The case for life around other stars, always a strong one, has become even more persuasive of late. First we found planet formation around HD 12039, a Sun-like star about 137 light years away, revealing a system that may look like our Solar System in its infancy. Now comes news based on findings from the Spitzer Space Telescope that astronomers have observed acetylene and hydrogen cyanide in the inner regions of the debris disk around the star IRS 46. Both gases are organic compounds considered to be precursors to DNA and RNA. IRS 46 is located in the constellation Ophiuchus about 375 light years from Earth. Like HD 12039, it is a young star, surrounded by a disk of gas and dust that should, if our theories hold, house the raw materials of planets. Astronomers at the W.M. Keck Observatory (Mauna Kea), Leiden Observatory and the Netherlands Institute for Space Research used Spitzer's infrared spectrometer to study 100 stars, but IRS 46 was the only one to reveal signs of an organic...
Earth Habitable Shortly After Formation
Readers who know of Centauri Dreams' fascination with 'deep time' will not be surprised that I am working on a side project involving past, not future time. Specifically, a study of the Eocene, that remarkable period beginning some 55 million years ago during which the ancestors of most modern mammals -- including the higher primates, such as apes, monkeys and man - appeared. And if the Eocene, 2/3 of the way back to the age of the dinosaurs, seems like a long reach from interstellar travel, ponder this: the more we learn about how life adapts to changing planetary environments, the better we'll be able to carry out the hunt for life around other stars. On that score, it's interesting to see that a team supported in part by NASA's Exobiology program has determined that Earth's continents were in place soon after the planet formed. The Earth was not, in other words, a purely ocean world in that era, or a barren, inhospitable place like the Moon. Analyzing the occurrence of a rare...
The Aesthetics of Extraterrestrial Contact
Jon Lomberg has a distinction of which few humans can boast -- he knows his art will last. As the designer of the cover of the Voyager Interstellar Record, Lomberg created an aesthetic statement that could, in fact, last for a thousand million years. As could the entire sequence of 120 photographs and diagrams that he designed for the Voyager record. And just to show that his interest in deep time isn't purely space-related, Lomberg also designed a 10,000 year nuclear waste marker for the US Department of Energy. Centauri Dreams appreciates all instances of genuinely long-term thinking, but particularly celebrates the marriage of art with technology in time-frames longer than our civilization. It seems fitting, then, that when Lomberg turns to SETI issues, he would bring an artist's eye to the proceedings, which is what he does in an article written with Guillermo Lemarchand (Centro de Estudios Avanzados, Universidad de Buenos Aires). The essay, called "SETI and Aesthetics" and...
Extraterrestrial Life Examined on TV
Two shows catch the eye tonight [Saturday] on the National Geographic Channel: Naked Science: "Alien Contact" at 9P et/pt Are we the only intelligent species alive in the universe? Join the quest to separate scientific fact from science fiction in the search for extraterrestrials. "Extraterrestrial" at 10P et/pt A dazzling galactic journey brings you face-to-face with fantastic alien life-forms that scientists believe could exist in our own galaxy. I haven't seen the former, but "Extraterrestrial" is quite good, with sound extrapolations about life forms that could develop in such interesting environments as a planet circling an M-class red dwarf, and interviews with scientists involved in the exoplanetary hunt. For more information (and alternate program times) look here. Thanks to Larry Klaes for the tip on the re-broadcast of these shows.
Target Stars for Terrestrial Planet Hunting
If you're looking for life similar to Earth's -- based, that is, on carbon chemistry and water -- you have to determine what kind of stars might have produced such planets. Certain factors weigh heavily in this analysis. The star must be a long-lived, solar-type star with constraints on its luminosity; it must offer an environment within which a planet with liquid water at its surface can exist. This Continuously Habitable Zone (CHZ) is defined this way in a new paper called "Astrobiologically Interesting Stars within 10 parsecs of the Sun," now available on the arXiv site: The inner edge of habitability is the region where water is lost through photolysis and hydrogen escape; the oceans simply evaporate; The outer edge of habitability is the region where C02 clouds form, cooling the planet by lowering its albedo. Also critical is planetary mass. A reasonable upper limit on mass seems to be a few Earth masses; planets larger than this are likely to be entirely covered with oceans,...
‘Alien’ Life on Earth?
"We may never find other life away from Earth, but we have already made aliens on this planet and we will continue to do so at an increasing pace," says Peter Ward, author of Life As We Do Not Know It: The NASA Search for (and Synthesis of) Alien Life (Viking, 2005). "In the last five years we've come to realize that we can make microbial life in a lot more ways than Mother Earth did." Aliens on this planet? Ward is talking about laboratory work here on Earth that has modified life as we commonly understand it. That includes creating microbes with at least one amino acid beyond the 20 found in the DNA of native Earth life. Genetic modification also constitutes, in Ward's view, the creation of an alien lifeform, as does modifying a lifeform to reduce its complexity. Ward, a paleontologist who studies these matters within the University of Washington's astrobiology program, is perhaps best known to Centauri Dreams readers as the co-author (with Donald Brownlee) of Rare Earth: Why...
A Mission to the Gravity Focus
Voyager 1 is, in a sense, our first interstellar spacecraft, with evidence mounting that it has reached the heliopause, that area marking the boundary between the Sun's outward-flowing particles and the true interstellar medium. The New Horizons mission, scheduled for launch in January, will go on to explore at least part of the Kuiper Belt. But what will our first true interstellar mission be; i.e., when will we launch a spacecraft designed from top down to studying nearby interstellar space? The answer may well be a mission to the Sun's gravity focus. Located at 550 AU (3.17 light days), some 14 times farther from the Sun than Pluto, the focus is that point to which the Sun's gravity bends the light from objects on the other side of it. The effect is to magnify distant images in ways that could be observed using the proper equipment. The effect of gravitational focus, first studied by Einstein in 1936, had already borne observational fruit by 1978 in the discovery of a 'twin...
SETI and Drake: Part II
Yesterday we looked at Milan ?irkovi?'s paper “The Temporal Aspect of the Drake Equation and SETI" (Astrobiology Vol. 4 No. 2, pp. 225-231), and pondered whether there might not be a 'communications window' -- an interval for any society between when it reaches the technological capacity for interstellar communication and the point when it becomes a 'supercivilization' unlikely to use conventional SETI methods to contact us or anyone else. If so, that 'window' would have a profound effect on how many civilizations we might be able to contact via SETI, and would thus change our answers to the Drake Equation. But there are other kinds of assumptions built into the equation that may be problematic. ?irkovi? notes that the equation assumes a more or less uniform physical and chemical history of our galaxy, but uniformitarianism doesn't work well in astrophysics or cosmology (think of the Steady State theory -- uniformitarian -- vs. the Big Bang, which introduced the concept of epochs...
A Hard Look at SETI and the Drake Equation
The famous Drake Equation was developed as a way to estimate how many technological civilizations might exist and thereby be targets for SETI research. Conceived in 1961 as astronomer Frank Drake worked at the National Radio Astronomy Observatory (Green Bank, WV), the equation exists in a variety of forms depending on which authors you consult (see, for example, this SETI Institute discussion of the equation). But all variants draw on the same idea: to study extraterrestrial civilizations, you must consider such factors as: the mean rate of star formation in the Galaxy; the fraction of stars that can support life; the fraction of stars that have planetary systems; the number of planets per system with conditions suitable for life; the number of planets where life does originate and evolve; the fraction of planets where intelligent life forms develop; the fraction of planets where intelligent life develops technology; and a final, crucial measure: the mean lifetime of a technological...
Life’s Origins in the Cosmos
To make life happen you need organic molecules that contain nitrogen. Now new work at NASA's Ames Research Center, to be reported in the October 10 issue of the Astrophysical Journal, reveals that organic molecules found throughout the galaxy do, in fact, contain nitrogen. "Our work shows a class of compounds that is critical to biochemistry is prevalent throughout the universe," said Douglas Hudgins, an astronomer at NASA Ames and principal author of the study. The studies combined laboratory experiments and computer simulations. We already knew, thanks to the Spitzer Space Telescope, that complex organic molecules called polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are all but ubiquitous. Learning that PAHs contain nitrogen implies that the building blocks of life are seeded everywhere in the universe. From a NASA Ames news release, quoting astrochemist and team member Louis Allamandola: "Chlorophyll, the substance that enables photosynthesis in plants, is a good example of this class...
Refining the Tools for Life Detection
If you're looking for a terrestrial analogue to one part of the Martian environment, you could do worse than the ice vents inside a frozen volcano on the Norwegian island of Svalbard. There, in a one million year old volcano called Sverrefjell, a team of researchers has found a community of microbes both living and fossilized. Ice-filled volcanic vents are believed to occur on Mars and may well be a potential habitat for life on the planet. Behind the Svalbard investigations is AMASE, the Arctic Mars Analog Svalbard Expedition, which is designing devices and techniques that may one day be used by automated landers to search for life on Mars. And thus far the findings are promising. The team has been able to perform its tests while maintaining scrupulous sterility, a key factor in ensuring that 'life' detections on another planet aren't simply the result of Earthly microorganisms being introduced into the local ecology. Examining 780-million year old sedinmentary rocks, the team also...
1991 VG: Natural or Artificial?
The search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) has seen a great deal of publicity, from television programs interviewing involved scientists to blockbuster movies like Contact. But the idea that there might be signs of extraterrestrial life closer to home has received relatively short shrift. Nonetheless, SETA (the search for extraterrestrial artifacts) has spawned interesting work, from Gregory Matloff's examinations of anomalous Kuiper Belt objects to Robert Freitas' surveys of 'halo orbits' around the Lagrangian points. So far both kinds of search -- SETI and SETA -- have come up short, but a few curious things have been observed on each side. One interesting SETA investigation involved an object called 1991 VG, which made a close approach to Earth in 1991 (thanks to Adam Crowl for bringing this one to my attention). Discovered by Jim Scotti using the University of Arizona's Spacewatch telescope (normally used to detect small asteroids near the Earth), 1991 VG seemed to be...
Possible Life Strategies on Titan
Centauri Dreams recently looked at Titan as a possible abode for life, energized by a paper given at the Division of Planetary Sciences meeting by David Grinspoon. A researcher at the Southwest Research Institute (Boulder, CO), Grinspoon is also an author whose book Lonely Planets: The Natural Philosophy of Alien Life (New York: Harper, 2004) discusses in depth and style the issue of extraterrestrial life and where we might find it. His Web site offers numerous links to his scientific output and materials from his book. Grinspoon has been all over the news lately, as witness this interview in the online journal Astrobiology Magazine. Recently, he was kind enough to forward a copy of his DPS paper "Biologically Enhanced Energy and Carbon Cycling on Titan?" Centauri Dreams reads a lot of research papers, but Grinspoon's work stands out not only for its rigor but its sheer energy. He speculates, for example, that our model of miniaturized cellular life in water on Earth may be...
From Titan to the Encyclopedia Galactica
Space artist Jon Lomberg, whose work illustrated yesterday's entry on the white dwarf star GD 362, wrote recently with a comment on Centauri Dreams' September 8 story on Titan. The story discussed new theories on Titan as an abode for life, citing a presentation at the recent Division of Planetary Sciences meeting in Cambridge and quoting Southwest Research Institute scientist David Grinspoon on the possibilities inherent in Titan's abundant hydrocarbons and acetylene, which might help power a metabolism. Titan, of course, is a very cold place, which would seem to inhibit the needed chemistry. But Lomberg points out a way around the problem: "Consider the organic superconductor dimethyltetra-thiofulvalene tetracyano-quinodimethane. Discovered in the 1970s, this was the first organic superconductor found, and it remains superconductive at [relatively] high temperatures. More have been discovered since. When Carl Sagan and I were working on my Encyclopedia Galactica series of...
Of Interstellar Arks and Nearby Stars
How long would it take to get to Alpha Centauri using a solar sail? The fastest travel time I've seen calculated is 1000 years. Imagine a reflective sheet only nanometers in thickness attached to the payload with diamond strength cable. A close pass by the Sun (the classic 'Sun-diver' maneuver, first called this, as far as I know, by Gregory Benford) is followed by sail deployment as close to the Sun as possible. Assume a sail of perhaps 100 kilometers in diameter, a payload of several million kilograms, and accelerations of a few g. After acceleration, the sail would be wound around the habitat for cosmic ray detection, and later re-deployment for deceleration. Gregory Matloff presents these ideas in an essay with the fetching title "The Reenchantment of the Solar System: A Proposed Search for Local ET's," available online (thanks to Larry Klaes for the tip on this). As you can see from the title, the sail mission to Centauri is only the beginning of the possible wonders discussed...
Life’s Possibilities on Titan Weighed
Can there be livable habitats on Titan? A paper just presented at the Division for Planetary Sciences meeting in Cambridge makes the case that several key ingredients of life may be present on the huge moon. Titan possesses liquid reservoirs, organic molecules and the needed energy sources. The question: is the environment simply too cold? With temperatures down to -178 degrees Celsius (-289 degrees Fahrenheit), the chemical reactions to produce life would move ponderously, but perhaps not too slowly to function. The first images from beneath Titan's cloud cover made the speculation all the more intense. Methane shows up in clouds as well as in liquid form at the surface at these temperatures, and may provide the analog for Earth's water in a life-sustaining hydrological cycle. Moreover, there are hints of ice volcanoes that imply the existence of large amounts of water (mixing with ammonia) not far below the surface. So where does it all lead? From a Southwest Research Institute...
A Closer Look at Tempel 1
Comet Tempel 1, the target of NASA's Deep Impact probe back in July, has offered scientists a stunning view of cometary topography. The first published results from the mission team will appear in the September 9 issue of Science and have been released at the Division of Planetary Sciences meeting at Cambridge. Among other things, Tempel 1 is the first comet to demonstrate impact craters, an indication of collisions with various space debris over the aeons. The craters range from 40 to 400 meters across, but are they common to all comets? Those we've had good views of, including Borelly and Wild 2, show significant differences in topography and shape. Of Tempel 1, we can only say that its lifetime has been complex. "This comet is a geologic wonder," said Peter Schultz, a professor of geological sciences at Brown University and a co-investigator on the mission team. "There are smooth surfaces, filled-in craters, ridges, cliffs. Tempel 1 also features an area marked by innumerable...
Enceladus and the Hunt for Life
Saturn's moon Enceladus is back in the news at the Division of Planetary Sciences meeting at Cambridge University this week. Not that it has ever quite left the spotlight since 1981; that's when Voyager 2 photographs told scientists that parts of the moon had been geologically active as recently as 100 million years ago. The moon's smooth terrain was hard to explain -- how does an object 314 miles across get hot enough to melt? Then Cassini came and Enceladus' wonders increased. We now know that the moon has an atmosphere of water vapor, nitrogen, carbon dioxide and other organic (i.e., carbon-based) molecules concentrated at its south pole. Moreover, that polar region is hotter than expected, -183 degrees Celsius vs. -203 Celsius as predicted by the models, and is marked by 80-mile long parallel cracks that vent vapor and ice particles. Some of this material may have crystallized on the surface as recently as the past decade. At the Cambridge meeting, Robert H. Brown (University of...
An Infrared Hunt for Artificial Kuiper Belt Objects
If extraterrestrials were to set up a colony in our Solar System, where would they choose to settle? Gregory Matloff and Anthony R. Martin make the case for the Kuiper Belt in a recent paper for the Journal of the British Interplanetary Society. Kuiper Belt Objects (KBOs) are, after all, easy to exploit as a resource base without the burden of a planet's gravity well. They are rich in volatile materials (more so than main belt asteroids), close enough to the Sun to harvest solar power, and far enough out that visits by those of us living in the inner Solar System would be few and far between. Moreover, the orbits of KBOs are relatively unaffected by planetary perturbations. Matloff was intrigued enough by these factors to make a proposed infrared search of the Kuiper Belt the subject of a 2004 paper ("A Proposed Infrared Search for Artificial Kuiper Belt Objects," JBIS 57, pp. 283-287). His new paper follows this up with an examination of the characteristics that artificial KBOs...
Recent Water on the Martian Surface?
It's hard to imagine water lasting for long on today's Martian surface. But a team at NASA's Ames Research Center has been studying gully sites that seem to indicate water outflows from what could be a subsurface aquifer. Indeed, the team's computer simulations show that if liquid water did emerge from underground, it could create gullies about 500 meters long. "Our model indicates that these fluvially-carved gullies were formed in the low temperature and low pressure conditions of present-day Mars by the action of relatively pure liquid water," said Jennifer Heldmann, principal author of the Ames study. Take a look at the photograph, which shows the channel and debris apron of recent Martian gullies. The scale of the bar in the photo is 1 kilometer. If we are looking at the work of recent surface water, then it surely existed in a challenging environment. Given the temperature and air pressure at the surface, exposed Martian water should either boil or freeze almost immediately. But...