AU) was there, but Bailer-Jones cautioned that distance measurements of this star could be incorrect. His paper on nearby stellar passes thus leaves the HIP 85605 issue unresolved. Enter Eric Mamajek (University of Rochester) and company. Working with data from the Southern African Large Telescope (SALT) and the Magellan telescope at Las Campanas Observatory in Chile, Mamajek showed that the distance to HIP 85605 has been underestimated by a factor of ten. As Bailer-Jones seems to have suspected, the new...

read more

Ceres: Past and Future

Now it's really getting interesting. Here are the two views of Ceres that the Dawn spacecraft acquired on February 12. The distance here is about 83,000 kilometers, the images taken ten hours apart and magnified. As has been true each time we've talked about Ceres in recent weeks, these views are the best ever attained, with arrival at the dwarf planet slated for March 6. What I notice and really enjoy about watching Dawn in action is the pace of the encounter. Dawn is currently moving at a speed of 0.08 kilometers per second relative to Ceres, which works out to 288 kilometers per hour. The distance of 83,000 kilometers on the 12th of February has now closed (as of 1325 UTC today, the 18th) to 50,330 kilometers. Its quite a change of pace from the days when we used to watch Voyager homing in on a planetary encounter. Voyager 2 reached about 34 kilometers per second as it approached Saturn, for example, then slowed dramatically as it climbed out of the giant planet's gravitational...

read more

A Black Hole of Information?

A couple of interesting posts to talk about in relation to yesterday's essay on the Encyclopedia Galactica. At UC-Santa Cruz, Greg Laughlin writes entertainingly about The Machine Epoch, an idea that suggested itself because of the spam his systemic site continually draws from "robots, harvesters, spamdexing scripts, and viral entities," all of which continually fill up his site's activity logs as they try to insert links. Anyone who attempts any kind of online publishing knows exactly what Laughlin is talking about, and while I hate to see his attention drawn even momentarily from his ongoing work, I always appreciate his insights on systemic, a blog whose range includes his exoplanet analyses as well as his speculations on the far future (as I mentioned yesterday, Laughlin and Fred Adams are the authors behind the 1999 title The Five Ages of the Universe, as mind-bending an exercise in extrapolating the future as anything I have ever read). I've learned on systemic that he can take...

read more

Information and Cosmic Evolution

Keeping information viable is something that has to be on the mind of a culture that continually changes its data formats. After all, preserving information is a fundamental part of what we do as a species -- it's what gives us our history. We've managed to preserve the accounts of battles and migrations and changes in culture through a wide range of media, from clay tablets to compact disks, but the last century has seen swift changes in everyday products like the things we use to encode music and video. How can we keep all this readable by future generations? The question is challenging enough when we consider the short term, needing to read, for example, data tapes for our Pioneer spacecraft when we've all but lost the equipment needed to manage the task. But think, as we like to do in these pages, of the long-term future. You'll recall Nick Nielsen's recent essay Who Will Read the Encyclopedia Galactica, which looks at a future so remote that we have left the 'stelliferous' era...

read more

A Full Day at Pluto/Charon

Have a look at the latest imagery from the New Horizons spacecraft to get an idea of how center of mass -- barycenter -- works in astronomy. When two objects orbit each other, the barycenter is the point where they are in balance. A planet orbiting a star may look as if it orbits without influencing the much larger object, but in actuality both bodies orbit around a point that is offset from the center of the larger body. A good thing, too, because this is one of the ways we can spot exoplanets, by the observed 'wobble' in the stars they orbit. The phenomenon is really evident in what the New Horizons team describes as the 'Pluto-Charon dance.' Here we have a case where the two objects are close enough in size -- unlike planet and star, or the Moon and the Earth -- so that the barycenter actually falls outside both of them. The time-lapse frames in the movie below show Pluto and Charon orbiting a barycenter above Pluto's surface, where Pluto and Charon's gravity effectively cancel...

read more

Charter

In Centauri Dreams, Paul Gilster looks at peer-reviewed research on deep space exploration, with an eye toward interstellar possibilities. For many years this site coordinated its efforts with the Tau Zero Foundation. It now serves as an independent forum for deep space news and ideas. In the logo above, the leftmost star is Alpha Centauri, a triple system closer than any other star, and a primary target for early interstellar probes. To its right is Beta Centauri (not a part of the Alpha Centauri system), with Beta, Gamma, Delta and Epsilon Crucis, stars in the Southern Cross, visible at the far right (image courtesy of Marco Lorenzi).

Now Reading

Recent Posts

On Comments

If you'd like to submit a comment for possible publication on Centauri Dreams, I will be glad to consider it. The primary criterion is that comments contribute meaningfully to the debate. Among other criteria for selection: Comments must be on topic, directly related to the post in question, must use appropriate language, and must not be abusive to others. Civility counts. In addition, a valid email address is required for a comment to be considered. Centauri Dreams is emphatically not a soapbox for political or religious views submitted by individuals or organizations. A long form of the policy can be viewed on the Administrative page. The short form is this: If your comment is not on topic and respectful to others, I'm probably not going to run it.

Follow with RSS or E-Mail

RSS
Follow by Email

Follow by E-Mail

Get new posts by email:

Advanced Propulsion Research

Beginning and End

Archives