Columbus or Erikson?

by Gregory Benford (Centauri Dreams note: Gregory Benford was kind enough to send along the following, which is the text of a speech he delivered at the Advanced Space Propulsion Conference in Aosta, Italy last June. A modified version of this talk is to appear shortly in the Journal of the British Interplanetary Society. Dr. Benford's extraordinary career as physicist and science fiction author needs no introduction here, but Centauri Dreams readers are also urged to have a look at his new Benford & Rose Web site, written in collaboration with UC-Irvine professor of ecology and evolutionary biology Michael R. Rose. Herewith Dr. Benford's thoughts on space exploration as human imperative). There are three forms of chimpanzees: the common chimp, the bonobo, and us. We are the only chimp who got out of Africa. That experience reflects and probably laid down the deep human urge—indeed, our signature: the urge to restlessly move on, explore, exploit. Natural selection gives us a...

read more

The Aesthetics of Extraterrestrial Contact

Jon Lomberg has a distinction of which few humans can boast -- he knows his art will last. As the designer of the cover of the Voyager Interstellar Record, Lomberg created an aesthetic statement that could, in fact, last for a thousand million years. As could the entire sequence of 120 photographs and diagrams that he designed for the Voyager record. And just to show that his interest in deep time isn't purely space-related, Lomberg also designed a 10,000 year nuclear waste marker for the US Department of Energy. Centauri Dreams appreciates all instances of genuinely long-term thinking, but particularly celebrates the marriage of art with technology in time-frames longer than our civilization. It seems fitting, then, that when Lomberg turns to SETI issues, he would bring an artist's eye to the proceedings, which is what he does in an article written with Guillermo Lemarchand (Centro de Estudios Avanzados, Universidad de Buenos Aires). The essay, called "SETI and Aesthetics" and...

read more

Robert Goddard on Interstellar Migration

"A manuscript I wrote on January 14, 1918 ... and deposited in a friend's safe ... speculated as to the last migration of the human race, as consisting of a number of expeditions sent out into the regions of thickly distributed stars, taking in a condensed form all the knowledge of the race, using either atomic energy or hydrogen, oxygen and solar energy... [It] was contained in an inner envelope which suggested that the writing inside should be read only by an optimist." -- Robert Goddard, "Material for an Autobiography," (1927), available in Pendray, G. E. and Goddard, E. C. (Eds.), The Papers of Robert H. Goddard (New York: McGraw Hill, 1970).

read more

On the Evolution of Science Fiction

Is science fiction a predictive medium, or is it, as I have opined before in Centauri Dreams, a diagnostic form of writing, telling us more about the times we live in than any purported future it describes? The question is occasioned by SF writer and scholar James Gunn, whose essay "Tales from Tomorrow," available online and in the August/September issue of Science & Spirit, synopsizes the evolution of science fiction from Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley's attempt to "...unfold to the world the deepest mysteries of creation" to recent work like Greg Egan's Permutation City, where the mysteries of uploading human personalities into computers take center stage. Here Gunn discusses the development of the genre in the early magazines, as edited by Hugo Gernsback and the legendary John Campbell: While there were few science fiction books to speak of until 1946, what evolved through magazines like Gernsback's was a literature of ideas and, more important, a literature of change and...

read more

On Expansion into the Galaxy

How much do human cultures change over cosmically tiny time frames? Specifically, how alien would we find the Sumerian outlook on life if we could immerse ourselves in it today? How foreign would the world of pre-Columbian America appear to our touchy 21st Century ethics? Would we be comfortable, or capable of, adopting the cultural imperatives of either? Now extend the question. Is it possible even within time frames of a few thousand years to imagine civilizations that are both stable over time while maintaining social goals like exploration and continual expansion? If the answer is questionable -- and it is -- then we can look at the Enrico Fermi paradox in another light. Perhaps the reason we haven't found evidence of other technologies in our galaxy is that, while they are there, they are not expansionist over the periods of time needed to make themselves known to us. Such are the musings of German physicist Claudius Gros (University of the Saarland), as developed in a recent...

read more

A Novel Solution to Fermi’s Paradox

Enrico Fermi's famous question "Where are they?" continues to resonate among scientists and laymen alike. After all, shouldn't the universe be teeming with life, and hasn't intelligent life had enough time to spread through our own galaxy? Some estimates put the average age of Earth-like planets in the Milky Way at 6.4 billion years, whereas our own Earth is 4.5 billion years old. Some biospheres, in other words, may have had a two billion year jump on us. Shouldn't we be seeing signs of extraterrestrial life? One intriguing solution to the Fermi paradox appears in Karl Schroeder's novel Permanence (New York: Tor Books, 2002). Using a hypothesis from evolutionary biology called 'adaptationism,' Schroeder's protagonist argues that consciousness is not necessarily required for toolmaking. "In fact, consciousness appears to be a phase. No species we have studied has retained what we could call self-awareness for its entire history. Certainly none has evolved into some state above...

read more

A Theory of Interstellar Migration

A continuing preoccupation at Centauri Dreams is long-term thinking. What can we as a species do to extend our time-frame beyond the infuriating short-term outlook of today, so that we can start thinking realistically about shaping a future beyond our own lifetimes? This kind of thinking will be necessary when we build our first interstellar probes, traveling journeys that will surely take decades and may involve centuries. What will drive us to think and plan within the millennial time frames that would allow humans to expand into and throughout the galaxy? Novelist Stephen Baxter addresses this question in a recent paper in the Journal of the British Interplanetary Society. Baxter points out the enormity of the time challenge: Voyager 1, the fastest human object ever built, travels at some 17.3 kilometers per second. It would reach Alpha Centauri (if headed in that direction) in 73,000 years. But starships that can reach 0.1c are not beyond possibility. If we can develop them, it's...

read more

Remembering ‘Gateway to Strangeness’

One of the earliest appearances of solar sails in the American science fiction magazines was Jack Vance's "Gateway to Strangeness." Appearing in the August, 1962 issue of Amazing Stories (two years after Cordwainer Smith's solar sail story, "The Lady Who Sailed the Soul," ran in Galaxy), the oddly named tale is actually an account of a young crew being put through its training aboard a solar sail-powered spacecraft. Invariably, they run into trouble, and are forced to find a way out of their life-threatening dilemma by the hard-as-nails Henry Belt, a space veteran who just might be on his last mission. The story later appeared with a title more suited to its content -- "Sail 25" -- in Vance's Dust of Far Suns (1964) and in a number of later anthologies, including The Best of Jack Vance (1976). Here's a snippet, recounting the crew's work in getting their ship ready for its mission by setting up and securing the huge sail: "Around the hull swung the gleaming hoop, and now the carrier...

read more

Astrodynamics at Princeton

Ed Belbruno did a terrific job putting together the New Trends in Astrodynamics and Applications II conference, from which I returned yesterday. I chose to drive to Princeton because of my growing aversion to airline travel. It was a long but generally uneventful drive except for the usual delays around Washington DC -- over an hour to clear the Beltway because of construction on one of the access ramps. But driving through western New Jersey is, as anyone who has done it knows, a pleasant experience, beautiful farmlands giving way to small villages here and there, with Princeton itself an oasis of lovely architecture, fine restaurants and, of course, a great university. About the only thing that didn't cooperate was the weather -- we had a chill rain for the first two days -- but Peyton Hall is about half a mile from the Nassau Inn, Princeton's fine colonial-era hostelry, and it was an energizing walk even with umbrella. The conference sessions were intense; we generally ran from...

read more

On ‘Central Projects’ for a Civilization

"The space program stands with the cathedrals and pyramids as one of the great 'central projects' of history, epic social feats embodying the worldview of a culture and the spirit of an age. On the launch pads, the rockets point heavenward like Gothic spires. Searchlights intersect on a waiting ship to form a great candescent pyramid, ablaze on the black horizon like some alien encounter, radiating light to the heavens. To reach for the heavens seems almost the signature of the central project. The pyramid was called the 'stairway to heaven,' the cathedral the 'gate of heaven.' The archetype is in Genesis: 'let us build us a city and a tower, whose top may reach unto heaven.' "Literature on the pyramids, cathedrals and moon shots has tended to miss the significance not only of great height as the signal feature of central projects, but also their function as means through which whole cultures have found symbolic expression. Writers often pay lip service to the official rationales --...

read more

Space Technology Viewing Itself

Sometimes the fuzziest image carries a sense of awe that later, far more detailed photographs do not quite convey. Such were the early photographs from the Palomar Observatory showing planetary images that forever fixed in my mind the dream of seeing these places up close; even Cassini's extraordinary views can't eclipse the memory of Palomar's Saturn as seen through a boy's eyes forty-five years ago. And it may be that the image below carries a bit of the same awe. Fuzzy it may be, but you're looking at an image of the Mars Odyssey spacecraft as seen by another craft, the Mars Global Surveyor using its Mars Orbiter Camera. This and another Mars Orbiter Camera image, that one of the European Space Agency's Mars Express spacecraft, mark the first time a spacecraft in orbit around another planet has taken pictures of another spacecraft orbiting that planet. You can compare the actual image of Mars Odyssey with the computer-generated view of the spacecraft below to interpret what you're...

read more

Why SETI Matters

"MacDonald paused outside the long, low concrete building which housed the offices and laboratories and computers. It was twilight. The sun had descended below the green hills, but orange and purpling wisps of cirrus trailed down the western sky. "Between MacDonald and the sky was a giant dish held aloft by skeleton metal fingers -- held high as if to catch the stardust that drifted down at night from the Milky Way. Go and catch a falling star, Get with child a mandrake root, Tell me where all past years are, Or who cleft the Devil's foot; Teach me to hear mermaids singing, Or to keep off envy's stinging, And find What wind Serves to advance an honest mind. "Then the dish began to turn, noiselessly, incredibly, and to tip. And it was not a dish any more but an ear, a listening ear cupped by the surrounding hills to overhear the whispering universe. "Perhaps this was what kept them at their jobs, MacDonald thought. In spite of all disappointments, in spite of all vain efforts, perhaps...

read more

Remembering ‘Proxima Centauri’

The possible asteroid belt around the star HD69830, covered here in a recent entry, caused several days of pondering and a scouring of the Centauri Dreams library. This exoplanetary belt seems to be 25 times as dense as our own, and as close to its parent star as the orbit of Venus is to ours. That would make for an unforgettable celestial display every night, a belt of light cutting across the sky. The idea of a 'ringed star' finally drew forth the memory: an old Murray Leinster story called "Proxima Centauri." Published in the March 1935 issue of Astounding Stories (an issue in which future Astounding editor John Campbell would have two stories, one of them under his pseudonym Don A. Stuart), "Proxima Centauri" tells the story of the Adastra, a vast starship a mile in diameter as it makes the first interstellar crossing. Ahead in the viewfinders, Proxima Centauri reveals itself to be surrounded by a glowing ring that comes into view long before the planets in the Proxima system....

read more

Tuning Up Terrestrial Planet Finder

We've recently discussed habitable zones, normally defined as the area around a star where liquid water can exist on the surface. Thoughts on just how far the habitable zone around our own star extends vary, but the Carnegie Institution's Maggie Turnbull pegs it at between .7 AU and 1.5 AU. To adjust the notion of habitable zone to other stars, Turnbull says, the same relationship can be scaled as the square root of the luminosity of the star. Turnbull thinks about such things because she has created a database of stars that could have terrestial-type planets around them. This is clearly of significance to future missions like Terrestrial Planet Finder and makes me wish I had been able to attend the NASA Forum for Astrobiology Research in March, where Turnbull gave a talk called "Remote Sensing of Life and Habitable Worlds: Habstars, Earthshine and TPF." The next best thing is an edited transcript of the lecture in Astrobiology Magazine, which is running it in a series of four parts...

read more

Voyager and the Benefits of ‘Slow Science’

The Washington Post takes note of the possible suspension of funding for the two Voyager spacecraft in a story by Rick Weiss called Our Incredible Shrinking Curiosity. As discussed here in a previous entry, NASA is eying the Voyager budget of $4.2 million per year as it ponders cutbacks. Such news, says Weiss, leaves him "...depressingly convinced that these 8 billion-mile-long extensions of human curiosity are indeed now smarter, or at least more enlightened, than the mortals who made them." In Weiss' view, "...the U.S. scientific enterprise is riddled with evidence that Americans have lost sight of the value of non-applied, curiosity-driven research -- the open-ended sort of exploration that doesn't know exactly where it's going but so often leads to big payoffs." But is it a lack of curiosity that motivates such cuts, or something more temporal? Isn't the real culprit our inability to think in the longer time frames required of what Stewart Brand calls 'slow science'? The Voyagers...

read more

Out onto the Wine-Dark Sea

"From time to time, alarm has been expressed at the danger of a 'sensory deprivation' in space. Astronauts on long journeys, it has been suggested, will suffer the symptoms that afflict men who are cut off from their environment by being shut up in darkened, soundproofed rooms. "I would reverse this argument: our culture will suffer from sensory deprivation if it does not go into space. There is striking evidence of this in what has already happened to the astronomers and physicists. As soon as they were able to rise above the atmosphere, a new and often surprising universe was opened up to them, far richer and more complex than had ever been suspected from ground observations. Even the most enthusiastic proponents of space research never imagined just how valuable satellites would actually turn out to be, and there is a profound symbolism in this. "But the facts and statistics of science, priceless as they are, tell only a part of the story. Across the seas of space lie the new raw...

read more

Speaking Up to Hans Bethe: An Appreciation

The death of Hans Bethe has been covered by the media worldwide, and William J. Broad's obituary in the New York Times seems among the most thorough and accurate of the accounts of his life. But to me, Bethe will always be seen through Richard Feynman's eyes, and I think Broad misses the point of the one Feynman anecdote he tells. Feynman first worked with Bethe at Los Alamos during the days of the Manhattan Project, and he recalls the physicist's openness to debate, and his focus on the issue at hand rather than personality. Here, Feynman has just arrived in Los Alamos, and work had just begun, as told in the wonderful Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman! (New York: W.W. Norton, 1984): "Every day I would study and read, study and read. It was a very hectic time. But I had some luck. All the big shots except for Hans Bethe happened to be away at the time, and what Bethe needed was someone to talk to, to push his ideas against. Well, he comes in to this little squirt in an office and...

read more

In Search of the Mad Rocketeer

It seems fitting that the crater named Parsons is on the Moon's dark side. It's named after John W. Parsons, a youthful rocket builder who joined Texan Frank Malina in the early experiments that would lead to the creation of the Jet Propulsion Laboratory. Parsons, Malina and a childhood friend named Ed Forman patched together equipment from junkyards and at one point tried to script a movie about going to the Moon, hoping that selling it to Hollywood would fund their idea of launching a rocket to Earth's upper atmosphere. The three formed the Rocket Research Group at the Guggenheim Aeronautical Laboratory at Caltech, where Theodore von Kármán, the Laboratory's director, gave them lab space and campus equipment to pursue their dreams. This was back in the 1930's, when the group's rocket motors were being tested at the Arroyo Seco near Pasadena. Around that time, Chinese graduate student Tsien Hsue-shen (who would go on to become the father of Chinese rocketry) joined the team,...

read more

Kurt Gödel and the Spacetime Continuum

Be aware of Time Bandits, an article by Jim Holt in the March 2 New Yorker, which studies the relationship between Albert Einstein and mathematician Kurt Gödel, now best known for his incompleteness theorems. The first of these, as Holt writes, "...demonstrates that no logical system can capture all the truths of mathematics." Here's a sample from this fascinating piece, discussing what happened when Gödel took on the relationship of space and time: What Gödel found was the possibility of a hitherto unimaginable kind of universe. The equations of general relativity can be solved in a variety of ways. Each solution is, in effect, a model of how the universe might be. Einstein, who believed on philosophical grounds that the universe was eternal and unchanging, had tinkered with his equations so that they would yield such a model—a move he later called "my greatest blunder." Another physicist (a Jesuit priest, as it happens) found a solution corresponding to an expanding universe...

read more

On Deep Space and the Imagination

How do we create our image of other worlds? The obvious answer -- through instrumentation on space probes -- is inadequate, because the raw data sent back by our spacecraft has to be assembled into the final images we see. Consider Hubble, which uses filters recording different wavelengths of light, and then combines them to create the image. Nor do we need confine ourselves to visible light, since we also get images in the infrared, and views filtered in whatever way will maximize science, like some of Cassini's radar images of Titan. Instead of just seeing an image, we assemble it. What you would see if you were actually there, in other words, isn't necessarily what you get. I notice that Elizabeth Kessler, a doctoral student in the University of Chicago's Committee on the History of Culture, has presented her work on Hubble and artistry at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science in Washington. The title of her talk, "Hubble's Vision: Imaging,...

read more

Charter

In Centauri Dreams, Paul Gilster looks at peer-reviewed research on deep space exploration, with an eye toward interstellar possibilities. For many years this site coordinated its efforts with the Tau Zero Foundation. It now serves as an independent forum for deep space news and ideas. In the logo above, the leftmost star is Alpha Centauri, a triple system closer than any other star, and a primary target for early interstellar probes. To its right is Beta Centauri (not a part of the Alpha Centauri system), with Beta, Gamma, Delta and Epsilon Crucis, stars in the Southern Cross, visible at the far right (image courtesy of Marco Lorenzi).

Now Reading

Recent Posts

On Comments

If you'd like to submit a comment for possible publication on Centauri Dreams, I will be glad to consider it. The primary criterion is that comments contribute meaningfully to the debate. Among other criteria for selection: Comments must be on topic, directly related to the post in question, must use appropriate language, and must not be abusive to others. Civility counts. In addition, a valid email address is required for a comment to be considered. Centauri Dreams is emphatically not a soapbox for political or religious views submitted by individuals or organizations. A long form of the policy can be viewed on the Administrative page. The short form is this: If your comment is not on topic and respectful to others, I'm probably not going to run it.

Follow with RSS or E-Mail

RSS
Follow by Email

Follow by E-Mail

Get new posts by email:

Advanced Propulsion Research

Beginning and End

Archives