Are Planets with Continuous Surface Habitability Rare?

Put a rocky, Earth-sized planet in the habitable zone of a Sun-like star, and good things should happen. At least, that seems to be the consensus, and since there are evidently billions of such planets in the galaxy, the chances for complex life seem overwhelmingly favorable. But in today's essay, Centauri Dreams associate editor Alex Tolley looks at a new paper that questions the notion, examining the numerous issues that can affect planetary outcomes. Just how long does a planetary surface remain habitable? Alex not only weighs the paper's arguments but runs the code that author Toby Tyrrell used as he examined temperature feedbacks in his work. Read on for what may be a gut-check for astrobiological optimists. by Alex Tolley

read more

Seafloor Volcanoes on Europa?

What’s going on on the floor of Europa’s ocean? It’s hard to imagine a place like this, crushed under the pressure of 100 kilometers or more of water, utterly dark, although I have to say that James Cambias does wonders with an ice moon ocean in his novel A Darkling Sea (Tor, 2014). Science fiction aside, Europa Clipper is in queue for a 2024 launch, and we can anticipate a flurry of new studies that feed into plans for the mission’s scientific investigations. The latest of these puts Clipper on volcano watch. The work deploys computer modeling to show that volcanic activity seems to have occurred recently on Europa’s seafloor. The concept is that there may be enough internal heat to cause melting -- at least in spots -- of the rocky interior, which would produce the needed results. How this heating affects the moon is deduced from the 3D modeling of heat production and transfer in the paper, which was recently published in Geophysical Research Letters. The lead author is Marie...

read more

Spiral Galaxies: A Common Path to Formation?

The galaxy UGC 10738 resonates with the galaxy described yesterday -- BRI 1335-0417 -- in that it raises questions about how spiral galaxies form. In fact, the team working on UGC 10738 thinks it goes a long way toward answering them. That's because what we see here is a cross-sectional view of a galaxy much like the Milky Way, one that has both 'thick' and 'thin' disks like ours. The implication is that these structures are not the result of collisions with smaller galaxies but typical formation patterns for all spirals. Nicholas Scott and Jesse van de Sande (ASTRO 3D/University of Sydney) led the study, which used data from the European Southern Observatory's Very Large Telescope in Chile. As you can see from the image below, the galaxy, some 320 million light years away, presents itself to us edge on, offering a cross-section of its structure. Key to the work was the team's assessment of stellar metallicity, as van de Sande explains: "Using an instrument called the multi-unit...

read more

The Most Ancient Spiral Galaxy Yet Found

My fascination with the earliest era of star and galaxy formation leads me to a new paper on an intriguing find. The authors describe the distant object BRI 1335-0417 as "an intensely star-forming galaxy," and its image as captured by the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) is striking. This is a galaxy that formed a mere 1.4 billion years after the Big Bang, making it the most ancient galaxy with spiral structure ever observed. Spirals make up perhaps 70 percent of the galaxies in our catalogs, but how they form is an open question. Indeed, the proportion of spiral galaxies declines the further back in the evolution of the universe we observe. The spiral structure observed here extends 15,000 light years from the center of the galaxy (about a third the size of the Milky Way), while the total mass of stars and interstellar matter roughly equals our own galaxy. Image: ALMA image of a galaxy BRI1335-0417 in the Universe 12.4 billion years ago. ALMA detected emissions...

read more

Lights of the Nightside City

On the matter of city lights as technosignatures, which we looked at on Friday, I want to follow up with Thomas Beatty's work on the issue in the context of an assortment of nearby stars. Beatty (University of Arizona, Tucson) assumes Earth-like planets examined via direct-imaging by LUVOIR, a future space telescope in planning, or HabEx, a different architecture for a likewise powerful instrument. What he's done is to take data from the Soumi National Polar-orbiting Partnership satellite to find the flux from city lights and the spectra of currently available lighting. He goes on to model the spectral energy distribution from such emissions as applied to exoplanet settings at various distances. Why look at city lights in the first place? Because they're another form of technosignature that may be within the realm of detection, and we'd like to find out what's possible and what any results would imply. In particular, Beatty reminds us, the National Academies' Exoplanet Science...

read more

Proxima Centauri b: Artificial Illumination as a Technosignature

Our recent look at the possibility of technosignatures at Alpha Centauri is now supplemented with a new study on the detectability of artificial lights on Proxima Centauri b. The planet is in the habitable zone, roughly similar in mass to the Earth, and of course, it orbits the nearest star, making it a world we can hope to learn a great deal more about as new instruments come online. The James Webb Space Telescope is certainly one of these, but the new work also points to LUVOIR (Large UV/Optical/IR Surveyor), a multi-wavelength space-based observatory with possible launch in 2035. Authors Elisa Tabor (Stanford University) and Avi Loeb (Harvard) point out that a (presumably) tidally locked planet with a permanent nightside would need artificial lighting to support a technological culture. As we saw in Brian Lacki’s presentation at Breakthrough Discuss (see Alpha Centauri and the Search for Technosignatures), coincident epochs for civilizations developing around neighboring stars are...

read more

Exploring Ice Giant Oceans

Laboratory work on Earth is, as we saw yesterday, leading to hypotheses about how planets form and the effect of these processes on subsequent life. Whether in our own outer Solar System or orbiting other stars, planets in the 'ice giant' category, like Uranus and Neptune, remain mysterious, with Voyager 2's flybys of the latter the only missions that have gone near them. We also know that sub-Neptune planets are common, many of these doubtless sharing the characteristics of their larger namesake. Thus recent experiments probing ice giant interiors catch my eye this morning. Involving an international team of collaborators, the work looks at the interactions between water and rock that we would expect to find in the extreme conditions inside an ice giant. Planets like Uranus and Neptune are thought to house most of their mass in a deep water layer, a dense fluid overlaying a rocky core, a sharp departure from terrestrial worlds. What happens at that interface is ripe for examination....

read more

Planet Formation Modes as a Key to Habitability

While a planet's position in the habitable zone is thought critical for the development of life like ourselves, new work out of Rice University suggests an equally significant factor in planetary growth. Working at a high-pressure laboratory at the university, Damanveer Grewal and Rajdeep Dasgupta have explored how planets capture and retain key volatiles like nitrogen, carbon and water as they form The team used nitrogen as a proxy for volatile distribution in a range of simulated protoplanets. Two processes are under study here, the first being the accretion of material in the circumstellar disk into a protoplanet, and the rate at which it proceeds. The second is differentiation, as the protoplanet separates into layers ranging from a metallic core to a silicate shell and, finally, an atmospheric envelope. The interplay between these processes is found to determine which volatiles the subsequent planet retains. Most of the nitrogen is found to escape into the atmosphere during...

read more

Alpha Centauri and the Search for Technosignatures

Is there any chance we may one day find technosignatures around the nearest stars? If we were to detect such, on a planet, say, orbiting Alpha Centauri B, that would seem to indicate that civilizations are to be found around a high percentage of G- and K-class stars. Brian Lacki (UC-Berkeley) examined the question from all angles at the recent Breakthrough Discuss, raising some interesting issues about the implications of technosignatures, and the assumptions we bring to the search for them. We’re starting to consider a wide range of technosignatures rather than just focusing on Dysonian shells around entire stars. Other kinds of megastructure are possible, some perhaps so exotic we wouldn’t be sure how they operated or what they were for. Atmospheres could throw technosignatures by revealing industrial activity along with their potential biosignatures. We could conceivably detect power beaming directed at interstellar spacecraft or even an infrastructure within a particular stellar...

read more

Voyager: A Persistent Clue to the Density of the Interstellar Medium

What are the long-lasting waves detected by Voyager 1? Our first working interstellar probe -- admittedly never designed for that task -- is operating beyond the heliosphere, which it exited back in 2012. A paper just published in Nature Astronomy explores what's going in interstellar space just beyond, but still affected by, the heliosphere's passage through the Local Interstellar Medium (LISM). We have a lot to learn out here, for even as we exit the heliosphere, the picture is complex. The so-called Local Bubble is a low-density region of hot plasma in the interstellar medium, the environment of radiation and matter -- gas and dust -- that exists between the stars. Within this 'bubble' exists the Local Interstellar Cloud (LIC), about 30 light years across, with a slightly higher hydrogen density flowing from the direction of Scorpius and Centaurus. The Sun seems to be within the LIC near its boundary with the G-cloud complex, where the Alpha Centauri stars reside. Image: Map of...

read more

Interstellar Research Group: 7th Interstellar Symposium Call for Papers

Regular Acceptance: Abstracts Due June 30, 2021 The Interstellar Research Group (IRG) hereby invites participation in its 7th Interstellar Symposium, hosted by the University of Arizona to be held from Friday, September 24 through Monday, September 27, 2021, in Tucson, Arizona. The Interstellar Symposium has the following elements: The Interstellar Symposium focuses on all aspects of interstellar travel (human and robotic), including power, communications, system reliability/maintainability, psychology, crew health, anthropology, legal regimes and treaties, ethics, and propulsion with an emphasis on possible destinations (including the status of exoplanet research), life support systems, and habitats. Working Tracks are collaborative, small group discussions around a set of interdisciplinary questions on an interstellar subject with the objective of producing "roadmaps" and/or publications to encourage further developments in the respective topics. This year we will be organizing the...

read more

A Bright Young World in the Ultraviolet

In the ranks of exoplanets we can actually see, we can include the gas giant PDS 70b, a young world orbiting the K-dwarf PDS 70. Bear in mind that of the more than 4,000 exoplanets thus far catalogued, only about 15 have been directly imaged, an indication of how tricky this work is and how far we have to go as we contemplate imaging Earth-size planets and taking spectroscopic measurements of their atmospheres. The most recent PDS 70b work was performed with the Hubble instrument, and is to my knowledge the first direct detection of an exoplanet in the ultraviolet. About 370 light years from Earth, PDS 70 (also known as V1032 Centauri) is a T Tauri star, a class of variables less than 10 million years old; this one appears to be no more than 5 million years old, and its largest planet is still in the process of building mass. The star is known to host at least two actively forming planets within its circumstellar disk of gas and dust, although only the larger is apparent in these UV...

read more

Exoplanet Geology: A Clue to Habitability?

Because we've just looked at how a carbon cycle like Earth's may play out to allow habitability on other worlds, today's paper seems a natural segue. It involves geology and planet formation, though here we're less concerned with plate tectonics and feedback mechanisms than the composition of a planet's mantle. At the University of British Columbia - Okanagan, Brendan Dyck argues that the presence of iron is more important than a planet's location in the habitable zone in predicting habitability. We learn that planetary mantles become increasingly iron-rich with proximity to the snow-line. In the Solar System, Mercury, Earth and Mars show silicate-mantle iron content that increases with distance from the Sun. Each planet had different proportions of iron entering its core during the planet formation period. The differences between them are the result of how much of their iron is contained in the mantle versus the core, for each should have the same proportion of iron as the star they...

read more

An Exoplanet Model for the Carbon Cycle

Earth's long-term carbon cycle is significant for life because it keeps carbon in transition, rather than allowing it to accumulate in its entirety in the atmosphere, or become completely absorbed in carbonate rocks. The feedback mechanism works over geological timescales to allow stable temperatures as CO2 cycles between Earth's mantle and the surface. As a result, we have carbon everywhere. 65,500 billion metric tons stored in rock complements the carbon found in the atmosphere and the oceans, as well as in surface features including vegetation and soil. It's a long-term cycle that can vary in the short term but be stabilizing over geological time-frames. The Sun has increased in luminosity substantially since Earth's formation, but the long-term carbon cycle is thought to be the key to maintaining temperatures on the surface suitable for life. Does it exist on other planets? It's an open question, as astronomer Mark Oosterloo (University of Groningen, The Netherlands) points out:...

read more

Charter

In Centauri Dreams, Paul Gilster looks at peer-reviewed research on deep space exploration, with an eye toward interstellar possibilities. For many years this site coordinated its efforts with the Tau Zero Foundation. It now serves as an independent forum for deep space news and ideas. In the logo above, the leftmost star is Alpha Centauri, a triple system closer than any other star, and a primary target for early interstellar probes. To its right is Beta Centauri (not a part of the Alpha Centauri system), with Beta, Gamma, Delta and Epsilon Crucis, stars in the Southern Cross, visible at the far right (image courtesy of Marco Lorenzi).

Now Reading

Recent Posts

On Comments

If you'd like to submit a comment for possible publication on Centauri Dreams, I will be glad to consider it. The primary criterion is that comments contribute meaningfully to the debate. Among other criteria for selection: Comments must be on topic, directly related to the post in question, must use appropriate language, and must not be abusive to others. Civility counts. In addition, a valid email address is required for a comment to be considered. Centauri Dreams is emphatically not a soapbox for political or religious views submitted by individuals or organizations. A long form of the policy can be viewed on the Administrative page. The short form is this: If your comment is not on topic and respectful to others, I'm probably not going to run it.

Follow with RSS or E-Mail

RSS
Follow by Email

Follow by E-Mail

Get new posts by email:

Advanced Propulsion Research

Beginning and End

Archives