What is 'space situational awareness,' and what does it have to do with SETI? The answer begins with the collision of a Russian Cosmos 2251 satellite with one of the 66 communications satellites that comprise the Iridium satellite constellation, a worldwide voice and data system. The collision, which occurred on February 10, 2009 produced hundreds of pieces of debris. The Air Force Space Command needs ways of tracking such debris, which poses a threat in the increasingly crowded skies above our planet. Enter the Allen Telescope Array, known primarily as a state-of-the-art center for the SETI effort to identify other intelligent species in the galaxy. The ATA caught the Air Force's eye as a way of tracking and cataloging man-made objects in orbit. Located in a volcanic valley near the Lassen National Forest in California, the array has proven its worth at this task in early tests, a fact that could inspire a new funding source for the observatory. And as we learned to our dismay...
SETI: The Michaud/Cooper Dialogue
Space writer Keith Cooper, the editor of the UK's Astronomy Now, is currently attending the Royal Astronomical Society's meeting in Llandudno, Wales -- in fact, the photo of him just below was taken the other day in Llandudno. But the frantic round of presentations hasn't slowed Keith down. When last spotted in these pages, he was engaged in a dialogue with me about SETI issues. That exchange got me thinking about having Keith talk to Michael Michaud, considering their common interests and realizing that they had already met at last year's Royal Society meeting where so many of these issues were discussed. Michael was kind enough to agree, and what follows is an exchange of views that enriches the SETI debate. Centauri Dreams readers know Michael Michaud to be the author of the essential Contact with Alien Civilizations: Our Hopes and Fears about Encountering Extraterrestrials (Springer, 2006), but he's also the author of over one hundred published works, many of them on space...
Beyond the Red Edge
If you study 'earthshine,' the light of our planet reflected off the unlit part of the Moon, you can discover much about how life leaves an imprint upon a spectrum. It's a useful exercise because one of these days we'll have the tools in place to be examining the spectrum of a terrestrial world around another star. In Earth's case, what two different teams have found is that water vapor, oxygen and ozone can be traced, just the kind of biosignatures we'd hope to find on a terrestrial world elsewhere. Careful study of the spectrum of earthshine also turns up a tentative detection of the so-called 'red edge' signature of chlorophyll. What's happening is that plants on our planet absorb visible light as part of the process of converting sunlight into energy. Beyond about 0.7 microns, just a bit longer in wavelength than the frequencies we can see, the same plants become highly reflective. This increase in reflectivity shows up as a sharp rise in the red part of the spectrum, hence the...
Asteroid Mining: A Marker for SETI?
Having just finished Iain Banks' The Player of Games, I'm thinking about the 'orbitals' he describes in his series of novels about the Culture, a vast, star-crossing civilization that can build space habitats in the form of massive rings. Orbitals are smaller than the kind of 'ringworld' Larry Niven envisioned, but huge nonetheless, bracelets of super-strong materials housing billions who live on their inner surfaces as they orbit a parent star. The visual effects Banks pulls off in describing these habitats are spectacular. And now a new paper by Duncan Forgan (University of Edinburgh) and Martin Elvis (Harvard Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics) has me wondering about the kind of mining activities it would take to produce the raw materials for such constructs. Forgan and Elvis are interested in what they describe as a multi-wavelength, multi-signal approach to SETI. We're used to the idea of huge radio dishes listening for extraterrestrial signals, but SETI is evolving through the...
Extraterrestrial Life: The Need for an Answer
An article in Time Magazine's latest issue caught my eye as I thumbed through it while waiting in line at the grocery store. The magazine is running a feature called '10 Ideas That Will Change the World,' and they tend toward being optimistic takes on huge problems. Thus the deficit gets an essay about how we're going to fix it, while Afghanistan gets a thumbs-up for progress in the right direction. The article finds gold in everything from direct mailings (OK because they help charities raise money) to modern airports, which are creating a new kind of community. And in the midst of this is a puzzling piece by Jeffrey Kluger called 'Relax: You Don't Need to Worry About Meeting E.T.', where the upshot is: 'Don't worry about contact with extraterrestrial civilizations. It will never happen.' Here's a quote: Humans and aliens haven't connected yet, but with 1022 stars out there (that's 1 with 22 zeros), it's just a matter of time — right? Wrong. If exobiologists have learned...
On Meteorites and Budgets
Two kinds of astrobiology stories are in the wind this morning. One of them has to do with the weekend eruption of stories concerning evidence of fossilized life inside a meteorite. The other deals with scientific investigation off-planet, and although sparsely covered, it's the one with the greater significance for finding life elsewhere. But first, let's get Richard Hoover's paper about meteorite life out of the way, for the growing consensus this morning is that there are serious problems with his analysis, especially as regards contamination of the sample here on Earth. I have no problems with the panspermia idea -- the notion that life just may be ubiquitous, and that planetary systems may be seeded with life not just from other planets within the system but from other stellar systems entirely. It's an appealing and elegant concept, but thus far we have no proof, and despite what Dr. Hoover is seeing in samples from three meteorites, we still can't definitively say that we've...
A Dialogue on SETI
Last October, a conference at the Royal Society looked into "the detection of life, the communication with potential extra-terrestrial civilizations, the implications for the future of humanity, and the political processes that are required." It was a fascinating gathering, one whose results I've been able to study ever since thanks to Keith Cooper, who forwarded videos of a debate there on interstellar messaging (METI) and passed along transcripts of the various panels. Keith is editor of the superb Astronomy Now and is an accomplished writer on space exploration and astronomy, with over 100 articles published. I especially want to mention SETI: Cosmic Call and SETI: Terminating the Transmission in relation to what follows below. For as Keith and I discussed these issues, it occurred to me that our correspondence in the form of a dialogue was a natural for Centauri Dreams. So here's a slightly edited version of some recent thoughts of ours on SETI, the strength of extraterrestrial...
A Living Planet Between the Stars?
A planet that wanders through the night far from any star is a fascinating notion, one that resonates on some primal level with me because of my childhood viewing of the 1951 film The Man from Planet X. In the movie, a scientist on a remote Scottish moor observes a rogue planet as it approaches the Earth, and deals with a visitor from that world whose apparent good intentions are brought to ruin by a self-serving character intent on exploiting the situation. I doubt similar viewing of this old classic motivated many of my readers, but evidently the idea of a rogue planet does inspire thought, given how many people wrote me about new work on the idea of wandering planets. The paper is by Dorian Schuyler Abbot and Eric Switzer (University of Chicago) and follows up studies of similar ‘dark’ planets by John Debes (Carnegie Institution) and Steinn Sigurðsson (Penn State) -- more about the latter duo in a moment. For now, focus on the process. We know that planets can be thrown out of...
The ‘I Love Lucy’ Signal
As a fan of I Love Lucy since childhood, I've always been pleased that this show -- and not, say, Milton Berle or Sid Caesar -- is the one always referred to when talking about Earth being detected by other civilizations. And when I first thought about it, the idea that there was a detectable bubble of TV transmission forging out into the galaxy since Lucy's first show in 1951 seemed completely wondrous. I Love Lucy is 60 light years from us now, or will be with this October's anniversary of that first show. I've always wondered what extraterrestrials would make of Fred Mertz. The film Contact mines the theme of stray transmissions from Earth, although in the case of Sagan's story, it's the transmissions from the 1936 Olympics in Berlin that trigger the detection and subsequent transmissions to Earth. A writer and music critic who I've known over the years once asked me about the expanding wavefront of Earthly transmissions, pondering how marvelous it would be to somehow get out in...
A Renewed Concern: Flares and Astrobiology
Before the recent American Astronomical Society meeting in Seattle gets too far behind us, I want to be sure to include an interesting story on red dwarfs in the coverage here. The story involves an extrasolar planet survey called SWEEPS -- Sagittarius Window Eclipsing Extrasolar Planet Search, which used the Hubble Space Telescope to monitor 215,000 stars in the so-called Sagittarius Window (also called Baade's Window, after Walter Baade, who discovered it with the 18" Schmidt camera on Mt. Palomar). The 'window' offers a view of the Milky Way's central bulge stars, which are otherwise blocked by dark clouds of galactic dust. M-dwarfs are by far the most common type of star in the Milky Way, and therefore have major implications for the search for extraterrestrial life. We now know from SWEEPS data that these small stars are given to stellar flares that can have major effects on a planetary atmosphere. Flares have often been mentioned as a serious problem for the development of life...
Arsenic and Odd Life
As if it were news, one thing the great flap over astrobiology and yesterday afternoon's NASA news conference tells us is that anything smacking of extraterrestrial life brings over the top commentary long before the findings are officially discussed, as should be clear from some of the Internet blogging about the GFAJ-1 bacterium found in Mono Lake. And what a shame. Despite the astrobiology teaser, GFAJ-1 does not in itself tell us anything about alien life and does not necessarily represent a 'shadow biosphere,' a second startup of life on Earth that indicates life launches in any available niche. But the find is remarkable in its own right. Let's leave the astrobiology aside for the moment and simply focus on the fact that life is fantastically adaptable in terms of biochemistry, and can pull off surprises at every turn. That's always a result worth trumpeting, even if it leaves the wilder press speculations in the dust. After all, it's long been assumed that the six elements...
Red Dwarfs: A Rich Harvest
I never have trouble finding topics to discuss on Centauri Dreams, but this morning's take was unusually bountiful. For the past several days I've had two embargoed stories to choose from, both going public this PM. Do I write about tripling the number of stars in the universe, or do I choose the first analysis of a 'super-Earth' atmosphere? It's a tough choice, but I'm going with the stars, given that the story relates to what I consider the most fascinating venue for astrobiology, planets around red dwarfs. We'll do the super-Earth atmosphere -- fascinating in its own right -- tomorrow. The story comes out of Yale University, whose Pieter van Dokkum led the research using telescopes at the Keck Observatory in Hawaii. We've long known that because of their faintness and small size, getting a handle on the red dwarf population was problematic. Usually, I've seen a figure around 75 percent cited for the Milky Way, meaning most stars in our galaxy are red dwarfs (the Sun, a G-class...
Astrobiology on the Cheap
Keeping space missions separate can be a difficult challenge when so many satellites are launched on a single rocket. Take O/OREOS (Organism/Organic Exposure to Orbital Stresses). The small satellite rode into space on an Air Force Minotaur IV rocket on the 19th, a launch we noted here in connection with the NanoSail-D solar sail demonstrator. For NanoSail-D was itself carried into space as part of the FASTSAT payload bus (Fast, Affordable Science and Technology Satellite), and FASTSAT and O/OREOS were subsumed under a mission called Space Test Program S26. Not to mention a number of other satellites from universities and industry that hitched a ride on the same booster. All of this produces not just confusion but acronym fatigue. Nonetheless, interesting science is in the works. O/OREOS is all about conducting astrobiology science experiments on the cheap using nanosatellites (CubeSats), helping scientists plan future experiments on how organic molecules are changed by exposure to...
The Poetry of SETI
Stephen Baxter's "Turing's Apples," which originally ran in a collection called Eclipse Two (2008), is an intriguing take on SETI and the problem of extracting meaningful information from a signal. It's a bit reminiscent of Fred Hoyle's A for Andromeda (1962) in that the SETI signal received on Earth contains instructions for building something that may or may not pose a threat to our species. Sorting out the issue involves discussion of information theory and Shannon entropy analysis. Say again? Best to handle this by quoting from the story. In this scene, the protagonist's brother, who is obsessed with the signal his team has received from the direction of the Eagle Nebula and, ultimately, the galactic center, is explaining how information is being extracted from it. Shannon entropy analysis looks for relationships between signal elements. The brother goes on: "You work out conditional probabilities: Given pairs of elements, how likely is it that you'll see U following Q? Then you...
Exoplanet Atmospheres: What We Don’t Know
What happens in the atmosphere of a tidally locked world in the habitable zone of a red dwarf? We have solid work suggesting through simulations that habitable conditions could exist there, but it's also true that we're in the early stages of these investigations and we have no actual examples to work with. Drawing hasty conclusions is always dangerous, particularly when we're talking about the details of atmospheric circulation on a planet no one has ever seen. Take Gliese 581g. Assuming it exists -- and there is still a bit of doubt about this, although the consensus seems to be that it's really there -- we can place it in a temperature zone that would allow life. We don't know for a fact, though, that it isn't a water world, covered entirely with deep ocean, a planet that migrated from beyond the snowline into its present position. And even if it is a rocky planet with a substantial atmosphere, our simulations of atmospheric circulation only represent the best that is known today....
SETI: The Red Giant Factor
The ‘slow boat’ to Centauri concept we’ve discussed before in these pages envisions generation ships, vessels that take thousands of years to cross to their destination. And based on current thinking, that’s about the best we could manage with the propulsion systems currently in our inventory. Specifically, a solar sail making a close solar pass (a ‘sundiver’ maneuver) could get us up to 500 or 600 kilometers per second (0.002c), making a 2000-year journey to the nearest star possible. It’s hard to imagine under what circumstances such a mission might be launched. But let’s think long-term, as Greg Matloff (New York City College of Technology) did in a session that just concluded at the International Astronautical Congress in Prague. Matloff, a solar sail expert and well known figure in the interstellar community, notes that when the Sun leaves the main sequence and becomes a red giant, its luminosity may have increased by a factor of a thousand. Imagine using that kind of star as...
Interstellar Archaeology on the Galactic Scale
The European Planetary Science Congress ends today in Rome even as scientists and engineers on the astronautical side of things head for Prague, where the International Astronautical Congress convenes on Monday. I'll be keeping an eye on events in Prague and wishing I could join the gathering of Tau Zero practitioners that will be taking place there -- Marc Millis will be presenting four papers, and many of the Project Icarus team members are also making the journey, so we should be getting regular updates on matters interstellar. Nor do I want to neglect the Royal Society meeting on extraterrestrial life, coming up early in October in Buckinghamshire in the UK. Emails from James Benford (Microwave Sciences) and Richard Carrigan (Fermilab) tell me both will be speaking at the session, which reminds me that it was way back in April that I promised more on Carrigan's notions of interstellar 'archaeology,' a form of SETI that makes no assumptions about the originating civilization. It's...
SETI on the Ecliptic
Is anyone out there in the galaxy aware of our presence? If so, it's most likely through detection of our planetary radars, like those at Arecibo and Evpatoria that are used to detect and study nearby objects like asteroids, and provide a valuable part of our planetary defense. Sure, we've been pumping television and radio signals into the deep for a long time now, but Arecibo is the most powerful radar in the world, its 430 MHz transmitter offering a maximum total peak pulse output power of 2.5 MW. The planetary radars at Arecibo, Goldstone and Evpatoria are sending far more powerful signals than the faint traces of our early TV broadcasts. It's one of the hopes of SETI that we might detect a similar transmission from another civilization, but in saying that we run into all kinds of assumptions. How long a time-frame does a civilization have before it develops technologies far superior to planetary radars for studying nearby objects? For that matter, how long would any sort of...
Detecting (and Understanding) Life Signals
A symposium celebrating the first fifty years of NASA' exobiology program takes place on October 14 in Arlington, Virginia. 'Seeking Signs of Life' looks all the way back to 1959, when NASA funded its first exobiology investigation, an experiment for a future spacecraft to detect life on Mars. The actual exobiology program was established in 1960, and led to the three Viking experiments that eventually flew. Exobiology has these days morphed into 'astrobiology,' as we look at topics as diverse as chemical evolution in interstellar space and planetary formation. For those in range of Arlington, more information is available here. Be aware as well of a workshop on SETI that is now taking place at the National Radio Astronomy Observatory in Green Bank, WV, marking the 50th anniversary of Frank Drake's first search for extraterrestrial signals. Webcasts begin at 0830 EDT (1230 UTC), and will include Drake's views on 'SETI in 2061 and Beyond' at that time on September 15. Further...
Poul Anderson’s Answer to Fermi
Enrico Fermi's paradox has occupied us more than occasionally in these pages, and for good reason. 'Where are they,' asked Fermi, acknowledging an obvious fact: Even if it takes one or two million years for a civilization to develop and use interstellar travel, that is but a blip in terms of the 13.7 billion year age of the universe. Von Neumann probes designed to study other stellar systems and reproduce, moving outward in an ever expanding wave of exploration, could easily have spread across the galaxy long before our ancestors thought of building the pyramids. Where are they indeed. Kelvin Long, one of Project Icarus' most energetic proponents, recently sent me Poul Anderson's thoughts on the subject. I probably don't need to tell this audience that Anderson was a science fiction author extraordinaire. His books and short stories occupied vast stretches of my youth, and I still maintain that if you want to get not so much the tech and science but the sheer wonder of the...