Eight Planets It Is

So now we know what a planet is. As confirmed by the passage of a revised resolution at the International Astronomical Union's general assembly today in Prague, a planet meets the following criteria: It must be in orbit around a star It must possess sufficient mass to allow it to assume a round shape; i.e., it assumes hydrostatic equilibrium It is large enough that it has cleared the orbit through which it moves The third item, of course, is the interesting part, for it rules out Ceres, about which there had been some controversy. I mean, it was one thing to consider 2003 UB313 as a planet, but to delve into the middle of the Solar System and define a new planet in medias res seemed a stretch too far for some people (though not for me). Pluto is also ruled out because it moves for part of its orbit inside the orbit of Neptune; Charon likewise is left without planetary designation. What does happen to Pluto is that it becomes a 'dwarf planet,' a new kind of object that also includes...

read more

Galileo Weighs in On Planetary Definitions

Centauri Dreams continues to admire the clarity of the draft IAU resolution on the definition of a planet. Although the criteria are easily understood, they also present teaching opportunities (imagine all those schoolchildren learning what a barycenter is, and why Pluto/Charon make a double planet thanks to the location of their center of gravity!). This sound definition also grows from the properties of the planets themselves and is based on the best current information on planetary formation. Galileo Galilei had some thoughts on naming things that seem apropos, and what better source to consider when defining a planet? The Tuscan astronomer/mathematician (1564-1642) could have been speaking of the current controversy when he said, "Names and attributes must be accomodated to the essence of things, and not the essence to the names, for things come first and names afterward." I submit that the draft resolution does a fine job accomodating the named thing to its essence -- that...

read more

Pioneer and ‘The Long Result’

It was Tennyson whose narrator, recalling youthful wanderings and celestial vistas in the poem 'Locksley Hall,' wrote about 'the fairy tales of science, and the long result of Time.' That long result is something we seldom look at in our feverish and accelerated world, but in these closing paragraphs from a book written with Chesley Bonestell in 1972, Arthur C. Clarke thinks about the Pioneer spacecraft, the distant future and the things that may survive man. For the Pioneers will keep going. "As our space-faring powers develop, we may overtake them with the vehicles of a later age and bring them back to our museums, as relics of the early days before men ventured beyond Mars. And if we do not find them, others may. "We should therefore build them well, for one day they may be the only evidence that the human race ever existed. All the works of man on his own world are ephemeral, seen from the viewpoint of geological time. The winds and rains which have destroyed mountains will make...

read more

Night Thoughts on Human Expansion

One summer night last year I found myself at a dinner party that had stretched late into the evening. Enjoying a good Côtes du Rhône and watching distant lightning flickering through the trees outside, I hadn't been saying much until the subject came around to space. Suddenly I was challenged to justify the notion of exploring not just distant stellar systems but even the nearby planets. And before long I was talking about the need to develop technologies that could help us deflect a potential life-threatening asteroid. At which point one of the guests stopped me cold by saying, "Why should we deflect it? The human race has done little enough. What does it matter if we're all destroyed?" Try to talk someone out of that. It's early 21st Century weltschmzerz in its purest form, writing off all future generations because of a perceived sense of human failure. Not even half a bottle of Côtes du Rhône could take the edge off it. Reading a recent essay in Acta Astronautica by Giancarlo...

read more

Calculating the Distance to a Star

Centauri Dreams' fascination with the history of science occasionally yields to forgetfulness. Which is why this piece on German mathematician and astronomer Friedrich Wilhelm Bessel, runs two days after his birthday rather than on the occasion itself. Bessel (July 22, 1784 - March 17, 1846) would go on to perform remarkable work in the study of stellar distances that in many respects anticipated the work of today's exoplanet hunters. He became, in fact, the first person to predict the existence of an unseen companion around another star. That was quite an accomplishment in 1844, when Bessel announced the find around Sirius, based on minute deviations in the motion of the star. The discovery would be verified by Alvan Graham Clark in 1862 with the first observations of Sirius B. We now know that Sirius B orbits the primary at a distance of roughly 20 AU, not so far off the 23.7 AU mean separation between Centauri A and B, although there the resemblance stops -- Sirius B is a white...

read more

Exploration as Necessity

"The urge to explore, the quest of the part for the whole, has been the primary force in evolution since the first water creatures began to reconnoiter the land. We humans see this impulse as the drive to self-transcendence, the unfolding of self-awareness. The need to see the larger reality -- from the mountaintop, the moon, or the Archimedean points of science -- is the basic imperative of consciousness, the specialty of our species. If we insist that the human quest await the healing of every sore on the body politic, we condemn ourselves to stagnation. Living systems cannot remain static; they evolve or decline. They explore or expire. The inner experience of this imperative is curiosity and awe. The sense of wonder -- the need to find our place in the whole -- is not only the genesis of personal growth but the very mechanism of evolution, driving us to become more than we are. Exploration, evolution, and self-transcendence are but different perspectives on the same process." Wyn...

read more

Two Ways to Look at the Future

Stewart Brand is a leading proponent of long-term thinking, the sort of thing that builds cathedrals and, perhaps one day, starships. In this excerpt from his book The Clock of the Long Now (New York: Basic Books, 1999), Brand discusses science fiction and the various forms of futurism. According to Kevin Kelly, 'Isaac Asimov once said that science fiction was born when it became evident that our world was changing within our lifetimes, and therefore thinking abut the future became a matter of individual survival.' The nanotechnology futurist Eric Drexler concurs: 'I have found over the years that people familiar with the science fiction classics find it much easier to think about the future, coming technologies, political effects of those technologies, and so on.' At Global Business Network (GBN), the scenario-planning business that employs me, we frequently send out science fiction books to the Network membership, and when we can get writers such as William Gibson, Bruce Sterling,...

read more

On Starshades and Planetary Threats

The possibility of deflecting an incoming asteroid became more problematic in early July. That's when David Polishook and Noah Brosch (both of Tel Aviv University) presented evidence that the number of binary asteroids near the Earth might be much higher than originally thought. Binaries might, in fact, comprise more than fifty percent of all NEAs. Now we're talking about moving two objects instead of just one, an indication that asteroid-nudging is more tricky than we thought. The paper "Many binaries among NEAs," available here, was presented at NASA's Near-Earth Object Detection, Characterization, and Threat Mitigation workhop in Colorado. It's a reminder that the environment incessantly nudges technological civilizations to extend their capabilities. Jose Garcia recently commented here on a story about the New Worlds Imager 'starshade' concept, noting that experience with starshades could come in handy in future attempts to mitigate the effects of global warming by covering up...

read more

Interstellar Migration and the Human Experience

Centauri Dreams returns to its normal schedule on Monday, following a week devoted to the emergence of the Tau Zero Foundation. Next week will be a busy one, with a new and significant study of Proxima Centauri, a more detailed than ever look at the complicated happenings around Beta Pictoris, and a paper presenting a fast, beamed propulsion mission to Alpha Centauri serving as the highlights. Thanks to all who wrote asking for further information about the Tau Zero Foundation and its plans to support research practitioners in work that may one day lead to interstellar flight. I'll continue to follow Foundation news here as the group works towards the launch of its own Web site. It's heartening to see the spirit of exploration embraced by readers and advocated on the Net, as noted, for example, in this post on Brian Wang's Advanced Nanotechnology site. A snippet: If we had the will we would mount a D-Day scale invasion of space. The current space effort, as noble as it has been, was...

read more

Cryopreservation: The Slow Way to Centauri

Slowing down the biological clock is one way to get to the stars. And it's a leading trope of science fiction, this idea that if we can't find faster ways to travel beyond our Solar System, we can at least shorten the journey for the crew, who will wake up decades (or centuries) after departure in orbit around their destination. Cryopreservation is one approach to slowing the clock, but it's always been plagued by the problem of tissue damage. For although some kinds of tissues can be frozen and revived, others succumb to damage from ice crystals that destroy the delicate structure of the cells. New work at the University of Helsinki, however, offers a sudden gleam of hope on the cryopreservation front. There, researcher Anatoli Bogdan has been working with a form of water called 'glassy water,' and in particular a form of it known as low-density amorphous ice. It's produced by supercooling diluted aqueous droplets, and it melts into what is known as highly viscous water (HVW). Let's...

read more

Remembering Tom Corbett

Going to the stars is a matter of hard science, but it's also a question of inspiration. I know scientists who found their calling by reading Poul Anderson's novel Tau Zero, and others whose love of the early Star Trek forever changed their career path. But for some of us, growing up in the 1950s, it was Tom Corbett, Space Cadet that did the trick, and for me, it was a book by Carey Rockwell called Danger in Deep Space (New York: Grosset & Dunlap, 1953). The second in the Tom Corbett series, the book exposed this space-crazy kid to a planet orbiting one of the Alpha Centauri stars, and before long the thought of habitable worlds around stars other than our own became an obsession. Which brings us to Frankie Thomas, who died recently of respiratory failure at the age of 85. A workmanlike actor who appeared in a number of pre-WWII films and Broadway plays, Thomas took up radio and television work after leaving military service and was cast as Tom Corbett in 1950 (beating out a young...

read more

The Exploratory Imperative

Centauri Dreams often uses planetary peril as one good reason for expansion into the universe. As the human species spreads out onto multiple worlds, the chances of survival continue to increase even if our planet meets catastrophe in the form of a rogue asteroid or comet. But another good reason is the need for exploration that seems to be hard-wired into our nature, in which case interstellar expansion becomes more or less inevitable if we can solve the technological riddles it involves. Do humans really have an innate drive for exploration, and if so, how does it operate? References for the notion are numerous, but a new study out of University College London gives a highly analytical look at what may be going on. Nathaniel Daw and John O'Doherty argue that pushing into the unknown involves a different part of the brain than staying on familiar territory. By analyzing how the brain works while people gamble, they show that what exploration demands is an overriding of the desire...

read more

An Ancient Crater Bigger Than Chicxulub

A meteor impact greater than the one that killed the dinosaurs? That's the word from Antactica, where scientists working in the Wilkes Land region have found a crater twice the size of the Chicxulub crater in the Yucatan, which was likely the blow that led to the dinosaurs' demise some 65 million years ago. "This Wilkes Land impact is much bigger than the impact that killed the dinosaurs, and probably would have caused catastrophic damage at the time," said Ralph von Frese, a professor of geological sciences at Ohio State University. Finding such a crater beneath the frozen wastes of Antartica isn't an easy proposition, but tapping the GRACE satellites made the difference. GRACE stands for Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment; it's a duo of satellites sent into orbit in March of 2002, each flying about 220 kilometers apart in a polar orbit 500 kilometers high. The GRACE experiment maps Earth's gravity by taking measurements of the distance between the satellites using GPS and...

read more

Two Thoughts for the Weekend

"Advanced societies throughout the galaxy probably are in contact with one another, such contact being one of their chief interests. They have already probed the life histories of the stars and other of nature's secrets. The only novelty left would be to delve into the experience of others. What are the novels? What are the art histories? What are the anthropological problems of those distant stars? This is the kind of material that these remote philosophers have been chewing over for a long time..." -- Philip Morrison (1961) "Will we be able to understand the science of another civilization?... Our science has concentrated on asking certain questions at the expense of others, although this is so woven into the fabric of our knowledge that we are generally unaware of it. In another world, the basic questions may have been asked differently." -- J. Robert Oppenheimer (1962)

read more

Thoughts on the NASA Budget

The recently released NASA budget has researchers shaking their heads and Centauri Dreams readers writing to check on the status of some of the programs we've highlighted here. The news is indeed bleak -- at least temporarily so -- and what is particularly grating is the decision to cut numerous worthwhile projects in NASA's strongest areas while funding a whopping 17 additional Shuttle flights. That these moves are counterproductive should be obvious to anyone who has just lived through the years of Cassini, Huygens, Stardust, Spirit, Opportunity, Deep Impact... The list could go on. The success of the robotic exploration of the Solar System (now pushing into the interstellar regions beyond) has been outstanding, but in terms of public relations it seems dwarfed by a manned program that is now directed at entirely questionable goals. The fact that the egregiously out-of-date Space Shuttle continues to leach funds from proven robotic technologies makes the disparity all the more...

read more

Speaking Across Time and Space

Science writer Larry Klaes wrote last November with a thought about New Horizons that I've been pondering ever since. Klaes was troubled to learn that the spacecraft -- just the fifth mission ever launched that will eventually leave the Solar System -- was carrying little that could communicate information about its makers. Its major relic was a CD disc with signatures collected from those who signed up at a Web site, along with an image of the mission team. Klaes added that the CD would itself would be rendered unreadable within decades or, at most, a few centuries. Noting that the European Space Agency had included samples of 1000 human languages on its Rosetta comet probe, Klaes went on to say, "I think this is why an independent committee should be formed working with NASA and any other space agency that plans to launch probes into interstellar space to create messages/info carriers for those future vessels. This may help to avoid giving the mission teams any extra issues beyond...

read more

A Wish for New Horizons

Yesterday's brief and unplanned exercise in 'liveblogging' was caused by an odd discovery: the only way for this observer to track the New Horizons launch was through the Internet. With over 200 channels available through cable television, I found that channel surfing through all of them yielded not one with live NASA coverage. Now ponder this. Centauri Dreams is based near North Carolina's Research Triangle Park, with three major universities within easy driving distance. The woods are full of PhDs, the area priding itself on high tech. With all these resources, there was not a single cable channel that could be devoted to the first mission to Pluto/Charon ever launched. You can imagine what kind of fare was available on many of the channels that were available. Around the same time, I also noted the slowdown in NASA servers as the launch progressed and received e-mails from people who were having trouble accessing NASA TV. Thus the attempt to post updates on the launch holds...

read more

Of Missions and Deep Time

The successful return of the Stardust samples offers a chance to study cometary materials up close, surely deepening our understanding of the origins of the Solar System. But it also serves as a reminder of the time frames in which deep space missions must be flown. At that, Stardust has been a relatively swift mission, traveling some 2.88 billion miles in a seven-year journey. But ten years of planning also went into that journey, and design work goes back over 20 years. Thus Don Brownlee's comment on the mission's origin. "I have been waiting for this day since the early 1980s when Deputy Principal Investigator Dr. Peter Tsou of JPL and I designed a mission to collect comet dust," said Dr. Brownlee. "To see the capsule safely back on its home planet is a thrilling accomplishment." As well it must be, for Brownlee (University of Washington, Seattle) is principal investigator for the entire Stardust mission. Now thoughts turn to New Horizons, just over a day from launch. Scheduled to...

read more

Hyperspace in Science Fiction

With hyperspace suddenly in the news, here are some thoughts on how taking a shortcut to reach the stars has appeared in science fiction. They're from The Science in Science Fiction, edited by Peter Nicholls (London: Book Club Associates, 1982), p. 72: "Hyperspace is the science fictional name for the 'other space' used in such short cuts. The word was invented by John W. Campbell for his short story "The Mightiest Machine" (1934) and unashamedly stolen by hundreds of writers since. Today, hyperspace is part of science fiction's standard furniture -- solving all those awkward problems of travel to the stars... "[One] view of hyperspace is as a 'universe next door' much smaller than our own, with every point in hyperspace corresponding to one in this universe. Mathematicians call this a 'one-to-one' mapping. So hyperspace behaves like a little map of our own universe, a map which can be visited -- as though we could step from London to the point marked 'London' on the map, walk a...

read more

The Art of the Wormhole

Last week Centauri Dreams discussed the possible signature of a wormhole in astronomical data, as worked out in a 1994 paper titled "Natural Wormholes as Gravitational Lenses." A wormhole moving between Earth and another star would show an odd but identifiable form of lensing — two spikes of light with a dip in the middle. But what would a wormhole look like if you could actually see it? Space artist Jon Lomberg had some thoughts on that and shared them in the following e-mail. The wormhole entry was fascinating. I had the opportunity to try to visualize how a wormhole would look during the production of the film CONTACT. For the novel on which the film was based, Carl Sagan had asked Kip Thorne [Feynman Professor of Theoretical Physics at CalTech, and author of Black Holes and Time Warps: Einstein's Outrageous Legacy] for guidance to keep the wormhole as scientifically plausible as possible. During the film's production, I consulted with Kip to determine the appearance of a...

read more

Charter

In Centauri Dreams, Paul Gilster looks at peer-reviewed research on deep space exploration, with an eye toward interstellar possibilities. For many years this site coordinated its efforts with the Tau Zero Foundation. It now serves as an independent forum for deep space news and ideas. In the logo above, the leftmost star is Alpha Centauri, a triple system closer than any other star, and a primary target for early interstellar probes. To its right is Beta Centauri (not a part of the Alpha Centauri system), with Beta, Gamma, Delta and Epsilon Crucis, stars in the Southern Cross, visible at the far right (image courtesy of Marco Lorenzi).

Now Reading

Recent Posts

On Comments

If you'd like to submit a comment for possible publication on Centauri Dreams, I will be glad to consider it. The primary criterion is that comments contribute meaningfully to the debate. Among other criteria for selection: Comments must be on topic, directly related to the post in question, must use appropriate language, and must not be abusive to others. Civility counts. In addition, a valid email address is required for a comment to be considered. Centauri Dreams is emphatically not a soapbox for political or religious views submitted by individuals or organizations. A long form of the policy can be viewed on the Administrative page. The short form is this: If your comment is not on topic and respectful to others, I'm probably not going to run it.

Follow with RSS or E-Mail

RSS
Follow by Email

Follow by E-Mail

Get new posts by email:

Advanced Propulsion Research

Beginning and End

Archives