I came across the work of Chin-Fei Lee (Academia Sinica Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Taiwan) when I had just read Avi Loeb's essay Cosmic Modesty. Loeb (Harvard University) is a well known astronomer, director of the Institute for Theory and Computation at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics and a key player in Breakthrough Starshot. His 'cosmic modesty' implies we should accept the idea that humans are not intrinsically special. Indeed, given that the only planet we know that hosts life has both intelligent and primitive lifeforms on it, we should search widely, and not just around stars like our Sun. More on that in a moment, because I want to intertwine Loeb's thoughts with recent work by Chin-Fei Lee, whose team has used the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) to detect organic molecules in an accretion disk around a young protostar. The star in question is Herbig-Haro (HH) 212, an infant system (about 40,000 years old) in Orion about 1300...
Magnetic Reconnection at the ‘Planet of Doubt’
Perhaps the image of Uranus just below helps explain why the planet has been treated so sparsely in science fiction. Even this Voyager view shows us a featureless orb, and certainly in visible light the world has little to make it stand out other than its unusual axis of rotation, which is tilted so that its polar regions are where you would expect its equator to be. Geoff Landis' "Into the Blue Abyss" (2001) is the best fictional treatment I know, but the fog-shrouded Uranus of Stanley G. Weinbaum's "The Planet of Doubt" (1935) has its own charms, though obviously lacking the scientific verisimilitude of the Landis tale. My admiration for Gerald Nordley's "Into the Miranda Rift" (1993) is unabated, taking us into this strange world's most dramatic moon, while I should also mention Kim Stanley Robinson's visit to Uranus in Blue Mars (1997), where the moon is established as a protected wilderness site while the rest of the Uranian satellite system is under colonization. Fritz Leiber's...
Planet 9? Planet 10? Planet X?
When you find a protoplanetary disk that displays unusual properties, the suspicion grows that an unseen planet is causing the phenomenon. The young Beta Pictoris is a classic case in point: Here we see disk asymmetry, with one side of the disk appearing longer and thinner than the other, and a warp that could be caused by the planet known as Beta Pictoris b. Or consider an extreme case, HD 142527. A T Tauri star in Lupus, HD 142527 displays an inner disk that is tilted by about 70 degrees (see HD 142527: Shadows of a Tilted Disk). Such a striking offset could be caused by an encounter with another star, though there no good candidates. Are we seeing the effects of proto-planets? All this comes to mind because of what Kat Volk (JPL) and Renu Malhotra (Lunar and Planetary Laboratory, University of Arizona) are seeing in our own Solar System. Their analysis of the more distant regions of the Kuiper Belt shows that objects there display an offset of about eight degrees from the...
New Horizons: Occultations in Preparation for MU69
Our spacecraft have never encountered an object as far from Earth as 2014 MU69, but New Horizons will change all that when it races past the Kuiper Belt object on New Year's Day of 2019. This summer is an interesting part of the project because planners will use it to gather as much information as possible about what they'll find at the target. We have three occultations to work with, one of them just past, and they are as tricky as it gets. But before I get to the occultations, let me offer condolences to the family and many New Horizons friends of Lisa Hardaway, who died in January at age 50. Hardaway helped to develop the LEISA (Linear Etalon Imaging Spectral Array) spectrometer that brought us such spectacular results during the Pluto/Charon flyby. She was program manager at Ball Aerospace for the Ralph instrument that contains LEISA. Mission scientists used data from the instrument package to make geological, color and composition maps of Pluto and its moons. The mission team...
Beam-Riding and Sail Stability
Breakthrough Starshot, the ambitious 30-year plan for launching small interstellar craft to a nearby star, depends critically on the sails that will ride a laser beam to 20 percent of lightspeed. In the essay below, James Benford takes a hard look at where we are now in the matter of sail stability, a subject he and brother Gregory have analyzed in their laboratory work. But as Jim points out, there is a great deal we still don't know, emphasizing the need for a dedicated test facility in which deep analysis and experimentation can proceed. The Chairman of the Sail Subcommittee for Breakthrough Starshot, Dr. Benford gives us insight into the magnitude of the challenge, and the possible solutions now being considered. By James Benford Riding on the beam, i.e., stable flight of a sail propelled by beam momentum, is an essential requirement of beam-driven propulsion. It places considerable demand upon the shape of the sail and beam. Some amount of beam jitter, oscillations in the...
DSTART: Imagining Interstellar Futures
Back in the 1970s, the British Interplanetary Society conceived the idea of designing a starship. The notion grew into Project Daedalus, often discussed in these pages, producing a final report that summed up what was then known about interstellar possibilities, from fusion propulsion to destination stars. Barnard's Star, 6 light years out, became the target because at the time, it was the only star for which evidence of planets existed, though that evidence later turned out to be the result of error in the instrument being used for the observations (more on this soon, in an essay I've written for the Red Dots campaign. I'll link to it as soon as it runs). The designing of Daedalus, much of it done in London pubs, was a highly significant event. What Alan Bond, Anthony Martin, Bob Parkinson and the rest were doing was not so much putting forth something that our civilization would build as sending us a clear message. Even at this stage of our development, humans could conceive of...
PLATO: Planet Hunting Mission Officially Adopted
The European Space Agency has just announced the official adoption of the PLATO mission. The untangled acronym -- PLAnetary Transits and Oscillations of stars -- tells us that, like Kepler and CoRoT, this is a planet hunting mission with asteroseismological implications. Photometric monitoring of nearby bright stars for planetary transits and determination of planetary radii should help build our target list for spectroscopic follow-up as we delve into planetary atmospheres looking for biosignatures. Launch is scheduled for 2026. Asteroseismology studies how stars oscillate, giving us information about the internal structure of the star that would not be available through properties like brightness and surface temperature. PLATO will be carrying out high precision photometric monitoring at visible wavelengths, targeting bright stars (mV ? 11), though with capabilities for fainter stars down to magnitude 16. Several hundred thousand stars will ultimately be characterized in the search...
A New Classification Scheme for Kepler Planets
As announced yesterday at NASA Ames, the Kepler team has released the final Kepler catalog from the spacecraft’s first four years of data and its deep stare into Cygnus. The numbers still impress me despite our having watched them grow with each new report: We have 4034 planet candidates, of which 2335 have been verified as exoplanets. More than 30 of the approximately 50 near-Earth sized habitable zone candidates have been verified. The new release brought us 219 new candidates, 10 of them habitable zone possibilities, giving us a final catalog that is our first take on the prevalence and characteristics of planets in the Milky Way, and paving the way for future space-based instruments as we look for targets for atmospheric characterization and direct imaging. By introducing simulated planet transit signals and adding known false signals, the researchers were able to tighten up the catalog, ensuring against errors in the analysis growing out of the team’s processing methods. The...
Pale Red Dot: Campaign 2
The Pale Red Dot campaign that discovered Proxima Centauri b produced one of the great results of exoplanet detection. For many of us, the idea that a world of roughly Earth mass might be orbiting in Proxima Centauri's habitable zone -- where liquid water can exist on the surface -- was almost too good to be true, and it highlighted the real prospect that if we find such a planet around the closest star to our own, there must be many more around similar stars. Hence the importance of learning more about our closest neighbors. Which is why it's so heartening to see that Pale Red Dot is by no means done. This morning, the team led by Guillem Anglada-Escudé (Queen Mary University, London) announced plans to acquire data from the European Southern Observatory's HARPS instrument (High Accuracy Radial velocity Planet Searcher) in a new campaign to study not just Proxima Centauri in search of further planets, but also the red dwarfs Barnard's Star and Ross 154. Also involved will be...
A Fusion Runway to Deep Space?
Beamed propulsion concepts are usually conceived in terms of laser or microwave beams pushing a lightsail. But as we've seen over the years, there are other ways of thinking about these things. Clifford Singer went to work back in the 1970s on the concept of pellet streams fired by an accelerator, each pellet a few grams in size. The idea here is to vaporize the pellets when they reach the spacecraft, their energy being redirected as a plasma exhaust. There are enough interesting variations on the idea that I'll probably return to it soon. But over the weekend, an email from Jeff Greason reminded me of Jordin Kare's unusual 'fusion runway' idea, to which he attached the moniker the 'Bussard Buzz Bomb.' Kare is an astrophysicist and space systems consultant with a background in laser technologies. He's been involved in studies of laser launch methods, in which beamed energy is focused on an onboard heat exchanger that converts liquid propellant into a gas to produce thrust. Currently...
Do All Stars Form as Binaries?
Interesting news this morning that begins with the Very Large Array in New Mexico, which a team of astronomers has been using to look at star formation. Their target: The Perseus molecular cloud, a stellar nursery about 600 light years from Earth. Clouds like this are sufficiently large (this one is about 50 light years in length) and dense to permit molecules to form, with molecular hydrogen (H2) being the most common, along with carbon monoxide (CO). Although we can't see into them in visible light (they appear as holes in the starry background because dust and gas obscure the stars forming inside, as well as background stars), such molecular clouds are ideally suited for study with radio telescopes. The VLA survey, called VANDAM (VLA Nascent Disk and Multiplicity) surveyed all the young stars in the Perseus cloud, including both single and multiple stars at separations down to < 20 AU. And now a duo of astronomers has supplemented the VLA data with observations from the James...
Focus on Interstellar Prebiotic Chemistry
400 light years away in a star-forming region called Rho Ophiuchi there is an interesting stellar system in the making. Catalogued as IRAS 16293-2422, what we have here is a triple protostar system -- a binary separated by 47 AU and a third star at 750 AU. All three have masses similar to the Sun, and while the system is young, it has already achieved a certain fame in that researchers working with data from the Atacama Large Millimeter Array have been able to identify a simple form of sugar called glycolaldehyde in surrounding gas. Learning that building blocks of life can form in other systems is useful, but here we have sugar in the region where a protoplanetary disk can form, an indication that such materials are widely available in the places where planets begin to coalesce around their host star. Then just this month we've learned that further ALMA work has yielded the prebiotic organic molecule methyl isocyanate (CH3NCO) in the same system. Niels Ligterink (Leiden Observatory)...
New Looks at Brown Dwarfs
Small stars are fascinating because of their sheer ubiquity. Some estimates for the fraction of red dwarfs in the galaxy go as high as 80 percent, meaning the planets around such stars are going to be the most common venues for possible life. For a time, I thought brown dwarfs would be shown to be even more numerous, but the WISE [Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer] data have indicated otherwise (see Brown Dwarfs Sparser than Expected). Hopes for a brown dwarf closer than the Alpha Centauri stars (and thus a convenient intermediary destination for future probes) have dwindled down to nothing, but we do have interesting systems like Luhman 16 AB, the third closest system to the Sun, captured in the image below via a 'stack' of twelve images courtesy of the Hubble instrument. The work is from Luigi Bedin (INAF-Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, Italy) and team, helping us with orbital parameters of the pair and demonstrating that there is no third companion. Image: Luhman 16 AB as...
Frank Malina: Texas Rocket Grandmaster
It's wonderful to have my friend Al Jackson back at the top of the site with a look at the career and times of JPL's Frank Malina. Al's service in the Apollo program came as astronaut trainer on the Lunar Module Simulator; he then spent 40 more years at Johnson Space Center, mostly for Lockheed working the Shuttle and ISS programs. His doctorate was in 1975 from the University of Texas at Austin. The author of numerous scientific papers on interstellar concepts, Al is a fixture at deep space conferences and a continuing source of inspiration on matters scientific as well as science fictional. Today Al gives us an overview of a man who played a key role in the sounding rocket era following World War II, as the infant Jet Propulsion Laboratory began its rich history of exploration and technical development. by Al Jackson I travel from Houston to Austin by Highway 290 fairly often, and sometimes I stop at Brenham, Texas for lunch. I skip the fast food joints on 290 and go downtown. It...
Planet Formation around TRAPPIST-1
Just how did the seven planets around TRAPPIST-1 form? This is a system with seven worlds each more or less the size of the Earth orbiting a small red dwarf. If these planets formed in situ, an unusually dense disk would have been required, making planet migration the more likely model. But if the planets migrated from beyond the snowline, how do we explain their predominantly rocky composition? And what mechanisms are at work in this system to produce seven planets all of approximately the same size? New work out of the University of Amsterdam attempts to resolve the question through a different take on planet formation, one that involves the migration not of planets but planetary building blocks in the form of millimeter to centimeter-sized particles. Chris Ormel (University of Amsterdam) and team note that thermal emission from pebbles like these has been observed around other low-mass stars and even brown dwarfs. The researchers believe these migrating particles become planetary...
Ultraviolet Insights into Red Dwarf Flares
I seem to be reminded every day of how many discoveries are lurking in our archives. On the question of red dwarf stars and the flare activity that could compromise the habitability of planets around them, the ten year dataset from GALEX is proving invaluable. The Galaxy Explorer Evolution spacecraft was launched in 2003 and operated until 2012. Bear in mind that it was designed to study the evolution of galaxies at ultraviolet wavelengths. But now this valuable mission's archives are helping us track the study of nearby habitable planets. Led by first author Chase Million (Million Concepts, State College PA), a project dubbed gPhoton has set about reprocessing more than 100 terabytes of GALEX data now at the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes (MAST), which is maintained at the Space Telescope Science Institute in Baltimore. Million worked with STScI's Clara Brasseur to develop custom software that could tease out the signature of flares for several hundred red dwarf stars. Dozens...
The Golden Apples of the Sun
Alex Tolley mentioned Ray Bradbury's story "The Golden Apples of the Sun" in connection with my first article on the Parker Solar Probe, and it's a short tale worth remembering in connection with a mission flying so remarkably close to our star. First published in 1953 in a Doubleday collection of the same name, the tale is a short, mythic take on dangerous questing, with its main character, the unnamed captain, a figure something like Melville's Captain Ahab. His goal is to fly to the Sun's surface and retrieve some of its fire: The captain stared from the huge dark-lensed port, and there indeed was the sun, and to go to that sun and touch it and steal part of it forever away was his quiet and single idea. In this ship were combined the coolly delicate and the coldly practical. Through corridors of ice and milk-frost, ammoniated winter and storming snowflakes blew. Any spark from that vast hearth burning out there beyond the callous hull of this ship, any small fire-breath that...
Into the Solar Wind
No spacecraft has ever flown as close to the Sun as the Parker Solar Probe will. The spacecraft will penetrate the outer solar atmosphere -- the corona -- where its measurements should help us understand the origin and characteristics of the solar wind. To put this in perspective, consider that Mercury is at 0.39 AU. The Helios-B spacecraft, launched in 1976, closed to within 43 million kilometers of the Sun (0.29 AU), the current record for a close pass. The Parker Solar Probe will fly seven times closer, moving within ten solar radii. We need to learn a lot more about this region as we consider various mission concepts for the future. The Parker Solar Probe uses an 11.43 cm carbon-composite shield designed to keep its instrument package at room temperature, or close to it, despite outside temperatures well over 1350° Celsius. The sundiver concept we talked about yesterday -- sometimes called a 'fry-by' -- has the advantage of maximizing the effect of solar photons by unfurling...
Parker Solar Probe: Implications for Sundiver
We're going to be keeping a close eye on what is now called the Parker Solar Probe as work continues toward a July 2018 launch. This is a mission with serious interstellar implications because it takes us into the realm of so-called 'sundiver' maneuvers in which a solar sail could be brought as close as possible to the Sun (perhaps behind a protective occulter) and then unfurled to get maximum effect. Velocities well beyond Voyager's can grow from this. Throw in the prospect of beamed propulsion and such sails could receive an additional boost. To be sure, the Parker Solar Probe is not a solar sail but an unmanned, instrumented probe designed to explore a region as close as 10 solar radii from the Sun's surface, where temperatures can be expected to reach about 1375° Celsius. But the sundiver implications are there, and we'll gain priceless data about operations in this extreme environment. Why a sundiver? Voyager 1 is exiting the neighborhood of the Solar System at 17.1...
SSEARS: Background of a NIAC Study
I always keep an eye on what's going on at the NASA Innovative Advanced Concepts office, which is where I ran into Jeff Nosanov's Phase I study for a solar sail called Solar System Escape Architecture for Revolutionary Science. At the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Jeff managed flight mission proposals and supported the radio isotope power program. He now lives in Washington DC, a technology entrepreneur whose fascination with spacecraft design has never diminished. In the essay below, Jeff explains the background of his first NIAC award (a second, PERIapsis Subsurface Cave Optical Explorer, would lead to Phase I and Phase II grants), and gives us an idea of the ins and outs of making ideas into reality at NIAC and JPL. For more, the website nosanov.com is about to go online, and Jeff's new podcast debuts today. By Jeff Nosanov It's an honor and a privilege to be asked to write about my near-interstellar mission work for the Tau Zero Foundation. Marc's book and Paul's writing were very...